[SPOILERS] CARLEY [Ep 3 discussion]

[KingOfTheDead]

what about doug lol no one cares about him anyway

[linch]

many people are dissipointed and so am i and i think she lived some one is even making a little book on how she survived and rejoined the group

[Danno123]

You're gonna stop playing a game because a character died?
People will die, and just because they do doesn't mean you should quit playing, especially if it's a game like The Walking Dead, where you should EXPECT death.

[Leegacy]

even though carley (and doug) was an awesome character bringing her back from the dead would be too horrible for her because she would have to travel for an insane distance and when she found out that katjaa,duck (and maybe ben) were dead,lee had been bitten and clemmy stolen by the "crazy fucker on the radio" she would probably put the bullet in her head herself because ultimatly lily prevented her from seeing those horrors i do miss carley though

[fd1972uk]

Yep was sad that Carley ended up dying. Although initially I had saved Doug, more because she had a gun and thought she'd be fine.

But I had 2 saves with Carley and Doug on each, obviously that's went to pot now.

But after the motel talk it was a tough loss for Lee.


FD

[enpeper]

Why did you have to kill carly😭. Doing this honestly made me cry in real life. Carley became my favourite character in any video game! I just wish that there was a way to save her but you guys pretty much ruined the best game I've ever played. But I'm still gonna finish the game because I bought all of the episodes at once. I just wish that you could of saved her somehow or that the bullet misses her brain and she somehow lives. I was even only Lily's side until this happened but once she shot Carley, Kenny And Clementine became the only people left that I can trust and Kenny Seems to hate me because I sided with Lily. Well you can probably guess I decided to leave Lily behind and will kill Ben if I get the chance.

[RabidMonkey]

Seriously Carley is dead as sad as that is to say. There should have been an option to save her and still have Lilly leave in order for the comic canon. Unfortunately she is dead or a 99.5% chance of being dead.

What I would like is an alternate version of Season one where you can make additional choices. E.g you can pour all your affection into Lilly at the cost of Kenny's but in doins so you can persuade her not to shoot Carley/Doug. But she still leaves seeing as she threatened the group. So it still makes the game hard as Kenny still hates you but you can save Carley/Doug . If they made this I would easily buy it as I loved this game until Carley died.

[T800kaz]

Originally Posted by RabidMonkey

Seriously Carley is dead as sad as that is to say. There should have been an option to save her and still have Lilly leave in order for the comic canon. Unfortunately she is dead or a 99.5% chance of being dead.

What I would like is an alternate version of Season one where you can make additional choices. E.g you can pour all your affection into Lilly at the cost of Kenny's but in doins so you can persuade her not to shoot Carley/Doug. But she still leaves seeing as she threatened the group. So it still makes the game hard as Kenny still hates you but you can save Carley/Doug . If they made this I would easily buy it as I loved this game until Carley died.

It would be cool if they added some dlc for alternate outcomes for Carley and other characters

[Viner16]

These people who quit after Carley's death have obviously never seen the mediums of TWD.

[Sotter]

Originally Posted by T800kaz

It would be cool if they added some dlc for alternate outcomes for Carley and other characters

No. Check alternative ending thread to see why. Could someone lock this thread? Carley is 1000000000% dead and no news for her seem to released.

[Mornai]

Originally Posted by Sotter

No. Check alternative ending thread to see why. Could someone lock this thread? Carley is 1000000000% dead and no news for her seem to released.

That's hardly fair. Just because there's nothing new on a character doesn't mean any discussion about them should be forbidden. Otherwise every thread here would be locked excepting season 2 discussion.

[Sotter]

Originally Posted by Mornai

That's hardly fair. Just because there's nothing new on a character doesn't mean any discussion about them should be forbidden. Otherwise every thread here would be locked excepting season 2 discussion.

You are right. But seeing another suggestion for alternative endings, well that sent me in Rage Mode. I tend to get mad easily, just like Larry. (Alas my head shall be smashed.)

[double_u]

I like how this thread manages to find its way back to the front page every once in a while. It just goes to show that the character was well written and well received, and new players are getting a chance to vent months after episode 3 has been done.

[Mark$man]

^ THAT or... we need season 2 just that badly xD

[Sotter]

Originally Posted by Mark$man

^ THAT or... we need season 2 just that badly xD

Who knows? I only know that i dont want s2 to be like heroes post season 1.

[RabidMonkey]

I guess people just miss certain characters and would have wanted to have them in the game more. I mean Carley was a fan-favorite to a lot of people just like Kenny and Lilly were to some. I guess what I am saying is it wasn't essential to kill Carley/Doug at that point in the game seeing as Duck and Kat die soon after. Carley could have lived a bit longer and if she was going to die then have her die in episode 5. Because for me I felt like there was going to be a lot more moments with her in the game e.g romance with Lee. But sadly that was taken away. No harm in wanting a DLC/patch to experience more with characters and providing more content over all.

[40965gamer]

I have just played episode three up to the point where Carly is killed,it really upset me and turned me off on the game,not only I won't be playing the rest of the game,I won't be buying anymore games from telltale ever,telltale sucks'i really love Carly and they ruined the game for me

[ZeroShoot]

Originally Posted by 40965gamer

I have just played episode three up to the point where Carly is killed,it really upset me and turned me off on the game,not only I won't be playing the rest of the game,I won't be buying anymore games from telltale ever,telltale sucks'i really love Carly and they ruined the game for me

Wow, probably the most stupid reason to stop playing a game I've heard lately... So if an actual apocalypse breaks out, and the crawlies get someone you care about, you won't avenge them? Won't keep going? You'll just move a gun up to your head and end it?

Don't say "Telltale sucks" because they have the balls to do something other companies couldn't, it's not all sunshine and rainbows in the apocalypse. It's dust, devastation, despair, death, depression, the 5 D's

[aaron1290]

Originally Posted by ZeroShoot

Wow, probably the most stupid reason to stop playing a game I've heard lately... So if an actual apocalypse breaks out, and the crawlies get someone you care about, you won't avenge them? Won't keep going? You'll just move a gun up to your head and end it?

Honestly, I would... Who would want to live in a world without your computer, friends, family and you're just stuck in a little camp. No Food. No water. No Meds. No nothin.

- MOO! -