Telltale Games

Isaac Goodluck · 09/06/2009, 04:30 am

guybrush crew from curse of monkey island are the best characters in the series, please let them be in tales of monkey island

Kroms · 09/06/2009, 04:35 am

Only if they're part of and contribute to the story. I doubt it'll happen, though.

Spadge · 09/06/2009, 04:44 am

It doesn't really matter who they bring back as long as it's not Murray or Stan. I'm sick of seeing those two guys in every game.

Bagge · 09/06/2009, 05:43 am

If they're bringing back a trio, I'd rather see the men of low morale fibre make a cameo.

jannar85 · 09/06/2009, 05:49 am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Spadge

It doesn't really matter who they bring back as long as it's not Murray or Stan. I'm sick of seeing those two guys in every game.

Murray was first introduced in CMI, so he's not been there all the way.

Stan, as annoying as he is, I kind of enjoy him. And Murray is awesome.

Back to the topic, I don't think the trio would make any appearance. Maybe one of them, but everyone? Nah. They came and they went.

Fealiks · 09/06/2009, 05:54 am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Spadge

It doesn't really matter who they bring back as long as it's not Murray or Stan. I'm sick of seeing those two guys in every game.

Murray's been confirmed already. I love him though, so it's all cool.

Kroms · 09/06/2009, 06:13 am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Spadge

It doesn't really matter who they bring back as long as it's not Murray or Stan. I'm sick of seeing those two guys in every game.

And if they contributed to the story? If they were actually a part of it?

(Well, Stan not so much. He's always an element in some larger puzzle, never part of the story.)

darknessofheart · 09/06/2009, 06:23 am

Bringing back old characters really won't make the game any better. I think this game is great and one of the reasons may be that their have been no old faces savior the main characters. It has to be part of a story and I don't see those three fitting in anywhere that could be a pivotal part of the story. I just want a great story, not littered fan service.

Farlander · 09/06/2009, 06:37 am

Quote:

And if they contributed to the story? If they were actually a part of it?

No. It's usually a bad idea to bring someone back when there's no reason too (and so far ToMI story doesn't show at least a single reason to bring the trio back), especially on fans' demand. It's not the matter of contribution to the story, but of the story's logic.

Stan kinda became a running gag in the games, just as "I'm selling these fine leather jackets" and things like that, something that's in every MI game, so I don't really have anything against him (and with him it doesn't really matter how, where, or why he started some new business, he was making laminated business cards in a coffin, for crying out loud). More than that, I will be surprised (though not frustrated) if he will be left out of the game. But I doubt barber trio would do any good. Heck, I'm not even sure that Murray would be in his place (and, let's face it, although I did enjoy EfMI pretty much, and loved dialoge with Murray in that game, he WAS out of place there. Heck, he was out of place in the second half of CMI). So, it's kinda a hard thing to think about, actually...

I WOULD like to see Herman Toothrot/H.T. Marley and Marley Family Lawyers in Trial and Execution of Guybrush Threepwood, though. I mean, H.T. being Elaine's grandfather and Guybrush being a part of Marley family, it would be logical for them to appear. Besides, the Lawyers have yet unopened potential (while barbers don't really have much of it left, considering how much time we've spent with them and little with those lawyers), and I love their music theme from EfMI.

Planeforger · 09/06/2009, 06:43 am

Telltale games have been making some great characters for Tales of Monkey Island. With all of these 'Make a Morgan Leflay spin-off game' and Winslow appreciation threads, I don't think they really need to resort to bringing back a whole lot of older characters.

Looking back at the older games, the only characters who are in multiple games are the core characters (Guybrush, Elaine, LeChuck) and a few other secondary ones (Voodoo Lady, Stan, Herman...maybe even Wally, Murray and the SOMI crew, if they count).
So the majority of characters that you meet in Monkey Island games are new and interesting - I don't see why Tales should be any different.

petethepanda · 09/06/2009, 07:08 am

I'd love to see a cameo by the barber trio (or especially from the men of low moral fiber), but not as main characters.

