Few questions about some characters.

[AnnaSan]

I'm very curious, and I just wanna hear your thoughts and opinions
(Idk if this may be considered as spoilers, but I just put it here just in case)

So I have few questions about some characters:
1.) We all know that Lee killed a senator for having an affair with his wife, but I wanna know he if he did it on purpose or accidentally?

2.) In Episode 1, My friend told me that if you don't choose between saving Doug and Carley, they both died. Does the story continue on, or do you have to replay that part and save one of them?

3.) I took Clem with me to Crawford(even though Vernon disapproves). What happens if you didn't take her with you?

4.) Is it a better choice to let Kenny kill the boy in the attic rather than me killing him? (Mine says it helped Kenny o.o)

5.) I was checking the wiki about Episode 4 and down at the trivia part it says, "The photo Molly shows you of her sister may just be a photo she stole from the house you are staying in, meaning Molly may have a plan to steal the boat. (This is hinted at by the fact that we see a smashed picture frame without a picture in it during a cut scene)"


What do you guys think?

[Red Panda]

Originally Posted by AnnaSan

I'm very curious, and I just wanna hear your thoughts and opinions
(Idk if this may be considered as spoilers, but I just put it here just in case)

So I have few questions about some characters:
1.) We all know that Lee killed a senator for having an affair with his wife, but I wanna know he if he did it on purpose or accidentally?

2.) In Episode 1, My friend told me that if you don't choose between saving Doug and Carley, they both died. Does the story continue on, or do you have to replay that part and save one of them?

3.) I took Clem with me to Crawford(even though Vernon disapproves). What happens if you didn't take her with you?

4.) Is it a better choice to let Kenny kill the boy in the attic rather than me killing him? (Mine says it helped Kenny o.o)

5.) I was checking the wiki about Episode 4 and down at the trivia part it says, "The photo Molly shows you of her sister may just be a photo she stole from the house you are staying in, meaning Molly may have a plan to steal the boat. (This is hinted at by the fact that we see a smashed picture frame without a picture in it during a cut scene)"


What do you guys think?

1. Accidently, he tells Carley
2. You have to replay to save one of them.
3. She kills a walker that gets into the house.
4. Who is to say? Maybe it will impact something in ep 5. but it doesn't seem to affect anything in ep 4
5. The photo Molly has looks smaller than the frame that was broken.

[AnnaSan]

Originally Posted by Red Panda

1. Accidently, he tells Carley

Thank you
but do you think he did kill the senator on purpose due to anger, or "accidentally"?

[Wydiwyg]

Originally Posted by AnnaSan

but do you think he did kill the senator on purpose due to anger, or "accidentally"?

It's what you think he did.
I'm pretty sure that we will never learn more about that, so we can fill in the blanks for ourselves. Him telling Carley about it might have been a lie, too.
Unless the guy on the radio turns out to be connected to the murder and tells a different story, nothing is set in stone.
That said, my personal Lee killed him due to anger and the heat of the moment, but he deserved it anyways. He wanted to cut the funding for Lee's University.

Regarding 5):
I don't know..it might be the case, as basically everything is possible, but to me, it just sounds like a theory as good or bad as any other one here on the forums. Never read that particular theory, though.

[Red Panda]

Originally Posted by AnnaSan

Thank you
but do you think he did kill the senator on purpose due to anger, or "accidentally"?

I never gave it much thought. I think the writers left it up in air because of the whole "tailored story" thing.

The way I'm playing Lee, I think it makes more sense it was an accident. If I was more aggressive I would go with a crime of passion.

[AnnaSan]

Originally Posted by Wydiwyg

It's what you think he did.
That said, my personal Lee killed him due to anger and the heat of the moment, but he deserved it anyways. He wanted to cut the funding for Lee's University.

Regarding 5):
I don't know..it might be the case, as basically everything is possible, but to me, it just sounds like a theory as good or bad as any other one here on the forums. Never read that particular theory, though.

Yeah, I honestly think the radio guy is somehow related to the senator or Lee since he seems more interested at Lee, and just using Clem as bait ._.

also I just read #5 on the wiki, and for sure it's not 100% reliable >.>

[AnnaSan]

Originally Posted by Red Panda

The way I'm playing Lee, I think it makes more sense it was an accident. If I was more aggressive I would go with a crime of passion.

You're right... although when the police officer was asking him if he was innocent, the look on his face seems very subtle

[Yertos]

Originally Posted by AnnaSan

I'm very curious, and I just wanna hear your thoughts and opinions
(Idk if this may be considered as spoilers, but I just put it here just in case)

So I have few questions about some characters:
1.) We all know that Lee killed a senator for having an affair with his wife, but I wanna know he if he did it on purpose or accidentally?

2.) In Episode 1, My friend told me that if you don't choose between saving Doug and Carley, they both died. Does the story continue on, or do you have to replay that part and save one of them?

3.) I took Clem with me to Crawford(even though Vernon disapproves). What happens if you didn't take her with you?

4.) Is it a better choice to let Kenny kill the boy in the attic rather than me killing him? (Mine says it helped Kenny o.o)

5.) I was checking the wiki about Episode 4 and down at the trivia part it says, "The photo Molly shows you of her sister may just be a photo she stole from the house you are staying in, meaning Molly may have a plan to steal the boat. (This is hinted at by the fact that we see a smashed picture frame without a picture in it during a cut scene)"


What do you guys think?

1.) Accident if you talk to Carley, but if you tell Katjaa you killed before and she asks if he would have killed you if you didn't he doesn't answer, somewhat implying he killed him on purpose (in the heat of the moment of course, doubt it was planned)

2.) They both die but story doesn't continue.

3.) She stays at the manor with a gun, or instructions to hide. If you gave her the gun you come home to a walker body, if not there's a walker in the broom closet.

4.) Personal opinion I guess, but I think he should. He needs to be able to do what needs to be done despite what he's been through, hard to do considering the boy looks like Duck and he just lost his whole family not long ago but if he really wants to live, he needs to move on from it somehow.

5.) First I'm hearing of this but I have noticed that smashed picture frame and thought about why someone would do that, but I believe you see that scene before meeting Molly making that a very big coincidence if true that you just happen to take shelter in that house. Correct me if I'm wrong though.

[Wydiwyg]

Originally Posted by AnnaSan

Yeah, I honestly think the radio guy is somehow related to the senator or Lee since he seems more interested at Lee, and just using Clem as bait ._.

Something tells me that this isn't the case, though. The way he talks to Clementine when Lee and Kenny hear it on the train sounds like he doesn't know anything about Lee except from what Clem told him. But then again, my knowledge about forensic psychology only comes from a couple of mediocre crime shows.
I wouldn't be surprised if this was something completely different, like a lone man who just wants to use the group to survive, maybe a maniac in a wheelchair who needs people to protect and feed him. That could be interesting when done right.

[AnnaSan]

Originally Posted by Yertos

5.) First I'm hearing of this but I have noticed that smashed picture frame and thought about why someone would do that, but I believe you see that scene before meeting Molly making that a very big coincidence if true that you just happen to take shelter in that house. Correct me if I'm wrong though.

It's actually the cut scene right after they found the boat : http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BYCz6gskd64&feature=plcp at 12:54

I honestly don't think Molly wouldn't do that though >.<

[AnnaSan]

Haha, people to protect and feed him.... I'ma kill him in episode 5!! D:<

because of him, Lee got bit ;___;