Telltale Games

mz3 · 07/24/2012, 04:16 pm

I didnot kill them
zombies can do this works(you know)

Juicius Maximus · 07/24/2012, 07:54 pm

Me neither. They were both so pathetic and clearly fucked in the end that killing them seemed like a pointless and hollow act.

The_Jesus_12489 · 07/24/2012, 08:01 pm

the only thing hollow about that act was the holes from the pitch fork coming out of Andy's? Danny's? chest

SteveTheBox · 07/25/2012, 09:05 am

It makes an impact in the story, Lee killed a State Senator for sleeping with his wife, people may question who he is or why he's like this and may know that Lee is a murderer later on in the story, although I spared them both because of my own personality to be honest, it reveals the people who they really are, and i'm no killer at least unless it has to be done, probably like when Lee shot the bandit at the next episode trailer, but not what Kenny did to Larry that's for sure.

Galdis · 08/05/2012, 03:47 pm

Saying that the zombies did the work is an awful argument because the zombies do not get in until after you deal with the two brothers.

Why did you not kill them AT THE TIME?

goemon13 · 08/05/2012, 04:18 pm

I wanted to kill them but didn't because I knew Clem would be watching.

Gman5852 · 08/05/2012, 04:18 pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Galdis

Saying that the zombies did the work is an awful argument because the zombies do not get in until after you deal with the two brothers.

Why did you not kill them AT THE TIME?

You see the zombies coming in after the second brother I think, so you could use that as a decision for him

Master of Aeons · 08/05/2012, 09:51 pm

I did not kill them. It's not true! It's bullshit! I did not kill them! I did naht...!

Sisterofshane · 08/05/2012, 10:33 pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Galdis

Saying that the zombies did the work is an awful argument because the zombies do not get in until after you deal with the two brothers.

Why did you not kill them AT THE TIME?

The bandits were after them at the time, though. After Danny was dealt with, my immediate concern was not that he should die, but rather there were still members of our group who were in danger.

Fast forward to Andy - his mother is dead, and his brother is most likely dying in the barn from blood loss (in my playthrough he DID get stabbed twice with a sickle to the torso by the way). Killing him there is for revenge, not for safety.

Besides, I've argued this before. The danger posed by the St. John's was eliminated as soon as we discovered what they intended to do with us. Now that we know, they pose no threat. We are better armed (you discover this when you are investigating the farm and then talk to Kenny) if they decide to come after us.

LeeLee · 08/25/2012, 02:42 am

Hi, I'm talking about those son's a bitch brothers that slaughter people!
what would you like to do with them ?

some of you may decide to leave them alive ( for Celmentain ) but please
don't do that. they are such an as* and must die by a bad way

if you leave them alive they will continue their work and slaughter more people

why some of players leave them alive ? I just would to know

Sir Fruitcakes · 08/25/2012, 02:53 am

Quote:

Originally Posted by LeeLee

Hi, I'm talking about those son's a bitch brothers that slaughter people!
what would you like to do with them ?

some of you may decide to leave them alive ( for Celmentain ) but please
don't do that. they are such an as* and must die by a bad way

if you leave them alive they will continue their work and slaughter more people

why some of players leave them alive ? I just would to know

Because some don't want to make the other people of the group think of them as a monster, AND destroy clementines soul, and waste their time killing peoples who are already going to die, besides the cannibalism was mother st.johns idea I Assure you, not the sons, but if you need more reasons than that...they kept the zombies occupied while we slowly walked away dramatically.

Gudmoore · 08/25/2012, 03:23 am

Quote:

Originally Posted by LeeLee

Hi, I'm talking about those son's a bitch brothers that slaughter people!
what would you like to do with them ?

some of you may decide to leave them alive ( for Celmentain ) but please
don't do that. they are such an as* and must die by a bad way

if you leave them alive they will continue their work and slaughter more people

why some of players leave them alive ? I just would to know

This. This is why parents shouldn't buy this game for their 12 year old, they have such filthy mouths when online.

