55% Lack Compassion...

[k1ngMe]

It was the beginning of the apocalypse, we didn't know how bad things were until the second episode.

[zev_zev]

At the first time when I was playing, I just had no time to decide

[LauriNicole]

I said no because I was afraid if she had the gun she might have chosen to shoot us (as in Lee, Carley and Glenn).

[Jaded X Gamer]

Originally Posted by LauriNicole

I said no because I was afraid if she had the gun she might have chosen to shoot us (as in Lee, Carley and Glenn).

I wasn't really worried about that since she had gone out of her way to stay out of everyone else's way, only coming out after Lee was literally knocking her door down. All because she didn't want to hurt anyone after she came back as a walker.

She didn't really strike me as crazy either. Suicidally depressed (for good reason) and a bit hysterical, but not crazy. She seemed well aware of what was going on and was even trying to warn Glenn and the others to leave her alone. I was more worried about her getting desperate and following us if we didn't let her kill herself.

As for the whole "it was the early days we don't know if she's really going to die." Between Larry making a big deal about bites and Irene explaining how she saw first hand how her boyfriend got sick, died and reanimated after being bitten, I was pretty much sold on bites being death sentences.

[LauriNicole]

Still, the St. John's... the group trusted them and we all know what happened then.

I just don't trust my weapons with a stranger. People die. I wish there was an option for Lee to shoot her himself- I would have chosen that.

[double_u]

Originally Posted by LauriNicole

Still, the St. John's... the group trusted them and we all know what happened then.

I just don't trust my weapons with a stranger. People die. I wish there was an option for Lee to shoot her himself- I would have chosen that.

This is a good idea. Plus, it could also lead to some interesting conversation choices afterwards, with group members agreeing or disagreeing with what you did and forming opinions of you that could come back and affect the game.

[Jaded X Gamer]

Originally Posted by LauriNicole

Still, the St. John's... the group trusted them and we all know what happened then.

I didn't trust the St. Johns. Hell, I thought they were suspicious from the moment they introduced themselves. Casually strolling up to a hotel of well armed people and calmly asking for gas like a neighbor wanting some sugar while Carley pointed her gun at them.

Even the most well meaning people are going to be more defensive when encountering armed strangers during an zombie apocalypse. Like Carley yelling at the St. John's to back off when she first saw them, or how Ben and Travis are afraid of Kenny, Lee and Mark when they first meet them.

Mark pissed me off when he decided everyone should come to the dairy, especially after all the probing questions the St. Johns asked. After Mark got hit I wanted everyone to leave. If they didn't tell us about Bandits they probably aren't telling us about a lot of other things. If they want to trade gas for food we can do it on a deal by deal business but there's no need for the whole group to be at the dairy. Lilly really annoyed me how she kept saying she wanted to leave, but didn't do shit about it.