Lilly vs Carley....who is more attractive?

[Gennadios]

Lilly's the strong silent type. I like strong silent types.

Carley's ok but I know chicks like her in the real world enough to be unimpressed.

[kingmartykim]

Originally Posted by Gennadios

Lilly's the strong silent type. I like strong silent types.

Carley's ok but I know chicks like her in the real world enough to be unimpressed.

Good luck when Lily gets on her period...her moodswing will be...deadly!

[Gennadios]

Originally Posted by kingmartykim

Good luck when Lily gets on her period...her moodswing will be...deadly!

There's as much of a chance of hooking up with her as Carley at this point, so it's all kind of moot.

[Red Panda]

Just physically speaking, I have to go with Lilly.

Carley has a cuter face.

Lilly's face isn't bad either (when she's not scowling), and her body is nice.

I like Carley more though and would get at her first. She's a real woman.

I couldn't deal with all of Lilly's shit. She's a Daddy's girl.

[L e x]

I think Lily's attitude is causing this landslide

[Drake Sigar]

Originally Posted by Gennadios

Lilly's the strong silent type. I like strong silent types.

For the strong silent type, she isn't very silent. More like a shrill harpy.

[Gennadios]

Originally Posted by Drake Sigar

For the strong silent type, she isn't very silent. More like a shrill harpy.

I bet she was totally pleasant for the 3 weeks after ep2 she spent holed up in her room strung up on opiates.

[Drake Sigar]

Originally Posted by Gennadios

I bet she was totally pleasant for the 3 weeks after ep2 she spent holed up in her room strung up on opiates.

Oh, so you like the drugged silent type. Well why didn't you just say so?

[YamiRaziel]

Lily totally. She tries to take responsibility and be leader. She's the true Rick Grimes of this group. The one doing the tough decisions and making people follow her even if they do not agree. Carley's just a useless girl who can shoot a gun and doesn't really like to be held responsible. I guess sometimes you can't be on everybody's good side.
Of course Lily snapped, but so has Rick. Still, he has Carl while Lily lost everything and Lee wasn't really supportive either. Had they given him more comforting options, things would've been different.

[Cyreen]

Really guys? Carley's all corpsified and Lilly is a control freak psycho WITH A GUN.

I suddenly begin to understand the divorce rate.

[skepticalguy90]

Originally Posted by YamiRaziel

Lily totally. She tries to take responsibility and be leader. She's the true Rick Grimes of this group. The one doing the tough decisions and making people follow her even if they do not agree. Carley's just a useless girl who can shoot a gun and doesn't really like to be held responsible. I guess sometimes you can't be on everybody's good side.
Of course Lily snapped, but so has Rick. Still, he has Carl while Lily lost everything and Lee wasn't really supportive either. Had they given him more comforting options, things would've been different.

To be honest, Lily isn't making decisions that are best for the group. Look at her decision to try and keep them at the motor inn as long as possible? I don't think she is making tough decisions, I just think she has fallen off the deep end.

[Luckycharm]

Carley. Her voice's pretty nice too, soothing.

[JCMcAdams84]

It's crazy but one of the reasons I like Carley is because I know a chick named Carley, looks just like her, even has the little scar on her face and everything. It kind of weirded me out a bit at first but then I got used to it. That was honestly the main reason I saved her my first play, because it felt like I was saving someone I really knew, lol.

[YamiRaziel]

Originally Posted by skepticalguy90

To be honest, Lily isn't making decisions that are best for the group. Look at her decision to try and keep them at the motor inn as long as possible? I don't think she is making tough decisions, I just think she has fallen off the deep end.

So abandoning the only shelter you have is better? Shooting for the unknown? What if they stumbled on some organized violent society like let's say.... Woodbury?
Lily tries to protect the group, Lily notices when somebody's stealing their supplies, she rations the food (not easy, ah?) and she still takes the blame for making decisions. Everybody complains but nobody wants to do it!
Kenny cares only about his family. Even before Lily killed Carley, he was ready to dump her in the Hotel just because he killed her dad and felt guilty. He ain't much of a team player.
Has Carley stepped up for taking some responsibility. It's really easy to be passive in situations like those and blame the ones who got to make the hard choices.
That's why none of them understand Lee either.

[skepticalguy90]

Originally Posted by YamiRaziel

So abandoning the only shelter you have is better? Shooting for the unknown? What if they stumbled on some organized violent society like let's say.... Woodbury?
Lily tries to protect the group, Lily notices when somebody's stealing their supplies, she rations the food (not easy, ah?) and she still takes the blame for making decisions. Everybody complains but nobody wants to do it!
Kenny cares only about his family. Even before Lily killed Carley, he was ready to dump her in the Hotel just because he killed her dad and felt guilty. He ain't much of a team player.
Has Carley stepped up for taking some responsibility. It's really easy to be passive in situations like those and blame the ones who got to make the hard choices.
That's why none of them understand Lee either.

I don't know about you, but how is the unknown worse than those 10-15 guys that are trying to put an arrow through your temple? She isn't trying to protect the group, she is hanging onto the naive notion that the motor inn is safe. By refusing to accept reality, she is endangering the group. The reality is you can say "what if" all you want, but you KNOW there are people trying to kill you at the motor inn. I'd take my chances on the road anyday in that situation. And straight out threatening and accusing Ben/Carley isn't helping the group either, as all she does is tear it apart and it ends up people killed. I'll admit she did the hard thing by rationing the food, but that doesn't earn you a get out of jail free card to shoot people at will.

[slayer300876]

Carley easily. 1 thing i dont under stand is in episode 1, Carley's breasts look bigger than episode 2 and 3. lily's look smaller in ep 1 then get bigger in episode 2-3.

[DreadMagus]

Necropostastic!

[Yertos]

Lilly, Carley's long neck turns me off. Also Lilly knows how to use and identify a battery :P

[DreadMagus]

She also has control issues and will SHOOT YOU IN THE FACE if you talk back to her.

I don't see myself being anyone's bitch, so Carley wins by default.

[HiggsBoson2142]

Originally Posted by PrinkiePrie

Sheesh, am I the only one who saved Dough?

Eh, I'm not really good with cooking.