Telltale Games

ZombieGoBoom · 08/27/2012, 08:04 pm

Sorry but I can't believe it will be Lilly, Duck or Kenny. It's just too obvious. It can't be Clem because she was so against stealing from that car. If someone is stealing from the group it has to hit home for Lee story-wise.

I think it has to be Doug/Carley that has been taking the food. In episode two, both Carley and Doug turned down when you offer them rations which I found remarkable. I really like Carley and it will bug me to no end if she's the one that has been stealing food but regardless it will be in the spirit of the TWD. I'm curious to see how such a situation plays out and how I will handle it... Probably not well.

ryannumber1gamer · 08/27/2012, 08:10 pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Milosuperspesh

My thoughts are larry despite being dead he could of been hording food for himself, of course if the thieving is on going it isn't larry but it could then be lilly. she would blame everyone else to undermine lee and kenny causing the group to implode and well who the fuck knows !

I agree because Lilly acted pissed off when Larry didn't get any food and didn't Mark say at the start of episode 2 that they had loads of food and it just seemed to go fast? Maybe Lilly sneaked food for Larry & herself. But i think it could be ether Lilly/Larry or Kenny. The way Kenny acted it does not take much to say he could have been sneaking food for Himself,Duck and Katjaa. We seen how he acted like he would betray the whole group just to save Duck (Which i think we would never let him do that and he would be out of the group in 1 minute if he tried any crap like that.

Sisterofshane · 08/27/2012, 08:49 pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by ZombieGoBoom

Sorry but I can't believe it will be Lilly, Duck or Kenny. It's just too obvious. It can't be Clem because she was so against stealing from that car. If someone is stealing from the group it has to hit home for Lee story-wise.

I think it has to be Doug/Carley that has been taking the food. In episode two, both Carley and Doug turned down when you offer them rations which I found remarkable. I really like Carley and it will bug me to no end if she's the one that has been stealing food but regardless it will be in the spirit of the TWD. I'm curious to see how such a situation plays out and how I will handle it... Probably not well.

I COULD see it being Clem, depending upon how you have influenced her.

Based on the preview, it seems that someone has been stealing food and HIDING it (Lee finds the bag of food in the vent). I think there was some sort of suggestion that somebody is taking the food, perhaps not for themselves, but to make the situation seem more dire than it really is at the motor inn.

Kenny is about the only person that has outwardly suggested that they leave - so I doubt it will be him as that is the OBVIOUS choice. But Clementine is thoughtful, and she pays attention to what is being said. It is possible that, over hearing conversations amongst the adults, that she has decided they need to leave the motor inn. It's also possible that she is being directly influenced by Lee (when he agrees with Kenny that they need to leave), or that she came to the conclusion on her own. If it is the latter, I can see her needing to CONVINCE Lee and the other adults to leave the motor inn, to show them that if they stay they WILL starve. Depending on your choice involving the abandoned car, she could feel herself justified in stealing by saying it is for the greater good, or that it doesn't really matter (everyone steals from the car, anyway).

j.em26 · 08/27/2012, 10:17 pm

I take my vote back, I don't suspect Doug/Carley anymore.
I have a feeling its Kenny.
Aside from the fact that Macon is already so "tapped" as he said, why is Kenny so keen on leaving the motel ?

The persistence of his idea that he had since episode 2 made me a bit suspicious.
And during the group discussion, Kenny either mentions that they can "sort" it out or reprimands about Lilly's bossiness tells me his next response would be something like

"Yeah, I did that. You're not the only leader here" kind of statement.

FoxxyFox · 08/27/2012, 11:17 pm

I have a feeling it might be Carley... I mean like someone pointed out when we offered her at the last episode some of the food, she didn't wanted it.

I also remember from a very soon trailer (that was removed quickly) about Episode 2, that Lilly said to Lee that Carley have some food and you better not take it from her.

