Telltale Games

Crixus · 10/19/2012, 12:29 pm

Just a thought about episode 5,i am interested to see what people would do in the following scenario. You have to choose between saving Clementine or Christa,Omid,Kenny and Ben if you brought them all with you. Would you let 4 die just to save 1?

DreadMagus · 10/19/2012, 12:31 pm

They elected to come, Clem had no choice.

Plus, Clem's "my - via Lee" responsibility.

Clem comes first.

QuarterPounderVlad · 10/19/2012, 12:33 pm

Everyone else. Even though I love Clem I'm not about to let 4 people die for 1. Even though she's a kid. Sorry Queen Clementine D:

Viser · 10/19/2012, 12:43 pm

Nope. I would feel selfish if I allowed four people to die because of only one person. Even if it's Clemmy. I'm pretty sure it won't come to that, but I would feel heartbroken either way.

KingOfTheDead · 10/19/2012, 12:52 pm

i would defiantly save clem. everyone in the group can be a d*ck except omid. christa always questioning how i raise clem. Kenny he was cool at the beginning now hes a d*ck just because i didn't kill larry or ben

DreadMagus · 10/19/2012, 12:55 pm

Selfish?

Omid and Christa forced themselves into the group - I told them all I wanted to go solo..... I'm not responsible for them.

Zeruis · 10/19/2012, 01:19 pm

Friends or acquaintances can get out. Parenting a little girl matters the most.

Phoenix VII · 10/19/2012, 01:26 pm

So long as Clem's mom is missing and there's no one else I can pawn her off to, I'd choose everyone else without hesitation. Sorry Clem-Clem, but how long can an 8 year-old survive in a ZA without anyone else to take care of her? Lee's dead after all.

Foinikas · 10/19/2012, 01:35 pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Crixus

Just a thought about episode 5,i am interested to see what people would do in the following scenario. You have to choose between saving Clementine or Christa,Omid,Kenny and Ben if you brought them all with you. Would you let 4 die just to save 1?

Somehow you sounded like Jigsaw asking that in my head... lol :P

Walker#8 · 10/19/2012, 01:39 pm

Okay just to clarify by voting it is who we would let die or who we would choose to remain alive? Ask yourself this question if you could sacrifice either direction, How long before you begin to feel like Ben and going crazy from the guilt?

ZacTB · 10/19/2012, 03:27 pm

Yeah I would choose everyone else. That would be a hard choice, but I would never save 1 life over 4 lives, as much as Clementine means to Lee.

Wydiwyg · 10/19/2012, 04:12 pm

Everyone else. I couldn't care less about Ben, but even 3 is pragmatically preferable to 1, especially since in a ZA, age doesn't matter too much anyways. It's not like there's still any society left for the kids to grow into.

trd84 · 10/19/2012, 04:24 pm

At this point Clem is like my daughter. What parent wouldn't chose their child?

trd84 · 10/19/2012, 04:32 pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Wydiwyg

Everyone else. I couldn't care less about Ben, but even 3 is pragmatically preferable to 1, especially since in a ZA, age doesn't matter too much anyways. It's not like there's still any society left for the kids to grow into.

You'd fit right in, in Crawford.

xXNinjaScoreXx · 10/19/2012, 04:39 pm

As much as I love Clem, I had to go with everyone else, the more people alive that can pull their own weight = the better.

trd84 · 10/19/2012, 04:42 pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by xXNinjaScoreXx

As much as I love Clem, I had to go with everyone else, the more people alive that can pull their own weight = the better.

The more people alive the more people who can screw up. And Omid and Christa is about to have a child they're not going to put the group before the baby. Ben is useless. Kenny is too emotional and will throw you to the wolves in a heart beat.

And Lee's about to die his only worry should be about Clem and not 2 people he just met, a guy who has almost gotten them killed numerous times and a guy who doesn't like him if you don't kill someone.

Rock114 · 10/19/2012, 04:43 pm

Christa, Omid, and Kenny all volunteered. They know the risks and how it could end for them. Clem is an 8-year-old girl who was kidnapped. I'd pick Clem every time, but a huge downside to that is that she'd be all on her own since Lee is bitten, and I would have been letting the other 4 die to save her.

xXNinjaScoreXx · 10/19/2012, 05:19 pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by trd84

The more people alive the more people who can screw up. And Omid and Christa is about to have a child they're not going to put the group before the baby. Ben is useless. Kenny is too emotional and will throw you to the wolves in a heart beat.

And Lee's about to die his only worry should be about Clem and not 2 people he just met, a guy who has almost gotten them killed numerous times and a guy who doesn't like him if you don't kill someone.

I really like Clem, but she can't use a gun as effectively as a whole group. So, survival wise, yes, everyone else would be better.

KingOfTheDead · 10/19/2012, 05:25 pm

My Little sweat pea of course :3

bdawgnit1785 · 10/19/2012, 05:27 pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by xXNinjaScoreXx

I really like Clem, but she can't use a gun as effectively as a whole group. So, survival wise, yes, everyone else would be better.

The point is though we are not trying to ensure long term survival of our group. Anyone who came is on a suicide run to if not save clementine then at least avenge her death. Everyone knows this is death's door and we are repeatedly ringing the doorbell like maniacal girl scouts trying to make quota so we are not beaten by the head mistress

View Poll Results: Clementine or Everyone Else?
Clementine	96	70.59%
Kenny,Christa,Omid and Ben	40	29.41%
Voters: 136. You may not vote on this poll

10/19/2012, 12:29 pm	#1
Crixus Senior Member Join Date: Sep 2012 Location: Not in Kenny's boat anyways! (Thanks alot Vernon....) Posts: 284	Clementine or everyone else? Just a thought about episode 5,i am interested to see what people would do in the following scenario. You have to choose between saving Clementine or Christa,Omid,Kenny and Ben if you brought them all with you. Would you let 4 die just to save 1?

