Telltale Games

DreadMagus · 09/04/2012, 08:14 pm

....about Carley being murdered in a moment of someone's misplaced rage?

NOTE: This is NOT about why you think OTHER people are upset, nor is it about Doug.... we get it, some people saved Doug instead of Carley on their main file....

For me, it's the fact she was the only character I felt I could trust to watch my back and not screw me over. Who I didn't feel I had to bribe or bargain with.

Though her lack of knowledge of simple things like Batteries worried me.

Plus. she looks darned cool with an eyepatch. Totally needs to be in a pirate game.

On the other hand, Kenny betrayed me in Episode 2, and I felt I had to "bribe" Lilly by trying to save Larry the BetaBully.

Ultraa · 09/05/2012, 04:19 am

Quote:

Originally Posted by DreadMagus

....about Carley being murdered in a moment of someone's misplaced rage?

NOTE: This is NOT about why you think OTHER people are upset, nor is it about Doug.... we get it, some people saved Doug instead of Carley on their main file....

For me, it's the fact she was the only character I felt I could trust to watch my back and not screw me over. Who I didn't feel I had to bribe or bargain with.

Though her lack of knowledge of simple things like Batteries worried me.

Plus. she looks darned cool with an eyepatch. Totally needs to be in a pirate game.

On the other hand, Kenny betrayed me in Episode 2, and I felt I had to "bribe" Lilly by trying to save Larry the BetaBully.

Plus there's the little part that she knew something that most of the group didn't know and told you first she knew

chaz99 · 09/05/2012, 07:04 am

I feel the same way about Carley, but nothing changes the fact that she's gone. I have her gun, and I suppose in some small way she is still with us.

She saved Lee's life at least four times- none of the other characters were as steady. If this thing lasts four seasons or more I doubt I will ever forget her.

Two things about her death that I have learned: One, the living are 10x as dangerous as the dead. Two, don't get too attached to the NPC. They will probably die horrible, grisly or pathetically sad deaths like Duck and Katjaa.

That being said, we have to move on. As the Roman philosopher Seneca said, "while there's life, there's hope."

QuarterPounderVlad · 09/05/2012, 11:35 am

Save doug!
I hate that they had to kill off Carley and Doug. It's really annoying. but that's how it goes. People die, And stay dead. There were several people saying Carley might be alive...

I said EPIC FAIL

Xarne · 09/05/2012, 03:27 pm

I dont like no hash!
(I chose Doug)

RafaelBrasileiro · 09/05/2012, 03:51 pm

She saved me, kenny, katja and duck in Ep1 ... saved me also when Clem was being attacked by a zombie, she did not tell anyone that I was a murderer, she would not accept the food offered to her and wanted I stayed with the food, and various other reasons!
Translating ... I totally trust her, she trusted me, and she saved me several times!
that's why I'm so upset!

Googolplexbyte · 09/05/2012, 05:40 pm

Why was it misplaced rage? It seems pretty clear Lilly wasn't a big fan of Carley, Lilly never shot at Doug she aimed for Ben when Carley wasn't there.

Zeruis · 09/05/2012, 05:45 pm

Carley was the only one who entirely trusted you. She could handle herself with a gun, and gave you encouraging advice as well as hints of a romance. Her last words were trying to stand up for Lee.

DreadMagus · 09/05/2012, 05:56 pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Googolplexbyte

Why was it misplaced rage? It seems pretty clear Lilly wasn't a big fan of Carley, Lilly never shot at Doug she aimed for Ben when Carley wasn't there.

Because, ultimately, her rage was at "losing everything"... the traitor, and Carley by extension, gave her something to focus it on.

Seemed to me she was just looking for someone to blame for that, when in the end it's the ZA that did it.

Had they not been forced out of their "home", I think this might have played out differently. Since this started with an investigation (pre-battle) and turned into a witch hunt (post battle)

Xarne · 09/05/2012, 07:41 pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Googolplexbyte

Why was it misplaced rage? It seems pretty clear Lilly wasn't a big fan of Carley, Lilly never shot at Doug she aimed for Ben when Carley wasn't there.

you know how catfights go in the ZA, first its about what someone's wearing, then it's missing suppies, next thing you know gunplay erupts

Draconigena · 09/05/2012, 08:41 pm

Because I have a hard-on for Lily and I knew it meant the worst for her.

NessaT · 09/05/2012, 09:10 pm

Carley was great. She encouraged Lee to come clean about his past and I was able to let people know that Lee was a convicted Killer. They didn't mind as much then.

I did another play with Doug, and I wasn't given that opportunity. So, Lilly blew my cover and people started mistrusting me.

