What did Campman tell you?

[Master of Aeons]

"You are a highly skilled warrior, well suited for this mission."
"I see that you like to play Sam and Max. As well as Tales of Monkey Island... You also like Puzzle Agent..."
"Hmmm. You have not saved often."

[slough]

On my first save, he pointed out that I brought Clem to the dairy, left Lilly on the side of the road, and brought Clem to Crawford. I'll update this post when I play through my other saves.

[Donut Funn]

"You killed a man with a pitchfork right in front of a little girl!"
"You let a boy get pulled into the night so you could save a pretty girl with a gun!"
"You brought her to the most dangerous place in this city where she could have died!"

[Zeruis]

Well, radio guy asked me why I brought Clem to the St. John dairy. And then he asked why I left Lilly out in the road, and why I brought Clem to Crawford.

[Harry Callahan]

He complained about me bringing Clem to the St. John Dairy and saving "a pretty girl with a gun" over Doug. An unloaded gun, you jackass.

I'm actually kind of surprised Lee didn't know about Clem's birthday; a lot has been going on recently, but the last three chapters have only covered a few days, if I'm figuring right. Wouldn't they still have been back at the motel six days ago? It's weird she didn't mention it to people.

[Tomi021]

Originally Posted by Rock114

He called me on killing Danny and leaving Lilly. He had no idea why my Lee did the things he did, and I stuck by my choices. I'd challenge him to do better in Lee's place.

<--

[AwkwardlyNERD]

Originally Posted by Chris-Sabian

I thought that too but since Clementine’s parents are seen right outside at the end, and since they were at the hotel before the outbreak, I figured the zombies had been there the whole time.

Also, He may have stalked the group since the beginning, since his car is seen at the hotel, so he must have stayed in the woods by the dairy and he possibly came in contact with the retarded brothers at the dairy.

I just laughed out loud.

[watertommyz]

On my first play through, he told me exactly about all the choices I made. Interesting thing bit; when I copied my file to see what else he can say otherwise he ended up saying that I let Clementine eat human meat, which I never did. But in my main file he told me what he was supposed to tell me. Weird glitch, or something, but it didn't ruin the experience for me. Though, I do think there was something wrong with him mentally. I find it suspicious he never goes into detail about his son, and not explain what happened to him.

I find Campman to be the perfect antagonist for Lee, as he was probably considered a "good" guy before the apocalypse, while he just wasn't suited for a harsher world and was driven mad. Lee on the other hand had gone mad (accidentally killing someone) in the normal world, but was able to find redemption in this very same world that twisted the stranger. I believe that he couldn't stand to see that Lee had actually kept Clementine safe, despite all these horrible things happening.

It's all a little open to interpretation but this is all conjecture from my end, but at the end of the day, I consider the villain the most important part of the game narratively speaking as it forces you to wonder about your choices, and the consequences of those choices. It all comes down to how it was about Clementine and her relationship to Lee the entire time.

[dinofire]

You took her to a farm full of sick people! (he says that if you don't let Clem eat Markloaf)
You let a boy get yanked out of a window to save a pretty girl with a gun!

I think that's about it.

[Sutinen]

He said he would "hurt me". My only arm said fuck you and strangled him.

[Demopan]

"You stole from my camper
You let a woman who knew who you are die to protect your secret(He means Carley, because I saved Doug)
That sweatshirt clementine's wearing is my boy's!"

Angry campman.

[Scaeva]

Originally Posted by Hidan13

I'm paraphrasing, as I completely forget what they are.

"You let her(Clementine) walk into a dairy full of sick people!"
(Going to the dairy in episode two)
"You let a man die to help protect a pretty girl with a gun."
(Carly or Doug)
"You left a grieving women on the side of the road to die."
(Leaving Lilly)

That's what I got as well.

He also called out Lee on stealing the supplies.

I had Lee defend every one of his actions, rather than apologize. For example when Campan calls Lee a thief and a murderer for stealing supplies that led to the death of Campman's wife and daughter, I had Lee say that his group was starving and desperate.

When Campman asked if he looked like a monster, I had Lee say, "We're all monsters now."

[HiggsBoson2142]

When he asked me if he looked like a monster, I wanted to say "By now, yes." But I couldn't. Yet I still said yes.

[Hudomonkey]

I let Clementine eat human(when I tried to stop by shouting You're eating human meat)
I took her to Crawford (After she repeatedly left the house when ordered to stay put and almost died because of it)
I lied to everyone about my past (I saved Doug so I had no choice to tell them)
I was completely justified and I have kept my morals
I wouldn't even kill him but Clem did...

[LauriNicole]

I think it's amusing in an annoying kind of way that whether you chose to save Carley or Doug, he complains either way.