Lee Everett or Rick Grimes

[KingOfTheDead]

Originally Posted by AnnaSan

Oh thanks, I did remember him telling me that.

your welcome AnnaChan

[dee23]

Originally Posted by hawkfire20

This made me chuckle. I'd still pick Lee, though, because he seem's a lot more safer and easier to be around and he won't kill me if I piss him off.

Rick won't kill you either. Every person Rick killed was killed to protect himself or someone in his group. Rick chose to reason with people first and used his police negotiation training in most cases, often to good effect. He did this at the Alexandria safe zone when Ron's dad was threatening to kill him which was after his break down and was even commended for his restraint by the man that was trying to kill him. As for Rick being a dictator, Rick did away with that awhile ago. He makes decisions with the group and has for quite some time now. He doesn't loose his temper when people disagree. He is a lot more rationale than you give him credit for. When Rick has had to be authorative and bark orders it has woken the group up and saved their lives often with a big moving speech.

[Forsoothe]

I'd choose Rick. My Lee was an asshole.

[Phil_TWD]

I only watch the TV Series and played TT's game, so it's TV Rick and Game Lee.

It's a tough pick, but in the long run I'd have to go with Rick.

He's the leader, lost his wife, went insane and took control of the group again.

[Mornai]

I'd choose Lee. He's a sound leader, has a calm mind(when Clem is not missing) and can effectively defuse most situations without consequence. Plus, he's lost his parents and had to put his own brother out of his misery. He's accepted that tragedy and doesn't let it affect him in any way.

[JakeSt123]

Hmm... isn't it funny how the protagonist of one series is a Cop, and the other is a Convict?
I'd pick Lee, because he appears to be much more caring and less ruthless to his group, but will tear down walkers when required. He can also manage his emotions slightly better than Rick can.

[ZeroShoot]

Lee cause he is quite sane and also keeps the spirit up, in my opinion he's a good leader he has the guts to make the hard decisions but won't kill a stranger cause of suspicions or not trusting them, the way rick treats people is cold, maybe neccessary but i think Lee is the man... at least my Lee is.

[Psyconix]

I would trust my Lee, because Rick seems to do some wrong decisions in the TV show. I also think that Lee would do anything to protect his group.

[DreadMagus]

My original post was based on TV Rick

Now that I've read Compendium One - I'd like to add, I think if I were in Rick's group - I'd run away screaming. That guy kills as many, if not more, than Ben.....

[Robbingrobin]

Originally Posted by DreadMagus

My original post was based on TV Rick

Now that I've read Compendium One - I'd like to add, I think if I were in Rick's group - I'd run away screaming. That guy kills as many, if not more, than Ben.....

So... You would take sure death instead of maybe death?

[DreadMagus]

I'd be better off solo

[Robbingrobin]

Of course. I like how everyone is thinking that.

[Phil_TWD]

Originally Posted by Psyconix

Rick seems to do some wrong decisions in the TV show.

Everyone commits mistakes, even team leaders. Lee isn't perfect neither, he's actually a dirtier character than Rick because he killed a man, while Rick's a police officer.

Yeah, not all police officers are clean or innocent, I know.

[DreadMagus]

Originally Posted by Robbingrobin

Of course. I like how everyone is thinking that.

Dude, he got his entire group killed (wife and daughter included) in the first 50 comics.

The only ones who lived where the ones smart enough to ditch him.

At least till they came back... heh.

[Ltvendetta]

I would like to say this game does have one thing to do with the Tv Show and the Comic.... Hershal.

[Mark$man]

Hershel in the game is the comics version. The game/comic Hershel is MUCH different than the tv one. People who play episode 1 will see that :P He actually kicked the group out of the farm, and was brought to the prison later on when the farm became unsafe.

[crispy01]

I don't know, as I ahvn't had the chance to read any of the comics yet, and the I find the show difficult to stick to, but if I had to choose, it would be my Lee. Lee seems to be the only one who doesn't break down during his limited stay in the apocalypse, and I would feel much safer with Lee, as he feels much more like a comforting human, rather than the mini crack SWAT team half of the TV show cast have turned into, where people dying is just another day for them. Rick seems to be in alot more control than Lee, which would probably increase your chances of survival, but to live with people you can no longer read or predict as a normal person, I would live in constant fear of being shot or thrown out.

[Rizefall]

I would say that this is more a question about You Vs Rick. Lee is the player.

[Cthulhu42]

Rick has managed to keep himself and a few others in his group alive for over a year and a half so far.

Lee couldn't manage more than 3 or 4 months.

I'll stick with Rick.

[Mark$man]

I'd rather stick with Lee. Lee's group's downfall was not his fault, and had he not gone looking for Clem, would have survived and all of them would be safe on a boat.

Lee is easier to trust(by far), is kind, has retained his naivety of people, is intelligent and great at improvising, is a great leader and friend, good shot and street fighter, is forgiving, is flawed but tries to make up for it, etc.

Rick has lost many of the qualities he had in the beginning, and has gone a bit insane. He has killed those who put him and those of his remaining friends and family at risk(even if unintentional). He has done some crazy shit, and I don't mean the cool kind, I mean the insane kind lol. I'd like to be with Rick's group too, but Rick puts his group at risk too much, where Lee just tries to keep everyone safe, and puts everyone elses' lives before his own.

I'd choose my Lee, hands down. Rick of comics is loco, and Rick of TV is kinda crazy too. He has protected his group much worse than in the comics, where until the Governor goes on a rampage he had many of his group still with him.