SPOILERS: Did anyone have similar choices I made in episode 4?

[John W.]

Originally Posted by coolmack24

In Episode 4, which I just played, The main choices I made were

1. I killed the boy zombie in the attic.

2. I decided to kill Ben when he was in the bell tower, because Clementine was already outside and Ben was a real A-hole for being in the bandit group and leaving Clementine (and yes I know he said he was shaken and he just ran away, but still.)

3. I decided not to show the bite because I was afraid they were going to kick me out of the group because of that.

4. I took Kenny with me to find Clem because I wanted Omid taken care of by Christa.

Anybody have the same (or almost the same) choices as me?

Had Kenny kill the boy - since he couldn't bring himself to kill his own son, I figured it would be something akin to closure for him, as well as letting him do some good. I felt it was something that he needed to do to start putting his horrors behind him.

Several times through the episode I wanted to deck Ben, but in the end I just couldn't stand to see one more person that I was supposed to be protecting die.

I also didn't show them the bite because I knew I'd need their help to find Clementine, and I assumed I'd be on my own if they thought I could turn and kill them at any moment. I mean, if you've seen the show or read the comics, you should really have expected that response from them. I think it turns out that they actually ALL go with you if you show them the damn bite, for all the sense that makes.

In the end, Christa refused to leave Omid, who couldn't come with us, so it ended up being me, Kenny, and Ben (looking for redemption - I hope he can prove himself in the next episode) going to find Clementine.

[Lightining Count]

I killed the kid.

I figured Crawford would be too dangerous for Clem, so I told her to stay at the house and gave her a gun.

I let Ben die.

I told Vernon I'd think about Clem going with him.

I showed the bite.

In the end everyone but Ben and Molly (killed in Crawford by walkers RIP) came with me.

[MissDRJ]

I used the gun and it just causes you to have less time to escape, no they don't crawl through the hole.

[Zeruis]

-I killed the boy.

-I was honest with Vernon.

-I took Clem with me.

-I saved Ben.

-At the end, Ben, Omid, and Christa came with me.

-My choice of words were "What do you want from me?"

[Dave of Canada]

Originally Posted by John W.

I mean, if you've seen the show or read the comics, you should really have expected that response from them. I think it turns out that they actually ALL go with you if you show them the damn bite, for all the sense that makes.

Well, it does make sense. They're not coming with you because of their personal feelings unless you show them the bite, which makes them see it as a last request.

[NeonBlade]

Originally Posted by Dave of Canada

Well, it does make sense. They're not coming with you because of their personal feelings unless you show them the bite, which makes them see it as a last request.

The thing is Christa is pregnant. I secretly know this. Why would she jeopardise here safety and potential child to tag along on what could be yet, another suicide mission?

[Demonseed]

-I killed the boy, I gave Kenny a chance to do it but he wasn't buying it so I went over and smashed his head with my wrench.

-I left Clem at the house, no way was I going to take a child to Crawford where everyone thought they were alive and carrying guns and hating kids.

-Even though I debated dropping Ben, I just couldn't. He did make tons of bad choices but he didn't do any of them for evil, he just made dumb decisions. To me killing him was wrong even though I had to think on it for a second. I will drop him on my second play through though.

-I told Vernon I'd think about it, he was showing concern so I decided not to get pissed at him for offering to help. He also saw disfunction in the group, he was only trying to help.

-I hid the bite and asked to go alone because I was bitten, I didn't want anyones blood on my hands if I turned before I found Clem. My thought was since I was dead anyway, I can suicide the last episode with no concern for myself, only rescuing Clem and getting her somewhere safe and with people who can care for her when I turn. I really hope she isn't the one to kill me, I'd prefer Kenny or a stranger.

[Ninja]

Originally Posted by NeonBlade

The thing is Christa is pregnant. I secretly know this. Why would she jeopardise here safety and potential child to tag along on what could be yet, another suicide mission?

That doesn't make sense.

[kirby18]

- let kenny kill him, which seemed to be the right decision because he sounded like he needed to, to get over the whole Duck thing

- saved Ben, which I dont regret I STILL HAVE FAITH that hes a good kid just unlucky and not the brightest kid. He promises he'll make it up so I trust him

- Showed the bite

- and took everyone with me besides kenny, I told him to f off so he can take the boat to nowhere by himself.

[Dee Jay]

I killed the boy. I'd let Kenny kill Duck so I figured I owed him this one. I think it's up there as one of the most horrible things I've had to do in a computer game with the walk to him and Lee's thoughts on seeing the empty water bottle, food bowl etc. I shot him as soon as I was close enough, anything else would have felt a bit too barbaric.

I took Clem with me to Crawford. If there was a choice to leave her at the house with someone besides a passed out Omid I'd have taken that. I'd also got into her bad books earlier in the episode when I tried to get her to go away from the dog carcass and obviously when you leave her to go with Kenny to look for a boat.

I saved Ben. I just couldn't bring myself to just let him fall to his death, even if he has proved himself to be completely useless so far.

I threatened Vernon. As much as his idea made sense you still don't really know anything about his group and the thought of Lee just willingly leaving Clem didn't sit right with me.

I showed the bite to everyone. I was close to hiding it but figured that wouldn't get me anywhere. Christa and Omid willingly came along with me and I talked Ben into coming along by pointing out how Clem had stuck up for him. Kenny mouthed off at me not caring about his family after the early days so I told him to go fuck himself.