LeeLee · 08/25/2012, 03:51 am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sir Fruitcakes

Because some don't want to make the other people of the group think of them as a monster, AND destroy clementines soul, and waste their time killing peoples who are already going to die, besides the cannibalism was mother st.johns idea I Assure you, not the sons, but if you need more reasons than that...they kept the zombies occupied while we slowly walked away dramatically.

don't you like kill them just to make people thinks you are a good guy ?
If you don't kill them they could continue their work

Quote:

Originally Posted by Gudmoore

This. This is why parents shouldn't buy this game for their 12 year old, they have such filthy mouths when online.

Ok, but I'm 23 years old. don't judge people like that

Milosuperspesh · 08/25/2012, 04:47 am

it got merged..

i think too many people have blood lust..

Gman5852 · 08/25/2012, 04:55 am

Quote:

Originally Posted by LeeLee

Hi, I'm talking about those son's a bitch brothers that slaughter people!
what would you like to do with them ?

some of you may decide to leave them alive ( for Celmentain ) but please
don't do that. they are such an as* and must die by a bad way

if you leave them alive they will continue their work and slaughter more people

why some of players leave them alive ? I just would to know

Very simply. They die no matter what. Ever notice the walkers coming into the farm? Well one brother is stuck in a bear trap, and the other is so wrecked that he won't fight them. They actually die a slower AND more painful death if you spare them. That's why.

Drbg · 08/25/2012, 05:38 am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Gudmoore

This. This is why parents shouldn't buy this game for their 12 year old, they have such filthy mouths when online.

That was incredibly mean.
Oh and I killed both on my first play through.

Hudomonkey · 08/26/2012, 02:48 am

I spared them because...
1. Andy was stuck in a bear trap and was unlikely to survive (also Clem)
2. The second brother's Mum had just died and the brother would probably also die so he had probably suffered enough
3. I had turned of the generator of course the zombies would finish the job

Rock114 · 08/26/2012, 08:58 am

I find it hard to believe that Andy had the will to go on living after hearing his mother was dead and his nice little life of cannabalism had been destroyed. I also find it hard to believe that Danny could lug his insane butt somewhere safe with a bear trap dangling from his leg while simultaniously bleeding out from his multiple sickle wounds. We're probably not going to be seeing any of the St. Johns again, however the Save Lots bandits are still out there...

Truxus · 11/23/2012, 01:56 pm

Situations like these made me love this game
killing danny was a decision made in a spilt second
stab that son of a ...
Pucnhing andrew made me consider
it really did
i was ready to push the buttons(aka punch the crap out of him) but i hesitated..
That was one of these moments the game became one of a kind

PerttuLaulaa · 11/25/2012, 10:05 am

Killed Danny , spared Andrew. I don't know a real awnser why. Its just happens, may be i felt guilty or something.

08/25/2012, 02:42 am	#210
LeeLee Member Join Date: Aug 2012 Posts: 37	*Would you like to kill those ashole ?** Hi, I'm talking about those son's a bitch brothers that slaughter people! what would you like to do with them ? some of you may decide to leave them alive ( for Celmentain ) but please don't do that. they are such an as* and must die by a bad way if you leave them alive they will continue their work and slaughter more people why some of players leave them alive ? I just would to know

08/25/2012, 04:47 am	#214
Milosuperspesh V3.0 The shining Join Date: May 2011 Location: Wai soh Sirius ? Posts: 3,168	it got merged.. i think too many people have blood lust.. __________________ https://www.facebook.com/pages/KIQCS/311661538927832 I am Sir Milo of Smeg https://www.facebook.com/#!/SaveCarley My soul tastes like butterscotch pudding Mentored by Mr flibble Sorry the aloe vera ran out for those burns. Last edited by Milosuperspesh; 08/26/2012 at 05:01 am.