WowMutt · 08/27/2012, 11:45 pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kiel555

I picked the Lee/Kenny option but I think it is Kenny. Since Lilly hates him and is the one who determines who gets fed each day, Kenny is lifting extra food to make sure his family gets fed from the food he took from the car.

Exactly the same vote and reason's why!

Even though, I'll still play my main playthrough as Kenny's pal, i'll try to let it slide depending on what exactly has happened.. It's all about the boat for me.

ozzmann · 08/28/2012, 12:01 am

I voted for Ben, but now that I know someone in the group is a BENedict Arnold I'm going to replay episode II and closely scrutinize everyone's actions/reactions/dialog and body language! This is a great story plot, I mean who doesn't love a good Who Done It mystery right?

ruairi46 · 08/28/2012, 02:04 am

Quote:

Originally Posted by ozzmann

I voted for Ben, but now that I know someone in the group is a BENedict Arnold I'm going to replay episode II and closely scrutinize everyone's actions/reactions/dialog and body language! This is a great story plot, I mean who doesn't love a good Who Done It mystery right?

Lol for all we know they could of just thought of this idea during the creation of episode 3, and this was never in the orignal design of ep 3.

Vegztah · 08/28/2012, 03:56 am

Quote:

Originally Posted by SilencerSteven

I think its Kenny, he was planning on leaving anyways and hes gonna need to bring food with him so yea. Also im not sure if its an inside joke but whos the one armed man? :?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XFldSKSCTkk

Araron · 08/28/2012, 04:00 am

I think it might be Clem/Duck,mostly Clem.We can see Lilly pointing a gun to her,and I'm sure she wouldn't do that without the reason...

TheWaltzingBread · 08/28/2012, 04:04 am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bearcules

Speaking of theft, I just noticed the bandit in the trailer telling the group "You don't [expletive] steal from us." I started thinking of the car at the end of the last episode.

Spot on IMO, that car in the Forrest had to belong to the bandits, we saw them on the way to the farm too. I think it's the same guy to boot.

The traitor? I haven't the faintest idea, but I think it may be Kenny, because of the whole Lilly thing.

Milosuperspesh · 08/28/2012, 04:32 am

/ means or in the poll not and..

yup the onearmed man is a mask meme/fugitive reference cookies to those who got it

reason why i grouped the polls is cos larry is now dead but most people know how close lilly and larry had been.

lee (being the player, why would we have to go looking for the bag if we stole it's contents to hide, would be retarded..)

clem n duck the kids (scooby doo style)

ben and katjaa being thr least likely

also to save space in the poll

Drbg · 08/28/2012, 05:54 am

Now that I think about it.. IT HAS TO BE BEN!!!

EchoGarrote · 08/28/2012, 08:46 am

There might be no traitor at all, and Lilly's just being overly paranoid and linking a bunch of little accidents, misplaced stuff, and other things together.

Don'tLickTheSaltLick · 08/28/2012, 09:16 am

Maybe the traitor depends on the choices you have made previously and how you have acted towards each person, and is a different person in each playthrough? Unlikely, but it would be pretty cool.

Don'tLickTheSaltLick · 08/28/2012, 09:48 am

Well, let's take a look at everyone's motivations...

Larry: Trying to protect himself and his daughter, could have been stealing some of the food, but I think that's probably unlikely.

Lilly: Getting more detatched from the group due to the death of her dad. She could also be leaving for woodbury and taking food and supplies for when/if she takes off on her own.

Clem: Could be stealing due to how she is being brought up by lee. She may be stealing after seeing lee and everyone else steal from the car, or maybe not if you didn't loot the car.

Duck: Wouldn't surprise me. His father's attitude could be rubbing off on him.

Lee: Pretty unlikely. I think we would know about it.

Kenny: Getting more detatched. Doesn't really care about anyone but his family, wants to keep them fed.

Ben: New to the group. May not be treated as a full member of the group. Also, he is young, and naive.