09/04/2012, 08:14 pm	#1
DreadMagus Arrgh! Thar Be Zombies! Join Date: Sep 2012 Location: The space between worlds. Posts: 2,095	Why are you upset.... ....about Carley being murdered in a moment of someone's misplaced rage? NOTE: This is NOT about why you think OTHER people are upset, nor is it about Doug.... we get it, some people saved Doug instead of Carley on their main file.... For me, it's the fact she was the only character I felt I could trust to watch my back and not screw me over. Who I didn't feel I had to bribe or bargain with. Though her lack of knowledge of simple things like Batteries worried me. Plus. she looks darned cool with an eyepatch. Totally needs to be in a pirate game. On the other hand, Kenny betrayed me in Episode 2, and I felt I had to "bribe" Lilly by trying to save Larry the BetaBully. __________________ WITCH! Oh sorry, got confused by all your crying. ~ Francis

Thread Tools	Search this Thread
Show Printable Version Email this Page	Search this Thread: Advanced Search

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
Episode 3 release dates: PSN NA, XBOX, PC/MAC out NOW, Steam Aug 29th (by 6pm PDT)!	Vainamoinen	The Walking Dead Discussion	3455	09/03/2012 07:10 am
(SPOILER ALERT!!!)Anyone else extremely upset by this in episode 3	Dante30	The Walking Dead Story Discussion - SPOILERS	32	09/01/2012 10:01 pm
upset about the mug	Poppycock	Tales of Monkey Island General Discussion	6	07/25/2010 06:03 am
I'm upset no one told me how good this game was...	Sgtmoody	Tales of Monkey Island General Discussion	4	05/25/2010 04:42 pm
Do you play S+M when you're upset?	Butterscotch-Biros	Sam & Max Series Discussion	44	01/15/2010 05:53 pm

09/05/2012, 07:04 am	#3
chaz99 Senior Member Join Date: Aug 2012 Posts: 145	I feel the same way about Carley, but nothing changes the fact that she's gone. I have her gun, and I suppose in some small way she is still with us. She saved Lee's life at least four times- none of the other characters were as steady. If this thing lasts four seasons or more I doubt I will ever forget her. Two things about her death that I have learned: One, the living are 10x as dangerous as the dead. Two, don't get too attached to the NPC. They will probably die horrible, grisly or pathetically sad deaths like Duck and Katjaa. That being said, we have to move on. As the Roman philosopher Seneca said, "while there's life, there's hope."

09/05/2012, 11:35 am	#4
QuarterPounderVlad Senior Member Join Date: Sep 2012 Posts: 586	Save doug! I hate that they had to kill off Carley and Doug. It's really annoying. but that's how it goes. People die, And stay dead. There were several people saying Carley might be alive... I said EPIC FAIL

09/05/2012, 03:27 pm	#5
Xarne Senior Member Join Date: Jul 2012 Location: A forest, riddled with Meth Posts: 931	I dont like no hash! (I chose Doug)

09/05/2012, 03:51 pm	#6
RafaelBrasileiro Senior Member Join Date: Sep 2012 Location: Brazil, Rio De Janeiro Posts: 216	She saved me, kenny, katja and duck in Ep1 ... saved me also when Clem was being attacked by a zombie, she did not tell anyone that I was a murderer, she would not accept the food offered to her and wanted I stayed with the food, and various other reasons! Translating ... I totally trust her, she trusted me, and she saved me several times! that's why I'm so upset!

09/05/2012, 05:40 pm	#7
Googolplexbyte Member Join Date: Sep 2012 Posts: 64	Why was it misplaced rage? It seems pretty clear Lilly wasn't a big fan of Carley, Lilly never shot at Doug she aimed for Ben when Carley wasn't there.

09/05/2012, 05:45 pm	#8
Zeruis Mundy Join Date: Jun 2012 Posts: 1,980	Carley was the only one who entirely trusted you. She could handle herself with a gun, and gave you encouraging advice as well as hints of a romance. Her last words were trying to stand up for Lee.

09/05/2012, 08:41 pm	#11
Draconigena Junior Member Join Date: Sep 2012 Posts: 15	Because I have a hard-on for Lily and I knew it meant the worst for her.

09/05/2012, 09:10 pm	#12
NessaT Resident Lurker Join Date: Jun 2012 Posts: 318	Carley was great. She encouraged Lee to come clean about his past and I was able to let people know that Lee was a convicted Killer. They didn't mind as much then. I did another play with Doug, and I wasn't given that opportunity. So, Lilly blew my cover and people started mistrusting me.