10/19/2012, 12:31 pm	#2
DreadMagus Arrgh! Thar Be Zombies! Join Date: Sep 2012 Location: The space between worlds. Posts: 2,089	They elected to come, Clem had no choice. Plus, Clem's "my - via Lee" responsibility. Clem comes first. __________________ WITCH! Oh sorry, got confused by all your crying. ~ Francis

10/19/2012, 12:52 pm	#5
KingOfTheDead The Protector Of Clem Join Date: Oct 2012 Location: In The Place Of Great Ritual Posts: 874	i would defiantly save clem. everyone in the group can be a dck except omid. christa always questioning how i raise clem. Kenny he was cool at the beginning now hes a dck just because i didn't kill larry or ben __________________ I am Sir KingOfTheDead the greatest of all queen clementines knights. Protector of the Crown

10/19/2012, 12:55 pm	#6
DreadMagus Arrgh! Thar Be Zombies! Join Date: Sep 2012 Location: The space between worlds. Posts: 2,089	Selfish? Omid and Christa forced themselves into the group - I told them all I wanted to go solo..... I'm not responsible for them. __________________ WITCH! Oh sorry, got confused by all your crying. ~ Francis

10/19/2012, 12:33 pm	#3
QuarterPounderVlad Senior Member Join Date: Sep 2012 Posts: 586	Everyone else. Even though I love Clem I'm not about to let 4 people die for 1. Even though she's a kid. Sorry Queen Clementine D:

10/19/2012, 12:43 pm	#4
Viser Ben is a cool guy Join Date: Aug 2012 Location: Brazil Posts: 422	Nope. I would feel selfish if I allowed four people to die because of only one person. Even if it's Clemmy. I'm pretty sure it won't come to that, but I would feel heartbroken either way.

10/19/2012, 01:19 pm	#7
Zeruis Mundy Join Date: Jun 2012 Posts: 1,942	Friends or acquaintances can get out. Parenting a little girl matters the most.

10/19/2012, 01:26 pm	#8
Phoenix VII Senior Member Join Date: Jul 2012 Posts: 255	So long as Clem's mom is missing and there's no one else I can pawn her off to, I'd choose everyone else without hesitation. Sorry Clem-Clem, but how long can an 8 year-old survive in a ZA without anyone else to take care of her? Lee's dead after all.

10/19/2012, 01:39 pm	#10
Walker#8 Member Join Date: Sep 2012 Posts: 62	Okay just to clarify by voting it is who we would let die or who we would choose to remain alive? Ask yourself this question if you could sacrifice either direction, How long before you begin to feel like Ben and going crazy from the guilt?

10/19/2012, 03:27 pm	#11
ZacTB Woodbury Bound Join Date: May 2012 Posts: 234	Yeah I would choose everyone else. That would be a hard choice, but I would never save 1 life over 4 lives, as much as Clementine means to Lee.

10/19/2012, 04:12 pm	#12
Wydiwyg Member Join Date: Oct 2012 Posts: 36	Everyone else. I couldn't care less about Ben, but even 3 is pragmatically preferable to 1, especially since in a ZA, age doesn't matter too much anyways. It's not like there's still any society left for the kids to grow into. __________________ So long, and thanks for all the fish.

10/19/2012, 04:24 pm	#13
trd84 Senior Member Join Date: Jun 2012 Posts: 368	At this point Clem is like my daughter. What parent wouldn't chose their child?

10/19/2012, 04:39 pm	#15
xXNinjaScoreXx Ninjas Can Play Games Too Join Date: Sep 2012 Location: In The Shadows Posts: 228	As much as I love Clem, I had to go with everyone else, the more people alive that can pull their own weight = the better. __________________ "It Happened Pretty Fast..."

10/19/2012, 04:43 pm	#17
Rock114 Senior Member Join Date: Jul 2012 Location: U.S. of A. Posts: 1,703	Christa, Omid, and Kenny all volunteered. They know the risks and how it could end for them. Clem is an 8-year-old girl who was kidnapped. I'd pick Clem every time, but a huge downside to that is that she'd be all on her own since Lee is bitten, and I would have been letting the other 4 die to save her.

10/19/2012, 05:25 pm	#19
KingOfTheDead The Protector Of Clem Join Date: Oct 2012 Location: In The Place Of Great Ritual Posts: 874	My Little sweat pea of course :3 __________________ I am Sir KingOfTheDead the greatest of all queen clementines knights. Protector of the Crown

Thread Tools	Search this Thread
Show Printable Version Email this Page	Search this Thread: Advanced Search

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
Lee's decisions finally catching up to Clementine in the final episode	darknessofheart	The Walking Dead Story Discussion - SPOILERS	8	11/18/2012 07:04 am
Clementine as the protagonist in season 2??	Dreamjbk	The Walking Dead Story Discussion - SPOILERS	26	10/17/2012 01:47 pm
Episode 4 Review and Predictions	Gregory2012	The Walking Dead Story Discussion - SPOILERS	3	10/16/2012 06:50 am
Clementine is leading you to your death..	ElderBoss	The Walking Dead Story Discussion - SPOILERS	44	09/28/2012 03:28 am
Episode Three – Long Road Ahead Review (Spoilers)	Gregory2012	The Walking Dead Story Discussion - SPOILERS	0	08/29/2012 07:30 pm