Katjaa: Don't really think it's her. Maybe the same reasons as Kenny.

Doug: Can't think of a good reason. Haven't done a doug playthrough yet.

Carley: Can't think of a good reason. Carley seems to be a bit more isolated, really only close to Lee. Then again, she could be setting someone up in order to get Lee into full control of the group.

One Armed Man: wat.

Milosuperspesh · 08/28/2012, 09:59 am

it's a joke

seriously...

Cyreen · 08/28/2012, 10:41 am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Don'tLickTheSaltLick

One Armed Man: wat.

A good indication of age and/or culture.

Don'tLickTheSaltLick · 08/28/2012, 10:42 am

Just to be clear: I get the reference. I was just saying that as I was confused as to why people were voting for it

Milosuperspesh · 08/28/2012, 10:57 am

have you see the other polls in threads ? some of them have a 'joke' choice it's how we roll here

View Poll Results: Who is the traitor ?
Larry/lilly	22	22.22%
clem/duck	15	15.15%
lee/kenny	15	15.15%
ben/katjaa	37	37.37%
doug/carley	10	10.10%
it was the one armed man !	13	13.13%
Multiple Choice Poll. Voters: 99. You may not vote on this poll

08/28/2012, 12:01 am	#27
ozzmann Banned Join Date: Jun 2012 Posts: 220	Motor-Inn Mayhem! I voted for Ben, but now that I know someone in the group is a BENedict Arnold I'm going to replay episode II and closely scrutinize everyone's actions/reactions/dialog and body language! This is a great story plot, I mean who doesn't love a good Who Done It mystery right? Last edited by ozzmann; 08/28/2012 at 12:01 am. Reason: OCD

08/28/2012, 04:32 am	#32
Milosuperspesh V3.0 The shining Join Date: May 2011 Location: Wai soh Sirius ? Posts: 3,168	/ means or in the poll not and.. yup the onearmed man is a mask meme/fugitive reference cookies to those who got it reason why i grouped the polls is cos larry is now dead but most people know how close lilly and larry had been. lee (being the player, why would we have to go looking for the bag if we stole it's contents to hide, would be retarded..) clem n duck the kids (scooby doo style) ben and katjaa being thr least likely also to save space in the poll __________________ https://www.facebook.com/pages/KIQCS/311661538927832 I am Sir Milo of Smeg https://www.facebook.com/#!/SaveCarley My soul tastes like butterscotch pudding Mentored by Mr flibble Sorry the aloe vera ran out for those burns.

08/28/2012, 09:59 am	#37
Milosuperspesh V3.0 The shining Join Date: May 2011 Location: Wai soh Sirius ? Posts: 3,168	*it's a joke* seriously... __________________ https://www.facebook.com/pages/KIQCS/311661538927832 I am Sir Milo of Smeg https://www.facebook.com/#!/SaveCarley My soul tastes like butterscotch pudding Mentored by Mr flibble Sorry the aloe vera ran out for those burns. Last edited by Milosuperspesh; 08/28/2012 at 10:57 am.

08/28/2012, 10:57 am	#40
Milosuperspesh V3.0 The shining Join Date: May 2011 Location: Wai soh Sirius ? Posts: 3,168	have you see the other polls in threads ? some of them have a 'joke' choice it's how we roll here __________________ https://www.facebook.com/pages/KIQCS/311661538927832 I am Sir Milo of Smeg https://www.facebook.com/#!/SaveCarley My soul tastes like butterscotch pudding Mentored by Mr flibble Sorry the aloe vera ran out for those burns.

08/27/2012, 08:04 pm	#21
ZombieGoBoom Carley's Gun Join Date: Jun 2012 Posts: 195	Sorry but I can't believe it will be Lilly, Duck or Kenny. It's just too obvious. It can't be Clem because she was so against stealing from that car. If someone is stealing from the group it has to hit home for Lee story-wise. I think it has to be Doug/Carley that has been taking the food. In episode two, both Carley and Doug turned down when you offer them rations which I found remarkable. I really like Carley and it will bug me to no end if she's the one that has been stealing food but regardless it will be in the spirit of the TWD. I'm curious to see how such a situation plays out and how I will handle it... Probably not well.