Sir Pantalones · 09/06/2009, 08:06 am

A visual cameo?

If not, there are references to two of them in chapter 1. If you show the Morgan LeFlay leaflet to Nipperkin, he says that some say he's a red-bearded giant, and some a peg-legged midget.
Might not be a reference to them, but to put two members from the same crew into the same sentence like that...

Spadge · 09/06/2009, 09:11 am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Farlander

... I WOULD like to see Herman Toothrot/H.T. Marley and Marley Family Lawyers in Trial and Execution of Guybrush Threepwood, though. I mean, H.T. being Elaine's grandfather and Guybrush being a part of Marley family, it would be logical for them to appear. Besides, the Lawyers have yet unopened potential (while barbers don't really have much of it left, considering how much time we've spent with them and little with those lawyers), and I love their music theme from EfMI.

I'd love to see Marley's Lawyers. It just makes so much sense for them to be on the trial. Plus the three of them use pretty much the same model. :P

tbm1986 · 09/06/2009, 09:23 am

I might be wrong on this but TT might only have a licence to reuse main and repeated secondary characters (which would allow Murray and others like Stan and Herman Toothrot to be in the game).

Someone in another thread had the brilliant idea of using Stan for Guybrush's defence. He's the only one I see being incompentent enough to lose the case without losing face (much like Lionel Hutz in the Simpsons).

Astro Gnocci · 09/06/2009, 09:26 am

Quote:

Someone in another thread had the brilliant idea of using Stan for Guybrush's defence. He's the only one I see being incompentent enough to lose the case without losing face (much like Lionel Hutz in the Simpsons).

I agree, that would be some pretty cool twist on the character

Spadge · 09/06/2009, 09:38 am

Quote:

Originally Posted by tbm1986

...Someone in another thread had the brilliant idea of using Stan for Guybrush's defence...

Hehe, I think it might have been me.

jortlaban · 09/06/2009, 01:17 pm

the barbershop trio... meh...

The men of low moral fiber on theother hand... what happened to them after MI2????

Farlander · 09/06/2009, 01:24 pm

Quote:

The men of low moral fiber on theother hand... what happened to them after MI2????

To be honest, I, personally, couldn't care less about them. It was fun to talk with them in MI1, meeting for the first time and such (plus rum and jam keg talk

), but in MI2... meh.

Ash735 · 09/06/2009, 01:53 pm

Unless we go back to Plunder Island, I don't want to see them again, loved them as the crew, plus they had some of the best music cues in Curse, the Barbershop theme, the banjo duel, the caber toss and Shipwrecked on Blood Island. But as they said, they wanted to return to Plunder Island to carry on with what they know best.

Slanzinger · 09/07/2009, 03:19 am

To be fair, they've already made their cameo. Not in appearance, of course, but in sound.

"A pirate I was meant to be..."

View Poll Results: Do you want the trio to appear in Tales of monkey island?
Yes	51	56.67%
No	39	43.33%
Voters: 90. You may not vote on this poll

09/06/2009, 04:30 am	#1
Isaac Goodluck Junior Member Join Date: Aug 2009 Posts: 9	Bring back the pirate-trio from Curse pleeease guybrush crew from curse of monkey island are the best characters in the series, please let them be in tales of monkey island

09/06/2009, 07:08 am	#11
petethepanda Man of Low Moral Fiber Join Date: Jul 2009 Location: Chicago, IL Posts: 85	I'd love to see a cameo by the barber trio (or especially from the men of low moral fiber), but not as main characters. __________________ "My true name is ‘Heart Lungs And Liver Boiled In The Stomach Of The Animal McMutton’." http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JH1F5Cfy6uQ

09/06/2009, 09:23 am	#14
tbm1986 Wannabe human Join Date: Jul 2009 Location: Guernsey, Channel Islands, Britain Posts: 1,603	I might be wrong on this but TT might only have a licence to reuse main and repeated secondary characters (which would allow Murray and others like Stan and Herman Toothrot to be in the game). Someone in another thread had the brilliant idea of using Stan for Guybrush's defence. He's the only one I see being incompentent enough to lose the case without losing face (much like Lionel Hutz in the Simpsons). __________________ Life is like an adventure game: if you don't click, you don't get it

