Who did you think was slipping the bandits supplies at first?

[Rock114]

I knew it was Ben the moment I questioned him about the flashlight. Up til then, I kept an open mind and assumed everybody in the group was a suspect.

[Viser]

I had no idea, really... and frankly, after we got out of the motel I didn't even care anymore. I didn't really suspect anyone because I only showed Doug (the only person I trusted 100%) the flashlight, so I didn't get to see other people's reaction to it. I did so because I thought "if there's someone sneaking supplies to the bandits, I don't want him/her to know I'm carrying out an investigation". But Ben's reason for sneaking the supplies was valid to me, so I didn't really blame him for anything after he confessed either.

[Mornai]

Oops, i zoned out briefly when choosing a vote and selected Lee accidentally. >.<

I thought it was Ben. His reaction seemed to point to it more than anyone else.

I wish we could have accused Lilly during the argument. Say something along the lines of her being so eager to pin it on somebody else, and convince everyone that he/she did it, so the case is closed, everyone thinks he/she was the culprit and Lilly gets rid of someone she dislikes. The perfect crime.

[thesuperzapper]

Carly. She was acting... frisky.

[aperose]

I thought it was Kenny because of the way he tries to nonchalantly tell Lilly to stop accusing everyone and how he was staying out of it.

[Freeze]

I always thought it was Ben because Lilly said something along the lines of "everyone knows we keep equipment and try to fix it" so logically the only one that would try and toss it would be the new guy and when they're in the RV before anyone says anything Ben says "I'm sorry".

[Psyconix]

At first I thought it would have been Ben, but later at the conversation outside of RV I startet thinking that I was Carley who took the supplies. I kinda went crazy when Ben told Lee that he was the one and Carley died for nothing.

[SeriousScar]

Ben, seeing as how he was the newest member. I spent time with the others and knew their characters. I would have been shocked had it been someone else.

[Gman5852]

Wait, why is Doug an option but not Carley? Do Carley players get a special episode where this deal never happens and we just didn't notice?
EDIT:And to keep on topic, Kenny because he has the biggest family there so I thought he'd take the most and not tell us.

[Freeze]

Originally Posted by Gman5852

Wait, why is Doug an option but not Carley? Do Carley players get a special episode where this deal never happens and we just didn't notice?
EDIT:And to keep on topic, Kenny because he has the biggest family there so I thought he'd take the most and not tell us.

No the deal scenario still happens. I don't know why Carley isn't an option.

[CarleyandLeeTWD]

When I questioned Ben, he acted so awkwardly that I believed it was him. And indeed it was.

Btw, why isn't carley in the choices? Just asking, but it probably ridiculous to accuse her, based on her personality and good character she wouldn't. But of course anyone could be the one.

[Basser]

I thought it was Carley because she shows romantic interest in Lee right after Lily says someone's stealing the supplies. I considered the possibility that she was trying to get Lee on her side because she knew she'd eventually get caught, and wanted someone to protect her.

Actually, if Ben hadn't said anything, I would've finished the game thinking it was her LOL.

[CarleyandLeeTWD]

For me, Carley stealing didn't. It's hard to believe it was her anyway. She's truthful/ trustworthy.

[Scaeva]

I suspected Ben right away, because he was the most defensive when asked about the flashlight. It was pretty much confirmed for me the moment the bandits overran the motor inn, because Ben had been on watch. He failed to sound a warning.

[CarleyandLeeTWD]

Maybe cus he was scared of getting shot. The others gave a solid no. Clem said no. Other said no. Carley said no (even joking around with the batteries). Ben- he didn't really give a solid answer and was so worked up and affected by it I knew it was him.

I just had a random realization. What if Lilly/Carley return in S2? (Seems impossible, but let's wait and see. I CANT WAIT FOR THE NEXT SEASON) thatd be interesting

[AnnaSan]

I didn't know until I asked Ben, you can easily tell.

[Scaeva]

Originally Posted by CarleyandLeeTWD

I just had a random realization. What if Lilly/Carley return in S2? (Seems impossible, but let's wait and see. I CANT WAIT FOR THE NEXT SEASON) thatd be interesting

Lilly could potentially return in the next season, but Carley won't.

Carley is dead in every playthrough.

[CarleyandLeeTWD]

I know. But idk, you know some of those games where the main character dies or whatever then they return to their home planet or whatever and tell their story on how they survived..

What do you think Lilly will be like?

[Rock114]

Wait, so Carley's planet needed her? And I'm pretty sure Lilly will still be a pent up bitch, but slightly more regretful because she killed an innocent person. Only slightly though.

[ZeroShoot]

for me it couldn't be lee because that'd be kinda stupid, lee (the player) must've remembered that, so no, Kenny didn't seem like a traitor to me same goes for Katjaa and Carley, Lilly didn't seem suspicious to me because she started the investigation, i figured Duck was too dumb, Clem too shy and even if she took something she wouldn't have a clue about what to do with it i mean we didn't know about bandits at that point, and getting high is nothing she'd do. Someone sneaking into the camp seemed unlogical to me because, why would they leave the stuff in that hole in the wall? if they were coming to steal they'd take it... but Ben he seemed to be that kind of guy, well he was the new one, and a mess after what happened to his friend and his teacher. In E2 when he told us "it's not the bite, that does it..." his voice sounded like he was about to cry...