08/27/2012, 10:17 pm	#24
j.em26 Hardcore Carley Fanboy :B Join Date: Aug 2012 Location: Unicorn Land :DD Posts: 82	I take my vote back, I don't suspect Doug/Carley anymore. I have a feeling its Kenny. Aside from the fact that Macon is already so "tapped" as he said, why is Kenny so keen on leaving the motel ? The persistence of his idea that he had since episode 2 made me a bit suspicious. And during the group discussion, Kenny either mentions that they can "sort" it out or reprimands about Lilly's bossiness tells me his next response would be something like "Yeah, I did that. You're not the only leader here" kind of statement.

08/27/2012, 11:17 pm	#25
FoxxyFox 100% Foxxyfied Join Date: Aug 2012 Location: Germany Posts: 188	I have a feeling it might be Carley... I mean like someone pointed out when we offered her at the last episode some of the food, she didn't wanted it. I also remember from a very soon trailer (that was removed quickly) about Episode 2, that Lilly said to Lee that Carley have some food and you better not take it from her.

08/28/2012, 04:00 am	#30
Araron No Title Left Join Date: Aug 2012 Location: Around Every Corner Posts: 228	I think it might be Clem/Duck,mostly Clem.We can see Lilly pointing a gun to her,and I'm sure she wouldn't do that without the reason...

08/28/2012, 05:54 am	#33
Drbg Senior Member Join Date: Aug 2012 Posts: 118	Now that I think about it.. IT HAS TO BE BEN!!!

08/28/2012, 08:46 am	#34
EchoGarrote Junior Member Join Date: Jul 2012 Posts: 6	There might be no traitor at all, and Lilly's just being overly paranoid and linking a bunch of little accidents, misplaced stuff, and other things together.

08/28/2012, 09:16 am	#35
Don'tLickTheSaltLick It's gross. Join Date: Jul 2012 Posts: 60	Maybe the traitor depends on the choices you have made previously and how you have acted towards each person, and is a different person in each playthrough? Unlikely, but it would be pretty cool.

08/28/2012, 09:48 am	#36
Don'tLickTheSaltLick It's gross. Join Date: Jul 2012 Posts: 60	Well, let's take a look at everyone's motivations... Larry: Trying to protect himself and his daughter, could have been stealing some of the food, but I think that's probably unlikely. Lilly: Getting more detatched from the group due to the death of her dad. She could also be leaving for woodbury and taking food and supplies for when/if she takes off on her own. Clem: Could be stealing due to how she is being brought up by lee. She may be stealing after seeing lee and everyone else steal from the car, or maybe not if you didn't loot the car. Duck: Wouldn't surprise me. His father's attitude could be rubbing off on him. Lee: Pretty unlikely. I think we would know about it. Kenny: Getting more detatched. Doesn't really care about anyone but his family, wants to keep them fed. Ben: New to the group. May not be treated as a full member of the group. Also, he is young, and naive. Katjaa: Don't really think it's her. Maybe the same reasons as Kenny. Doug: Can't think of a good reason. Haven't done a doug playthrough yet. Carley: Can't think of a good reason. Carley seems to be a bit more isolated, really only close to Lee. Then again, she could be setting someone up in order to get Lee into full control of the group. One Armed Man: wat.

08/28/2012, 10:42 am	#39
Don'tLickTheSaltLick It's gross. Join Date: Jul 2012 Posts: 60	Just to be clear: I get the reference. I was just saying that as I was confused as to why people were voting for it

Thread Tools	Search this Thread
Show Printable Version Email this Page	Search this Thread: Advanced Search