09/06/2009, 01:17 pm	#17
jortlaban Monkey Island Hermit Join Date: Jun 2009 Location: Schiedam, the Netherlands Posts: 219	the barbershop trio... meh... The men of low moral fiber on theother hand... what happened to them after MI2???? __________________ Shareholder TWDC and EDASCA.. "Camera's everywhere, Obscure cartoon characters, Smell's like urine.... This just like Tokyo Disneyland" - Jun-Jee

09/06/2009, 04:35 am	#2
Kroms Knows Pi backwards. Join Date: Jun 2007 Posts: 774	Only if they're part of and contribute to the story. I doubt it'll happen, though.

09/06/2009, 04:44 am	#3
Spadge Not a Guru Join Date: Jul 2009 Location: Bulgaria Posts: 832	It doesn't really matter who they bring back as long as it's not Murray or Stan. I'm sick of seeing those two guys in every game.

09/06/2009, 05:43 am	#4
Bagge Senior Member Join Date: Nov 2006 Location: Oslo Posts: 603	If they're bringing back a trio, I'd rather see the men of low morale fibre make a cameo.

09/06/2009, 06:23 am	#8
darknessofheart Senior Member Join Date: Jun 2009 Location: Point A to Point B to Point C Posts: 436	Bringing back old characters really won't make the game any better. I think this game is great and one of the reasons may be that their have been no old faces savior the main characters. It has to be part of a story and I don't see those three fitting in anywhere that could be a pivotal part of the story. I just want a great story, not littered fan service.

09/06/2009, 06:43 am	#10
Planeforger Freelance Lagomorph Join Date: Jan 2007 Location: Melbourne, Australia Interesting Posts: 0 Posts: 290	Telltale games have been making some great characters for Tales of Monkey Island. With all of these 'Make a Morgan Leflay spin-off game' and Winslow appreciation threads, I don't think they really need to resort to bringing back a whole lot of older characters. Looking back at the older games, the only characters who are in multiple games are the core characters (Guybrush, Elaine, LeChuck) and a few other secondary ones (Voodoo Lady, Stan, Herman...maybe even Wally, Murray and the SOMI crew, if they count). So the majority of characters that you meet in Monkey Island games are new and interesting - I don't see why Tales should be any different.

09/06/2009, 08:06 am	#12
Sir Pantalones Senior Member Join Date: Jun 2009 Posts: 324	A visual cameo? If not, there are references to two of them in chapter 1. If you show the Morgan LeFlay leaflet to Nipperkin, he says that some say he's a red-bearded giant, and some a peg-legged midget. Might not be a reference to them, but to put two members from the same crew into the same sentence like that...

09/06/2009, 01:53 pm	#19
Ash735 Senior Member Join Date: Jun 2009 Location: Manchester, UK Posts: 1,149	Unless we go back to Plunder Island, I don't want to see them again, loved them as the crew, plus they had some of the best music cues in Curse, the Barbershop theme, the banjo duel, the caber toss and Shipwrecked on Blood Island. But as they said, they wanted to return to Plunder Island to carry on with what they know best.

09/07/2009, 03:19 am	#20
Slanzinger Really fearsome pirate Join Date: Jul 2009 Posts: 87	To be fair, they've already made their cameo. Not in appearance, of course, but in sound. "A pirate I was meant to be..."

Thread Tools	Search this Thread
Show Printable Version Email this Page	Search this Thread: Advanced Search

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
[B][/B]Bring back the 2D!	xkane	Tales of Monkey Island General Discussion	17	07/08/2009 11:02 am
Pirate music	Haggis	Tales of Monkey Island General Discussion	26	06/30/2009 02:32 pm
Bring back the case files	EeK	Sam & Max Series Discussion	34	02/02/2008 11:48 pm
Monkey Island! Bring It Back!	The Flash	General Chat	41	01/15/2008 02:28 am