I went with 'What do you want from me' as my final words. I didn't see the point in trying to threaten someone you can't see or know anything about.

[John W.]

Originally Posted by Dee Jay

I went with 'What do you want from me' as my final words. I didn't see the point in trying to threaten someone you can't see or know anything about.

Yeah, same. It's funny, though, because he just kinda ques up the radio and goes, "Dur?"

[Jingster]

1. I killed the boy zombie in the attic.

2. I saved ben just cause im a reasonable person and killing innocent people is wrong and also i see ben as actually taking care of clem after lee is gone even though at that point i didnt know lee will get bit!

3. I showed the bit cause i didnt want to get all the shit for not showing it and also i didnt want to randomly turn and bite somebody!

4.I took Omid, Ben and Christa with me and left Kenny with the boat cause i realy didnt like the attitude of Kenny towards Ben. I think Kenny was being unreasonable cause if Ben didnt give them the supplies in the third episode they would of attacked us earlier and we would not had the RV and would of died or just ran, but running would probably still get us killed or we would starve unless we get somekind of lucky break like the car int the second episode which i highly doublt.

[aguyuno]

Originally Posted by NeonBlade

Also it seems in my game. Lee is the whipping boy. I absolutely got whupped by Kenny in the train since I couldn't find the dot, and I couldn't press the button quick enough to stop Molly from flooring me. Well, atleast I'm a semi-competent Zombie killer.

I restarted the molly fight 5 times until I finally got her down. I was like NO. KENNY IS -NOT- SAVING ME.

Anyway...

I got Kenny to kill the kid. I hoped it would help snap him out of his stupor.

I brought Clementine because the only one staying behind to watch her would be Omid, who was sick and, frankly, could go zombie at any minute - who knew how infected he was? On top of that, considering the last couple times, she's clearly liable to just do whatever she wants anyway, and I did NOT want her following me into Crawford _by herself_. I don't think she does that if you don't take her, but I didn't want to take the chance.

I watched Molly's tape, told her I knew about it, and was kind but still demanded answers. We had told her most of our stuff, it's about time I got to know wtf about hers.

I saved Ben. I've had Lee in my file kill people (or basically kill people, like in the case of Lily and leaving her behind) on a couple occasions, specifically the St. John Brothers ("I said. It's. OVER." *BOOM*), but they've all deserved it and I've given the same justification to Clementine. Dropping Ben there would've been akin to the same kind of thing to me, and he DIDN'T deserve it. He's an idiot, yes, but not a bad person.

I told Vernon to walk away after he brought that up. Which rules cause then Lee slams him into a wall telling him straight up if you get between me and Clem, I'll kill you. Which is correct 100%.

I took Christa and Omid because I like them. Christa speaks her mind all the time, and Omid's the comic relief we desperately need in this group. I told Ben it was up to him, and he said he wanted to come with me so I was like aight. Aaand I told Kenny to go fuck himself because, seriously, fuck that guy.

Am I missing any choices? I'm sure there's a couple here but... yeah.

Oh. And I told the walkie talkie guy I'd fucking kill him. Though Lee doesn't say anything anyway so whatever.

[wolfen100]

I told Kenny to go f*** himself he was talking about how i never had his back and stuff. Whatever Kenny can die for all I care he always wanted you to support him like he was the only person in the group.

[Zombies are Awesome!]

Originally Posted by Jingster

4.I took Omid, Ben and Christa with me and left Kenny with the boat cause i realy didnt like the attitude of Kenny towards Ben. I think Kenny was being unreasonable cause if Ben didnt give them the supplies in the third episode they would of attacked us earlier and we would not had the RV and would of died or just ran, but running would probably still get us killed or we would starve unless we get somekind of lucky break like the car int the second episode which i highly doublt.

So your saying Kenny should have liked Ben for all his stupid decisions?

Are you fucking serious? Kenny should be fucking pissed at Ben

[Zombies are Awesome!]

Kenny told me "Lee you have always had my back, What kind of friend would i be if i didn't help you, Bitten or not im with you till the end"

[Ninja]

Originally Posted by Zombies are Awesome!

Kenny told me "Lee you have always had my back, What kind of friend would i be if i didn't help you, Bitten or not im with you till the end"

I got the same response.

[NeonBlade]

Originally Posted by Ninja

That doesn't make sense.

How do you mean? I mean would you want your pregnant wife going on a hunt for a little girl, walking into a clear trap with a psychopath and God knows who else.

Or stay at the well fortified house and hide till we get back?

[SkyPrincess213]

I killed the kid because it was pretty obvious that Kenny wouldn't be capable of doing it, and I didn't wanted that mini-walker to create problems.
I didn't brought Clem to Crawford, I was afraid that something happened to her
I saved Ben, because, seriously, he's human, he have his flaws. He was trying to protect the group when he was giving the bandits supplies, think, if he didn't, those bandits would kill him and attack the motor inn. Also, it's not totally his fault that Carley/Dough died, was Lilly's.
Saved Molly
Showed the bite
Told Vernon to go fuck himself
Brought everyone with me

[Kenny-Lee]

I convinced Kenny to shoot the boy in the attic
I've beaten Molly when i met her
I didn't show my bite , and went alone so i've cut my own arm off
didn't take clem to crawford (still have to trie if molly can die there)
I let Ben fall to his death.