Spoilers\ What was your decision on the two brothers?

[DREWBAA]

I killed them both.

When I finished the game it said only 12% of players killed them..

Were you guys asleep?? They killed and fed you a member of your own group and held the rest of you in a torture chamber and you let them live?!?!?!

I guess I am going to have to rock the impending apocalypse solo then.. weak.

[CapnJay]

In the impending Zombie Apocalypse I'm not teaching my Adopted Daughter that it's a dog eat dog world also we didn't loot the car either


Also it's more ruthless to leave andy to the Walkers

[Lara's Nemesis]

I killed the first brother but left the other one.


The reason was because Clementine saw the first one. The other guy was as good as dead anyway.

Found it quite funny when you see the zombie mother going down the lawn towards the 2nd guy.

[zenstrata]

Fool me once, shame on you. Fool me twice, shame on me.

Basically I am willing to give people one chance to prove their intentions. The family on the farm made their choice to cut mark up into pieces, and attempt to kill and eat lee, clementine, larry, and all the other survivors in your group eventually. I would say that more than justifies taking them out.

In some ways the children NEED to learn what the world is like and the proper way to handle things. It is a parents duty to teach their children to survive. If this means taking hard choices and teaching hard lessons, then so be it. The best you can do is try to explain the reasons behind your actions so the children understand why difficult choices need to be made. I explained to clementine that they were bad men and it had to be done. I would say that even a child could understand that after witnessing their other crimes.

[CapnJay]

In front of Clementine?

[Notthevictim]

Killed them both. I figured Clementine would be right there when I killed him, but I did it anyway. Hearing the second brother screaming when I told him his family was dead tore me up so I mercy killed him. It was pretty intense. I later told Clementine that I regretted my decision, and didn't loot the car, so I think I'm patching things up.

[CapnJay]

I didn't kill either brother they could have got out together but andy was focused on his cry to the heavens.

[DREWBAA]

Originally Posted by CapnJay

In the impending Zombie Apocalypse I'm not teaching my Adopted Daughter that it's a dog eat dog world also we didn't loot the car either


Also it's more ruthless to leave andy to the Walkers

I threw Andy into an electric fence.. look at Rick and Carl. It is a dog eat dog world. People are more dangerous than walkers.

[jaybreezy]

On my first play (I go with my gut instinct on the first play) I took them both out AND looted the car. I'm in the *do anything needed to survive* camp.

Oh yeah.. Also sided with Kenny on the Larry situation.

[ruairi46]

Stabbed one guy Shot the other. I don't take no shit. Im nice to clementine but im training her to be a survivalist, and do what ever is neccessary.

[zipp]

I tryed to be nice but it seemed like killing Larry was a good idea. Hes an ass hole and he was possibly dead. I also killed the 2 brothers because they were gonna kill us and top it off with having use for desert.

This was WAY more emotional than I thought this game would deliver. I literally almost cried...

I love you telltale. The wait was a little to long but loved the episode.

Anyone else kill Larry and the 2 brothers?

[iMuzzaa]

I killed Larry, it was a tough decision to make, but I thought, if he IS dead then we're screwed, and it's better to be safe than sorry.

I also only killed the first brother, I left the second for the zombies.

Yeah, I agree this was more emotional than the first episode, it left me with a sour taste in my mouth when I discovered they were harvesting humans.

[coryay113]

I'm playing Lee as if he is Rick. Anyone who fucks with Clem dies.

[ZacTB]

I didn't kill either, they were both screwed anyway.

[jessicamariedee]

Originally Posted by Notthevictim

Killed them both. I figured Clementine would be right there when I killed him, but I did it anyway. Hearing the second brother screaming when I told him his family was dead tore me up so I mercy killed him. It was pretty intense. I later told Clementine that I regretted my decision, and didn't loot the car, so I think I'm patching things up.

I had the same conversation with Clem after killing only Denny. I did leave Andy to make his own choice about his fate. Denny, I killed in a fit of rage and vengeance. Andy? With everyone watching... I dunno-- I just wanted to get everyone away from the farm and out of the chaos. Without the added peril of the missing characters and without coming off of the decision to save or kill Larry, killing Andy felt too premeditated for me.

I thought that the characters were all battered and broken by that point, and enough damage had been done. I felt more compelled to walk away.

I actually do not regret killing Denny, I regret only that Clementine saw it. I felt like I'd been punched in the stomach.

[Gennadios]

As Lee pointed out, these guys were mad, but they weren't exactly stupid. Killing both was a win/win

If they would have died to zombies, it's two less zombies to worry about.

If they would have survived I don't really need people like that seeking bloody vengance. Or preying on anyone else for that matter.

Would have done a double tap on the mother as well if the game would have let me.

[RMJ1984]

Originally Posted by DREWBAA

I killed them both.

When I finished the game it said only 12% of players killed them..

Were you guys asleep?? They killed and fed you a member of your own group and held the rest of you in a torture chamber and you let them live?!?!?!

I guess I am going to have to rock the impending apocalypse solo then.. weak.

Because if you kill him your doing what he wants.

Its better to leave him sufferinger. Thats basically what it comes down to.

Let the zombies eat him alive, see how he likes being eaten.

[Oomi]

I killed them both.

[Sergiy]

Didnt kill a single one, the first i had Lilly to cover my back, the second one, everyone was watching, and i felt horrible for shooting the woman earlier...

[donmike84]

first walkthrough killed one of the brothers the one that got traped in the bear trap i can't remember his name and walked away from the other one at the end and stole the food