Which decision was the hardest to you?

[ZeroShoot]

We all had to decide certain things, like in the belltower, or in the drugstore, at the side of the road, meat locker, in the forest, in the hospital (...) and so on.

I would like to know which one was the most difficult for you to make?

For me it was the one in the belltower, i dropped him the first time, saved him the second and third time.

I won't make a poll since i would like to see reasons too

[zev_zev]

The last decision in game was most hard for me. And I chose that more good for Clementine in my opinion - leave Lee.

[The Fallen]

Same as you. Ben in the bell tower. I hated him for getting so many people (that telltale suckered me into caring about) killed, through both stupidy (forgivable) and cowardice (not so forgivable) and i wanted the Molly to take his space on the boat.

I was basically hoping/looking for a chance to kill him, but then when it came it felt so harsh and i wasn't gaining anything by killing him. I paused the game for more thinking time i was so conflicted.

Eventually dropped him.

[Willzy123]

Deciding what to kill Fivel with...

[CarScar]

Leaving Lilly or not. Right after what she did to Carley... I waited till the last second, I ended up bringing her with us.

[aaron1290]

Originally Posted by Willzy123

Deciding what to kill Fivel with...

you made my day... i was gonna say that though so i guess my worst choice is to not threaton vernon or not ( i didnt )

[o0HeaDShoT0o]

What to do with Beatrice.

If I shot her, the walkers would've came after me and Kenny. If I left her, I could get inside the pharmacy undetected.

I was trying to decide what to do while aiming at her head, and just when the timer was about to go out, I chose to leave her.

[double_u]

The vote to kick or keep Ben in the group. I absolutely hated his guts for all the suffering that he caused even if it was unintentional. All the characters that I cared about bought the farm due to the chain of events he unleashed on the group. He was a coward too, refusing to help Clem and leading to Chuck to sacrifice himself. I can understand from a rational perspective why Ben is a screw up, but when I try to play in character, I figured being pissed at him made sense and would take priority.

But when it came down to it, I had a much tougher time clicking the abandon Ben option when Clem chimed in "We don't leave friends behind" or something along those lines. Damn you Clem! During my playthrough, I've decided Clem and Carley would be my moral compass. And since Clem obviously objected and I suspected Carley would've too even if she knew what a POS ben was, I decided to vote for keeping.

[Rock114]

The meat locker. Chose to make sure Larry didn't come back, and became a much more pragmatic Lee from then on.

[DreadMagus]

Taking the supplies from the vehicle.

I had "just" given Clem a lecture on being good - I felt like such a hypocritical dick.

But pragmatism, what can ya do......

[Frostixa]

Ben.... I hated him for causing numerous deaths. So finally getting a chance to kill him off I wanted to so bad. But I felt guilty :/ Killed him anyways though haha.

And the final one with clem I think.

[Zeruis]

Deciding whether or not to bring Clem to Crawford. I did.

[Shrewsbury Survivor]

Larry Help or kill. If Clem wasnt there boom!!! Just couldnt smash his head infront of her

[BlackBoxx]

The meat locker. My first play through was me trying to be the most moral I could think of. That meant I really didn't like how Lilly and her dad ran things. I could understand being strict and pragmatic, but they were borderline abusive to their groupies (no question with Larry) from my perspective.

So on one hand I found myself siding with Kenny in all of their little arguments. They get into another one and I find Kenny is pushing for they solution I was trying to avoid. I wanted to side with him because we were becoming very good friends, but... he was advocating killing a guy without trying to help him. I just couldn't do it, no matter how much I hated Larry and Lilly's sudden helplessness whenever he fell.

All subsequent play throughs though...

[cnaf]

Leaving Lilly or not. At the time I was furious that she just took out one of my fav characters. Carley was good with a weapon, and seemed to be teaming up with Lee quite nicely. My gut was to leave her, but my head was saying the group needed all the "warm" bodies we could find. I ended up letting her on the RV- but unlike other decisions that I made and moved on...I debated it for a good part of the episode while it unfolded.

[CarleyandLeeTWD]

Originally Posted by CarScar

Leaving Lilly or not. Right after what she did to Carley... I waited till the last second, I ended up bringing her with us.

That one for me but i left her. Also about ben since he screws up so many times and the result is bad.

[Nekrocop]

This might seem strange but for me it was bringing Clem with me to Crawford.

[Toasty]

Whether to bring Lilly or not with us. I ended up bringing her at the last second.

[Phil_TWD]

1. Asking Clementine to shoot me (Lee)
2. Chopping my arm off (Christa sawing Lee's arm)
3. Deciding between Carley and Doug (chose Carley - because she was a girl in danger )

[ASSASSINO]

1- Bell Tower (I pulled Ben up, even though he was useless I couldn't kill him)
2- Leaving or bringing Lily (Even though she killed one of my favorite characters (Carley) I was always on her side and I wanted to forgive her, so I brought her along)
3- Showing the bite or not (I was afraid of being kicked out of the group or killed because of it, so I didn't show the bite)