So, now we have all five episodes who's going to play them all in a row?

[CelestialSpiral]

I will be doing at some point just too make different choices to what I made the first time....
I mean I wonder what would the out come be if I did not steal the food from the back of the car?.I wonder what conversation I would hear from the guy in Episode5 if I had not stole it.
Please do not tell me if you did the opposite to what I did.

[plaqueconspiracy]

I've played through the first 3 at least 4 times I think. But I'll be doing it again... The only downside is to do all the "assemble swing" parts... Look at that. Look at that. Because if there is an icon, I will click it. Even if I've seen it 200 times. And that sucks.

[PerttuLaulaa]

I need a brake. may be on January. last ep. was so sad its made me sick, so... need time.

[deadman67797]

I'm playing them all straight when the last day before the VGA's come. I want Telltale to win GOTY.

[Christoaster]

Honestly... This game is hard to replay... Replaying a story that is already laid out for your is not really that fun. Although... it's extremely fun the first time playing it. Things are SO fucking tense it's so interesting and seriously stellar to play... This game is story driven which makes it so hard to replay, since you already knows what happens...

Not saying this game should change it's style (IT SHOULDN'T, it's what makes it special) but a game with more satisfying gameplay makes it more replayable. This game isn't a game you'd want to replay... It's more like the same gameplay but with slightly different experiences based on what you said.

Which is not interesting to me... I HATE rewinding, because it ruins the realism. I never rewinded and stuck with my choices because It's probably what I would have chosen in real if i didn't have much time to think about it. That's what i love about this game.

They give you a timer to make the choices, because in life in dire situations you don't have that much time to make decisions. Which brings a whole erra of realism and emotion...

[CelestialSpiral]

I hear what your saying Christoaster.It is like who reads a stephen king book twice.Not many people if I had to guess.
I also belive the dialog only changers on the different choices you make not the actual game play?
Saying all this though I could be wrong and if I am ? someone will let me know Im sure.
But my vote is still the same,at somepoint I will play it again.......

[Shatilov]

Finished them twice. with different alliances, and choices. I hated Larry real bad in both plays. He is just unlikable, no matter how u look at it.

[dee23]

Originally Posted by CelestialSpiral

I will be doing at some point just too make different choices to what I made the first time....
I mean I wonder what would the out come be if I did not steal the food from the back of the car?.I wonder what conversation I would hear from the guy in Episode5 if I had not stole it.
Please do not tell me if you did the opposite to what I did.

Sorry to be the bearer of bad news but choice doesn't really matter. I had 2 files running for each episode. I only played my first file for episode 5 where my Lee didn't take the food and it made no difference from your play through. The guy still wanted to kill me and keep Clementine because I was with the people who ate his food. Replay it by all means, I will be, but don't expect much changes. The same events are still scripted to happen and the same scenes are used just with different responses from the group members with you. In my play through of ep5 I let Christa and Omid cross the walk way with the banner first and it collapsed so I couldn't follow. I thought fair enough it made sense, he even pointed out Christa had more weight cause she was pregnant but Omid was the lightest. When I watched the youtube play through the guy playing chose to go first and the walk way collapsed straight after Lee passed so Christa and Omid couldn't follow. He then told them to go to the train just as I did.

[CelestialSpiral]

Originally Posted by dee23

Sorry to be the bearer of bad news but choice doesn't really matter. I had 2 files running for each episode. I only played my first file for episode 5 where my Lee didn't take the food and it made no difference from your play through. The guy still wanted to kill me and keep Clementine because I was with the people who ate his food. Replay it by all means, I will be, but don't expect much changes. The same events are still scripted to happen and the same scenes are used just with different responses from the group members with you. In my play through of ep5 I let Christa and Omid cross the walk way with the banner first and it collapsed so I couldn't follow. I thought fair enough it made sense, he even pointed out Christa had more weight cause she was pregnant but Omid was the lightest. When I watched the youtube play through the guy playing chose to go first and the walk way collapsed straight after Lee passed so Christa and Omid couldn't follow. He then told them to go to the train just as I did.

Hi there mate

Yeah I had a feeling the core game play would not change much,if at all.
Like we have agreed it is just the dialog that changes.
It would have been nice if the core game play did change due to your choices.
Would have giving it a bigger reply value as to play it again to see how the story would have gone if you did Y instead of X.
Although the game we were all given I still enjoyed very much,but like many have said I can not see myself playing through it more then twice.
But then again you never know,10 years down the line I may put my 720 away and dig out the 360 and give it a play through again for nostalgia lol.

As to the bit in your quote :

In my play through of ep5 I let Christa and Omid cross the walk way with the banner first and it collapsed so I couldn't follow. I thought fair enough it made sense, he even pointed out Christa had more weight cause she was pregnant but Omid was the lightest.

I went across myself and it did the same although I am glad I did as there is a chance to do something cool involving mass slaughtering some zombies with a meat clever

[Saoralba131]

I want to make other choices,and see how that plays out,so yes,in fact I am just now.