I do believe that the reason I ranked Episode 1 and 2 so low was that I already watched someone else play it before buying the season pass and playing it for myself. I already knew what was gonna happen the first 2 episodes, but the 3 remaining episodes were brand new experiences.
"Oh... This is when they find Mark..."
So pretty much Episodes 1 and 2 didn't stand out as much to me in the end.
The Walking Dead (Of course
Ace Attorney Series + Investigations
999: 9 hours 9 persons 9 doors
Zero Escape: Virtue's Last Reward
Mass Effect Series
... Pretty much anything story driven