Whose death made you so emotional?

[Dead_Man_Walking]

Originally Posted by Magic Emperor

To be honest, I think the rapid-fire deaths messed up Episode 3's pacing. When I lost Carley I was devastated and sad, and I still thought about her even when it came time for Katjaa and Duck's scene, and so the latter two's deaths didn't have as big of an impact on me as they should have.

But that's just my two cents.

Well, I like your two cents. That's actually how I felt, too. Makes me wonder how episode four is going to follow up.

I chose other. I think the bunny rabbit (Beginning of Episode two) was the most screwed up death. D: I didn't even get to eat him. I hope he comes back as a Walker and we can see him in episode four. Deep down, we all know that happy endings have rainbows, butterflies, a sunrise, pixie dust, rainbow farts and BUNNIES!

Seeing that dead rabbit made me feel like there was no hope left. <3

[Master of Aeons]

That's pretty much the point. It's shockingly bad, it's terrible, it's way worse, and the final step of it all is shooting the little boy who never shut up and now is quietly wheezing out his last moments. If you don't like the pointedly manufactured hopelessness of this episode, Walking Dead isn't for you.

[sparkzfly]

Originally Posted by Dead_Man_Walking

Seeing that dead rabbit made me feel like there was no hope left. <3

hahaha omg marry me.

[RedKoolLoops]

The gravity of Carley's death never really hit me until the latter stages of the episode.
I will admit that I am still sad about it but it was Duck's death that had the most impact on me at the time.

The whole scene. The talking and the lead up to it with Kenny pleading with Kat and of course, that bloody soundtrack. Kudos to the sound department, man. That music alone could've brought tears to a glass eye. Katjaa's death was simply salt in an already painful wound.

[donmike84]

im not gonna vote as i say it's a tie between kennys family and carley

[ZacTB]

Carley's death was more of a shock, Katjaa and Duck was more emotional.

[TMLC]

I think Carley’s death was probably the most shocking in the sense that I did not saw it coming.

But the saddest were most probably Duck’s and Larry’s because of the other characters involvement. Watching Lily trying to save her dad and Kenny facing the need to kill his son (and doing that myself into my game) had a deepest impact.

[Xarne]

none of them were emotional as in teary eyed

Larry death- relief
Doug- 'Doug, you ok?, Walk it off brah'
Kat and Duck: 'Oh snap, that just happened...this episode is crazy!'

As I'm realizing now, Doug was just fluff. Carley interacts with you more substantially in her episodes; saves your ass at the beginning of Ep2 with the dude in the pickup turning; gives you food; allows you to come clean in Ep3; she had your back like you had Kenny's.
Doug is hard to talk to, if he talks at all- he does make that alarm system at the motel but that's it. I picked him because the OBVIOUS choice was Carley so I figured, he must have been the hidden gem. No, he was just the illusion of choice for Ep 1.

[Cyreen]

Different person, different death, different emotion. I was shocked and angry when Carley/Doug died, hurt and a little guilty when Katjaa died because I didn't see it coming, sad but resigned when Duck died.

[Viser]

Originally Posted by Xarne

none of them were emotional as in teary eyed

Larry death- relief
Doug- 'Doug, you ok?, Walk it off brah'
Kat and Duck: 'Oh snap, that just happened...this episode is crazy!'

As I'm realizing now, Doug was just fluff. Carley interacts with you more substantially in her episodes; saves your ass at the beginning of Ep2 with the dude in the pickup turning; gives you food; allows you to come clean in Ep3; she had your back like you had Kenny's.
Doug is hard to talk to, if he talks at all- he does make that alarm system at the motel but that's it. I picked him because the OBVIOUS choice was Carley so I figured, he must have been the hidden gem. No, he was just the illusion of choice for Ep 1.

It is true that you can bond better with Carley, but Doug was not just fluff. He was actually my favorite character. He was a very nice person, heck, he got in the way of a bullet for a guy he barely even knew, he just didn't save you as often as Carley because he didn't like guns. On Ep2 he does hit David/Travis when he attacks you, but as it turns out, wooden planks aren't very effective against zombies. I guess I liked him because he was a character I could identify myself, my Lee, with, I feel like he was the only person you could actually count on, he just didn't have that many moments to shine.

[Xarne]

Originally Posted by Viser

It is true that you can bond better with Carley, but Doug was not just fluff. He was actually my favorite character. He was a very nice person, heck, he got in the way of a bullet for a guy he barely even knew, he just didn't save you as often as Carley because he didn't like guns. On Ep2 he does hit David/Travis when he attacks you, but as it turns out, wooden planks aren't very effective against zombies. I guess I liked him because he was a character I could identify myself, my Lee, with, I feel like he was the only person you could actually count on, he just didn't have that many moments to shine.

I thought Doug was gonna build us a laser-guided walker killer or some anti-walker grenades...something McGuyver-ish. I was all 'ha! everyone picked Carley, lets show them, Doug!'...nothin.
When I replayed it with Carly; omg; so much interaction- she seems alive and part of the group.

[Zombies are Awesome!]

Carley is dominating the poll, and she should cause i agree. I was shocked beyond belief when it happened

[Viser]

Originally Posted by Zombies are Awesome!

Carley is dominating the poll, and she should cause i agree. I was shocked beyond belief when it happened

Oh well. Just different opinions I guess. I've yet to do a playthrough where I save Carley, I plan on doing that after I finish all 5 episodes. But I don't know, I feel like Doug deserves a bit more attention, he was a very cool guy, and as I've stated on more threads than I can remember, I almost cried when Lilly shot him, but still couldn't bring myself to be mad on neither her nor Ben...

[Xarne]

Originally Posted by Viser

Oh well. Just different opinions I guess. I've yet to do a playthrough where I save Carley,

oh...you'll be in for a surprise. I know you like Doug but you'll see the devs clearly spent their time on Carley

[Skythe1908]

Other: Lee axing his brother was the most emotionally charged death scene for me.

[Viser]

Originally Posted by Skythe1908

Other: Lee axing his brother was the most emotionally charged death scene for me.

Really? I find that interesting... we didn't get to know Lee's brother and family that much, so all I could do was feel a little sorry that Lee had to do that, but nothing else, really.

[RafaelBrasileiro]

Is the first time I feel sad, nervous and shocked by a character in a game die! Carley was the one who always saved lee, the person I trusted most (Clementine too), because until now I'm sad ...
But see kenny crying and kaatja dead beside him, and duck!that was sad too!

[Master of Aeons]

Originally Posted by Xarne

I thought Doug was gonna build us a laser-guided walker killer or some anti-walker grenades...something McGuyver-ish. I was all 'ha! everyone picked Carley, lets show them, Doug!'...nothin.
When I replayed it with Carly; omg; so much interaction- she seems alive and part of the group.

Whoops.

[Xarne]

lol ur going to video game hell

[Master of Aeons]

I'm taking all of you with me! *drinks nitroglycerine*