Let's say you didn't steal from the stationwagon...

[izzywozzy]

The dad's spark of revenge comes from them stealing the supplies! So what if you didn't steal from it?

[thespanner]

I didn't, and he was still an asshole. He judges you for a variety of choices you made throughout. He angered me so much, as though Clem would do better with him!? His own children didn't!

[AceStarr]

He still wants to keep Clem

1)When he ask do you know who i am? I say yes

2)Then he goes you must have seen my car and i say yes

3) He says No matter...after much chitter chatter he says im evil and i dont even know Clems Age ...which i say 8 and he says know she turned 9 FIVE days ago
he says he will keep her and kill me so they can be a "FAMILY"

[lilTomTom]

He still doesn't trust/like you and treats you like the root of all his problems. When in reality he brought it on himself by taking his son out in the forest to go hunt.

I guess he wanted to look for someone to blame. Even though the others stole from the van. It looked abandoned anyways. I didn't steal anything because Clementine thought it was wrong and I felt like someone was still around.

But the thing that made me kill him. The guy lost it. He kept his dead wife's head in a bowling ball bag... And what would stop him from trying to take another little child to fix his 'family'. He needed to be killed and put out of his torment. It was almost a kind gesture.

[Mornai]

If you don't steal, he says initially he wasn't out for you, just your group. However, he then says he slowly started to turn against you after the decisions you make, which Clementine tells him about.

As for me, he attacked me for:

Leaving Lilly on the side of the road.

Taking Clementine with me to Crawford.

I think one more thing but i can't remember at the moment. I wonder what happens if you do everything "right" in his eyes? I.e. leaving Clementine at the manor, not abandoning Lilly, etc.

[lilTomTom]

Originally Posted by Mornai

If you don't steal, he says initially he wasn't out for you, just your group. However, he then says he slowly started to turn against you after the decisions you make, which Clementine tells him about.

As for me, he attacked me for:

Leaving Lilly on the side of the road.

Taking Clementine with me to Crawford.

I think one more thing but i can't remember at the moment. I wonder what happens if you do everything "right" in his eyes? I.e. leaving Clementine at the manor, not abandoning Lilly, etc.

I dont think it mattered what you did. The guy was off his rocker.

[Fezzan]

He's still like "NO, we have to make an interesting story point so I'm gonna hate you! No matter if you were a good guy and I'm a crazy maniac."

[Kiel555]

Originally Posted by izzywozzy

The dad's spark of revenge comes from them stealing the supplies! So what if you didn't steal from it?

He brings up other things. Like when I killed Danny with the pitchfork or chose the pretty girl over the boy (Carley and Doug I suppose) blah blah blah. I just responded with silence. Who the hell is he to judge me anyways psycho bastard.

Clem hit him on the head with a bottle and I strangled him with both hands. There's your answer Campman and yes I do think you are a monster.

[Luigi01080]

well for most of these choices i did the right thing so i got less yelling. I saved doug(mostly cause he was cool), saved the st.john brothers, let lily back on the rv, shot duck, had kenny shoot the boy in the attic, brought clementine to crawford(mostly because i got episode 4 spoiled sort of and wanted to save molly). Campman went crazy just like jolene from episode 2, he lost his kids, his wife, and his sanity and he cant judge anyone.

[cojemo]

Originally Posted by Luigi01080

well for most of these choices i did the right thing so i got less yelling. I saved doug(mostly cause he was cool), saved the st.john brothers, let lily back on the rv, shot duck, had kenny shoot the boy in the attic, brought clementine to crawford(mostly because i got episode 4 spoiled sort of and wanted to save molly). Campman went crazy just like jolene from episode 2, he lost his kids, his wife, and his sanity and he cant judge anyone.

What did he say was bad for you? bringing clem to crawford was bad for him. ( I didn't ) Also, I like how he brought up small things, like how Clem was wearing his sons sweater.

[george1120]

Originally Posted by AceStarr

He still wants to keep Clem

1)When he ask do you know who i am? I say yes

2)Then he goes you must have seen my car and i say yes

3) He says No matter...after much chitter chatter he says im evil and i dont even know Clems Age ...which i say 8 and he says know she turned 9 FIVE days ago
he says he will keep her and kill me so they can be a "FAMILY"

never got that second option and he told me six days ago.