Thread Tools	Search this Thread
Show Printable Version Email this Page	Search this Thread: Advanced Search

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
A quick guide to the Fables Universe- SPOILERS EVERYWHERE	Eduardo	The Wolf Among Us Discussion	19	11/05/2012 11:42 am
Decision wrap up glitch (probably spoilers)	Undead Fiend	The Walking Dead Discussion	3	04/26/2012 09:21 am
About the title of Episode 4 - spoilers	pilouuuu	Tales of Monkey Island General Discussion	17	06/20/2010 10:38 pm
I always thought this would be interesting: Revenge plot point, Spoilers	metroidreborn	Tales of Monkey Island General Discussion	45	03/18/2010 11:02 pm
Spoilers (No not spoilers in the thread, it's a thread about spoilers)	Chris1	Tales of Monkey Island General Discussion	11	09/28/2009 11:03 am

07/24/2012, 04:16 pm	#201
mz3 stay close to me Join Date: Jul 2012 Location: bright falls Posts: 153	I didnot kill them zombies can do this works(you know)

07/24/2012, 07:54 pm	#202
Juicius Maximus Drooler Extraordinaire Join Date: Jun 2009 Posts: 348	Me neither. They were both so pathetic and clearly fucked in the end that killing them seemed like a pointless and hollow act.

07/24/2012, 08:01 pm	#203
The_Jesus_12489 Member Join Date: Jul 2012 Posts: 83	the only thing hollow about that act was the holes from the pitch fork coming out of Andy's? Danny's? chest

07/25/2012, 09:05 am	#204
SteveTheBox Junior Member Join Date: Jul 2012 Posts: 12	It makes an impact in the story, Lee killed a State Senator for sleeping with his wife, people may question who he is or why he's like this and may know that Lee is a murderer later on in the story, although I spared them both because of my own personality to be honest, it reveals the people who they really are, and i'm no killer at least unless it has to be done, probably like when Lee shot the bandit at the next episode trailer, but not what Kenny did to Larry that's for sure.

08/05/2012, 03:47 pm	#205
Galdis Member Join Date: Jul 2012 Posts: 97	Saying that the zombies did the work is an awful argument because the zombies do not get in until after you deal with the two brothers. Why did you not kill them AT THE TIME?

08/05/2012, 04:18 pm	#206
goemon13 Junior Member Join Date: Aug 2012 Posts: 1	I wanted to kill them but didn't because I knew Clem would be watching.

08/05/2012, 09:51 pm	#208
Master of Aeons Senior Member Join Date: Oct 2010 Posts: 1,684	I did not kill them. It's not true! It's bullshit! I did not kill them! I did naht...!

08/26/2012, 02:48 am	#217
Hudomonkey Senior Member Join Date: Aug 2012 Posts: 495	I spared them because... 1. Andy was stuck in a bear trap and was unlikely to survive (also Clem) 2. The second brother's Mum had just died and the brother would probably also die so he had probably suffered enough 3. I had turned of the generator of course the zombies would finish the job

08/26/2012, 08:58 am	#218
Rock114 Senior Member Join Date: Jul 2012 Location: U.S. of A. Posts: 1,711	I find it hard to believe that Andy had the will to go on living after hearing his mother was dead and his nice little life of cannabalism had been destroyed. I also find it hard to believe that Danny could lug his insane butt somewhere safe with a bear trap dangling from his leg while simultaniously bleeding out from his multiple sickle wounds. We're probably not going to be seeing any of the St. Johns again, however the Save Lots bandits are still out there...

11/23/2012, 01:56 pm	#219
Truxus Junior Member Join Date: Nov 2012 Posts: 2	Situations like these made me love this game killing danny was a decision made in a spilt second stab that son of a ... Pucnhing andrew made me consider it really did i was ready to push the buttons(aka punch the crap out of him) but i hesitated.. That was one of these moments the game became one of a kind

11/25/2012, 10:05 am	#220
PerttuLaulaa Junior Member Join Date: Jul 2012 Posts: 16	Killed Danny , spared Andrew. I don't know a real awnser why. Its just happens, may be i felt guilty or something.