F*** Lily thread

[CrazyandProud]

The worst character in the game next to Larry. She kills innocent people. She doesn't want to help people in need. Doesn't say any to her father after he literally tries to kill you. Later on in the comics she helps kill Rick's wife and a baby. She doesn't go out into the field together supplies, but still bitches about how things are handled. She also steal the RV, leaving everyone else to rot. All she does for the group is whine and complain.

She can burn in hell.

[Rock114]

I find it hard to count Judith and Lori's deaths on her, as the Governor had manipulated everyone in Woodbury into thinking that Rick's group was a bunch of monsters and barbarians with no humanity. She didn;t know she was shooting a mother and her infant child, she just thought she was shooting at some bandit who'd killed a lot of her friends. By the time she actually found out the truth, it was too late.

[YamiRaziel]

Also, she doesn't know that Larry tried to kill you back there.
The amount of copycat topics around here is getting ridiculous...

[Rock114]

Originally Posted by YamiRaziel

Also, she doesn't know that Larry tried to kill you back there.

But they find out. Mark knows in Episode 2, so it stands to reason everyone else does as well. Kenny most likely knows, considering he's the one that saves you after it happens. Lilly would probably know too, at least later, yet she never has any words with Larry concerning him treating Lee better after he saved his life and all.

[CrazyandProud]

Originally Posted by YamiRaziel

Also, she doesn't know that Larry tried to kill you back there.
The amount of copycat topics around here is getting ridiculous...

Yeah, because that would not come up.

[Zeruis]

Hold up here. Without Lilly, Rick would be dead. Lilly kills the governor, who was about to kill off Rick and Carl. Besides, she showed complete distress in killing a mother and her child.

[Rock114]

Actually, the Governor told the remnants of the Woodbury army to leave Rick and Carl because they were running through a group of walkers. He reasoned that Rick had a deathwish after seeing Lori die, and began making preparations to get the woodbury soldiers that remained into the prison to fortify and clean it out.

[Yertos]

And with the Road to Woodbury book making what seems like a completely different Lilly, our Lilly here might not even be the one who does that, I would much prefer her to be a different Lilly then a pretty big plot hole of a character. Plus if they're different then we can get Lilly for Season 2! Fingers crossed...

[Robbingrobin]

Originally Posted by Yertos

And with the Road to Woodbury book making what seems like a completely different Lilly, our Lilly here might not even be the one who does that, I would much prefer her to be a different Lilly then a pretty big plot hole of a character. Plus if they're different then we can get Lilly for Season 2! Fingers crossed...

Good god! THANK YOU. I thought I'd be the only one who would see this.

[CrazyandProud]

Originally Posted by Zeruis

Hold up here. Without Lilly, Rick would be dead. Lilly kills the governor, who was about to kill off Rick and Carl. Besides, she showed complete distress in killing a mother and her child.

They already gotten away at that point and were surrounded by zombies, that is when she killed him.

[chiefzackery]

Awwwww they took down my fuck you jenny pitcher thread altleast this is still up

[CarScar]

I just replayed the game for the billionth time, lost a little respect for Lilly. I thought at the beginning she didn't want to kick Duck out and was only trying to calm her dad down... Nope.

"Calm down dad, we'll get rid of this kid and..."

[Kaserkin]

Originally Posted by CarScar

I just replayed the game for the billionth time, lost a little respect for Lilly. I thought at the beginning she didn't want to kick Duck out and was only trying to calm her dad down... Nope.

"Calm down dad, we'll get rid of this kid and..."

She's still alright though.

Oh. Jesus. Mary. That. Stupid. Bitch.
Now I feel bad to not have supported Kenny in episode 2.

[Rock114]

Also in the pharmacy...

"That violence with my dad earlier didn't help." (if you defend Kenny).

So I guess she'd rather a harmless child die than her dad getting a little upset. And people say that Kenny is the only one who doesn't care about anyone but his family...

[Yertos]

But if you side with Larry she says something like "By the way, I don't think my Dad was right", playing through again soon so I'll update later with the exact quote.

[Rock114]

But at the same time, she wasn't going to stand up to Larry and tell him he was wrong. If he says that the kid is getting thrown out, Lilly says so too. In fact, I think that it's even worse if she doesn't agree with her dad, but is willing to let Duck die anyway. If she truly thought Larry was wrong, she would have actually stood up to him like my Lee did. Instead she was willing to let her father, who she claims is actually "a good person", kill a child because he's afraid.

[NSS]

Originally Posted by Rock114

Also in the pharmacy...

"That violence with my dad earlier didn't help." (if you defend Kenny).

So I guess she'd rather a harmless child die than her dad getting a little upset. And people say that Kenny is the only one who doesn't care about anyone but his family...

Lilly was far and away more pragmatic than Kenny. Always refused to help people that weren't an asset or could potentially be a liability. She would've fit in great at Crawford.

Then her father died, and Kenny turned her philosophy on her. Irony at its finest.

Carley calling Lilly a "scared little girl" that pretends to be a "tough bitch" was a beautiful summation of her character.

[plaqueconspiracy]

If I was given the option to take her gun and shoot her I would've shot her twice.
She didn't want someone to ruin everything for everyone else yet she did that very thing. Selfish. Dumb. Mentally disturbed. Bitch.

I see some of you are talking about her in season 2.
.... I would like her to be the protagonist. That would be pretty cool if this is a different Lilly.

[Rock114]

I wouldn't go so far as to say that I hate her guts, or that I would shoot her. The thought never crossed my mind, even after she killed Carley. I still cut her loose though. What she did was straight up murder, because someone insulted her. Even if it had been actually put to a vote by the group, I have no doubt it would have been unanimous. I'm glad I exiled Lilly. She was too dangerous to have around.

[YamiRaziel]

Originally Posted by NSS

Lilly was far and away more pragmatic than Kenny. Always refused to help people that weren't an asset or could potentially be a liability. She would've fit in great at Crawford.

Then her father died, and Kenny turned her philosophy on her. Irony at its finest.

Carley calling Lilly a "scared little girl" that pretends to be a "tough bitch" was a beautiful summation of her character.

What is call irony is Lee asking whether Kenny would've done the hard thing if it was Duck or Katjaa and then his replay "That's never gonna happen. Not if I had anything to do with it".
Entire episode 3 was just so good...