Quote:
Originally Posted by MattP
Unfortunately Windows 8 is not currently a supported platform, however all games have been shown to run without a controller plugged in. The workaround listed in the other thread should be able to assist anyone who needs a controller to play any of our games.
We do want to investigate this further, so if anyone can specify whether they have Win 8 32-bit or 64-bit, that would be helpful. Thanks.
|
Hi Matt,
Thank you for an "official" TellTale response. Although my post-count and general forum activity certainly won't show it, I've been a fan of your games for quite awhile, starting with the Sam & Max revamp actually. Your support and interaction with the community have always been top notch and I've been a strong advocate for the way your company does business in an industry that continually eschews good support for a higher profit margin.
However, I would ask that your company please not drop the ball on the incredibly important aspect of making all your games, not just TWD, 100% feature compliant with Windows 8. In my opinion, this is an outright necessity.
As a developer (not games), I understand that there are many ways to solve the problem outlined in my OP. The first you already alluded to in that none of your games list Windows 8 as a supported OS in the system requirements. This is all fine and good, but Windows 8 isn't going away anytime in the near future. Even certified "duds" like Windows ME and Vista lasted a number of years before they were supplanted by something more widely adopted. That said, nearly all consumer class PC's from major brands such as Dell, HP, Acer, et. al. are now shipping with some variant of Windows 8 pre-installed. Taking what I would consider the lowest road (i.e.; "our games aren't compatible") would be tantamount to shooting yourselves in the foot as far as further sales of your titles go.
Of course since the games run fine on Windows 8 other than the controller support, you could simply add a line to the requirements that gamepads are not supported on the latest OS. Again, I think this would be a mistake... both for new Windows 8 PC buyers as well as upgraders like myself. Anyone who attempts to play one of your games with a controller plugged in will be greeted with absolutely nothing when attempting to run TWD, BttF, or generally any other TellTale game I'd surmise. With no error message to go on or feedback other than slogging through the event log for "hints", the user will likely be left with the feeling that their game simply "doesn't work." I'm sure that's not the impression your company wants to make. Again, Windows 8 isn't going anywhere anytime soon.
At a minimum, I feel that either a message on runtime that "controllers are not supported on Windows 8" if one is plugged in or an update that effectively removes controller support and allows the game to run would be necessary. This is one of those kinds of issues where I think you need to do something. You can't just leave the situation to chance and hope that the user reads what you've wrote and/or fully understands what you're trying to convey.
Bottom line is that I feel this problem needs to be actively addressed one way or the other. Definitely in the here and now, since Windows 8 will only become more prolific and Telltale games affected are actively sold on your website as well as other digital distribution channels. Also, what of the future with TWD season 2, Fables, and other Telltale games? The problem will need to rectified eventually. Why not do it the "right way" and put in the work to add controller support back to the games/engine for Windows 8 without workarounds that involve downloading core components from what may be questionable sources?
With that, I've effectively said my peace. Given your track record, I trust the TellTale team will do the right thing here. Thanks for hearing me out.