Would you leave Lilly if she had killed Ben?

[The_Cheshire_Cat]

Nope, she would have been more than welcome to stay in the group. Shoot, I would have given her a medal.

[Xarne]

Yea lets demonize Lily for
1) Hitting the bullseye and zeroing in on the real threat to the group
2) having the balls to take action on it while the majority of you would still be talking about it while the badits rifle through the rest of your belongings and the zombies kill you all.

[Eric Northman]

Originally Posted by Phoenix VII

I figured Ben was the traitor even before the bandit attack on the motel, so I wouldn't have left her if she killed him, although I prefer exile to execution. Carley, on the other hand was killed without discussion or evidence and mainly because she pissed Lilly off, which is why I left her because, like Kenny said, if she would kill Carley out of anger then how do I know she won't kill him? I don't know whether I'd have left her or not if it was Doug I had with the group instead of Carley, since his death is so different and more of an accident, but I haven't done a playthrough where I saved him yet.

Do you really think of Ben as a traitor? In his own way he was trying to save the group. The bandits wouldn't have just left everyone alone if they weren't getting something in return. In actuality he bought the group time to finsh repairing the RV.

[Instant Karma]

I left Lily cuz she killed. Not because she killed Carley or Doug. Because she killed. Ben turning out to be the traitor doesn't change that. You all have to remember that at the time of the murder, we weren't aware that Ben was the traitor, and frankly, it wouldn't have mattered to me. I understood why he did what he did, and while I will be a little more wary of him, I don't plan on getting him killed either.

[Xarne]

Originally Posted by Instant Karma

I left Lily cuz she killed. Not because she killed Carley or Doug. Because she killed. Ben turning out to be the traitor doesn't change that. You all have to remember that at the time of the murder, we weren't aware that Ben was the traitor, and frankly, it wouldn't have mattered to me. I understood why he did what he did, and while I will be a little more wary of him, I don't plan on getting him killed either.

Would you have done EP3 the same way as Ben, in his shoes?

[Cyreen]

Originally Posted by Xarne

Would you have done EP3 the same way as Ben, in his shoes?

Would you really have done EP3 the same way as Lilly, in her shoes?

[Instant Karma]

Originally Posted by Xarne

Would you have done EP3 the same way as Ben, in his shoes?

I'd like to think not, but I have clue how I would react to that situation in general. However, I also would like to think I wouldn't have killed Ben had I been in Lily's position.

[Master of Aeons]

About the only person I think I would actually act like in this game is probably Omid. Joke around, freeze up, cry through the next episode.

[Cyreen]

Hopefully you'd have better luck sticking the landing.

[Instant Karma]

Originally Posted by Master of Aeons

About the only person I think I would actually act like in this game is probably Omid. Joke around, freeze up, cry through the next episode.

That probably describes more people than are willing to admit.

Present company included

[Xarne]

Originally Posted by Cyreen

Would you really have done EP3 the same way as Lilly, in her shoes?

Dont you know you cant answer a persons question with another question?!
Now, please, allow me to administer my litmus test to the presented party

[Xarne]

Originally Posted by Instant Karma

I'd like to think not, but I have clue how I would react to that situation in general. However, I also would like to think I wouldn't have killed Ben had I been in Lily's position.

Would you have made that deal and kept it secret- thats the 10,000 question

[Master of Aeons]

Why is everyone asking so many questions?

[Xarne]

Cyreen is trying to stop me from fanning the 'Ben is human waste matter' flames, yet again.
I was just asking a simple question
/halo

[Cyreen]

Originally Posted by Master of Aeons

Why is everyone asking so many questions?

Why is it he didn't answer my question?

[Master of Aeons]

Did I tell you we play Questions Only in my improv class?

[Cyreen]

Does that mean you're not going to answer my question either?

[Xarne]

I got a question: Can we all stop using the word question? I mean, I know there are alot of questions on this thread right now but really, ask yourself this question. Are all these questions really necessary? I mean, Im not trying to question the status quo but really, this is a little crazy, and it raises the question: Is this guy trolling us right now?

[Calamitymlc]

I don't know how I'd really feel, I mean its easy to say one thing but in the real situation after three months of getting to know Carley/Doug and defending their lives as they defended yours... things would be different.

I would probably have killed Lily on the spot, I don't like losing loose ends with people who are dangerous like the St. Johns brothers (I killed both of them.) Ironically this is very Lily minded.

Morality is just not as important as survival in a hostile environment. One thing that contrasts Lee Everett and Rick Grimes is the fact that Rick always taught Carl that survival comes first, while Lee (regardless of player interaction) guides Clem to try and be moral when there is no room for it.

Lily was just a bad egg, she was going insane and had to be taken care of. Giving away supplies is traitorous but it is not murder. The situation could have been handled later on maybe on the way to Savannah or before they got on the train.

[Xarne]

Originally Posted by Calamitymlc

Morality is just not as important as survival in a hostile environment. One thing that contrasts Lee Everett and Rick Grimes is the fact that Rick always taught Carl that survival comes first, while Lee (regardless of player interaction) guides Clem to try and be moral when there is no room for it.

I like this guy already, good post