Episode 4 Trailer (inside)

[Rock114]

Originally Posted by Red Panda

I guess I have to ask. Why are you certain they are different people?

Different hair color, for one. The recorded woman also has a different voice, and upon seeing the tape Christa says "What kind of place is this!" If it WERE Christa on the tape, I'd think that she would have an idea of exactly how bad that place was if she had actually been there, and she and Omid would NOT be going all the way to Savannah with Lee and Co if she had somehow escaped there.

[Cyreen]

Maybe because the woman on the tape appears Caucasian.

Originally Posted by Gary Whitta

I'm surprised no-one's spotted it yet.

Tease!

[Red Panda]

Originally Posted by Rock114

Different hair color, for one. The recorded woman also has a different voice, and upon seeing the tape Christa says "What kind of place is this!" If it WERE Christa on the tape, I'd think that she would have an idea of exactly how bad that place was if she had actually been there, and she and Omid would NOT be going all the way to Savannah with Lee and Co if she had somehow escaped there.

1. Like I mentioned before, lighting could explain the difference. The hair is brown and straight in both cases. I don't see the big difference.
2. The "what kind of place is this!" is probably just clever editing so it isn't too spoilery. Remember the ep 3 trailer? You hear a gunshot ,then see Clem holding a gun, shaking. People speculated she killed a walker or human and it turns out she didn't even fire the gun.
3. Last, who is to say they have been there before? They obviously meet new people. Who is talking when they mention the "stories" about how bad the place was? I gave an theory as to why this could all happen without Christa ever haven visited Savannah. Even if she did, it's not like they planned to go to Savannah. She was forced by the horde.

I can't say you're wrong. I see you're view. We have to wait and see but personally, I'm not yet convinced that there's no way this could be not Christa.

[thestalkinghead]

Originally Posted by Cyreen

Maybe because the woman on the tape appears Caucasian.

Christa appeared Caucasian or maybe Asian (south Asia, Indian, Pakistani, Bangladeshi etc.) to me until i checked the wiki, but she does look more Caucasian than Christa

[Red Panda]

Originally Posted by Cyreen

Maybe because the woman on the tape appears Caucasian.

She doesn't to me. Plus, lighting can make a huge difference.

Take a real life example:

[thestalkinghead]

Originally Posted by Red Panda

She doesn't to me. Plus, lighting can make a huge difference.

that is Photoshop it is well known that basically all her photos are changed to make her look more white

[Red Panda]

Originally Posted by thestalkinghead

Christa appeared Caucasian or maybe Asian (south Asia, Indian, Pakistani, Bangladeshi etc.) to me until i checked the wiki, but she does look more Caucasian than Christa

I don't trust that wiki. They make stuff up. I don't even think Carley was Caucasian. She could easily be Latina, but I digress.

[Cyreen]

Looks Caucasian? Sure, okay...

[Red Panda]

Originally Posted by thestalkinghead

that is Photoshop it is well known that basically all her photos are changed to make her look more white

lol

[RafaelBrasileiro]

I also think that Christa not know this woman's video, it would be much coincidence.
but who knows?

Originally Posted by Red Panda

I don't even think Carley was Caucasian. She could easily be Latina, but I digress.

I think she is not Caucasian.

[thestalkinghead]

Originally Posted by Cyreen

Looks Caucasian? Sure, okay...

well not in that picture, but she does look south Asian in that picture

[Red Panda]

Originally Posted by RafaelBrasileiro

I also think that Christa not know this woman's video, it would be much coincidence.
but who knows?

I obviously have my doubts, which is why I never brought it up, but like you said, who knows?

[thestalkinghead]

Originally Posted by Cyreen

Looks Caucasian? Sure, okay...

her skin tone is similar to carleys and a tan can make white people very brown

[Red Panda]

Originally Posted by thestalkinghead

well not in that picture

I don't think in any picture Christa looks white. Do you have one where she does? Is there a scene in video you can point to?

[thestalkinghead]

Originally Posted by Red Panda

I don't think in any picture Christa looks white. Do you have one where she does? Is there a scene in video you can point to?

i may possibly have my brightness a bit higher than recommended on my pc, so just imagine that picture slightly brighter, but as i said a tan can make white people very brown

[Red Panda]

Originally Posted by thestalkinghead

her skin tone is similar to carleys and a tan can make white people very brown

I agree a tan can make white people look very brown



Maybe just a spray tan or heavy make up



but I don't think so in this case

[thestalkinghead]

a bit like this


but yeah after seeing the wiki i wasn't in shock that she wasn't white, i was more like "oh another misidentified race good on me"

[Red Panda]

Originally Posted by thestalkinghead

i may possibly have my brightness a bit higher than recommended on my pc, so just imagine that picture slightly brighter, but as i said a tan can make white people very brown

Why, I agree lighting can make a difference! Back to my original point: the woman in the video is Christa...

[thestalkinghead]

Originally Posted by Red Panda

Why, I agree lighting can make a difference! Back to my original point: the woman in the video is Christa...

yeah i know, but as i said i wouldn't bet money on it being her

[Yertos]

Originally Posted by Red Panda

I guess I have to ask. Why are you certain they are different people?

Well the woman in the video appears white, while Christa is black. Could just be the lighting but odds are they're different people.