Mankind or Clementine?

[thewalkingwalker]

44 people have no humanity

[anonymau5]

Originally Posted by thewalkingwalker

44 people have no humanity

Or 44 people aren't selfish.

[zev_zev]

Originally Posted by anonymau5

Or 44 people aren't selfish.

So what do YOU choose?

[anonymau5]

Originally Posted by zev_zev

So what do YOU choose?

Mankind. I did however, ignore the situation that was provided. In a situation where I instantly had to choose between mankind and Clementine, with no syringes or whatever, I would choose mankind. In the plane situation, I would choose Clementine because the cure there would do almost nothing. As Spock said, the needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few.

[zev_zev]

Originally Posted by anonymau5

Mankind. I did however, ignore the situation that was provided. In a situation where I instantly had to choose between mankind and Clementine, with no syringes or whatever, I would choose mankind. In the plane situation, I would choose Clementine because the cure there would do almost nothing. As Spock said, the needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few.

Depressurization

Did you save Clementine against vaccine?

You and 47% players catched a vaccine

.................................................................

[J_Scheff]

Originally Posted by anonymau5

Or 44 people aren't selfish.

Selfishness has nothing to do with it. I am not saving Clem because I will be sad or lonely without her, I am saving her because she deserves to have a chance to survive and prosper, I chose her because she is a helpless innocent 9 year old girl who has been through Hell and deserves better.

Plus by saving Clem you are risking your life a lot more than by saving the vaccine. What if you lose your footing or grip while trying to save Clem? You could fall to your death as well.

There is nothing selfish about saving Clem. Its the Logical, Practical, and has the most likely successful outcome.

[anonymau5]

Originally Posted by J_Scheff

Selfishness has nothing to do with it. I am not saving Clem because I will be sad or lonely without her, I am saving her because she deserves to have a chance to survive and prosper, I chose her because she is a helpless innocent 9 year old girl who has been through Hell and deserves better.

Plus by saving Clem you are risking your life a lot more than by saving the vaccine. What if you lose your footing or grip while trying to save Clem? You could fall to your death as well.

There is nothing selfish about saving Clem. Its the Logical, Practical, and has the most likely successful outcome.

It's not exactly selfish, but it's more selfish then saving the rest of mankind. But, then again, look at my above post on my thoughts on the scenario we have to choose from.

[J_Scheff]

Originally Posted by anonymau5

It's not exactly selfish, but it's more selfish then saving the rest of mankind. But, then again, look at my above post on my thoughts on the scenario we have to choose from.

Yeah I get what your saying, and that would make a difference in the decision making process. But that is not how the vaccine works according to this thread and so by killing Clem you sacrificed her for nothing more than bacteria in a tube.

I understand what your saying tho, but that is not the situation.

[Hudomonkey]

It simply comes down to the situation and a vaccine is basically pointless in a zombie outbreak

The walkers are dead bodies all this vaccine would do is make young children (which you are probably never going to meet) from a possible infection (which is an unlikely cause of death) when a walker could still rip them apart or they could be shot or starve to death

It is a useless vaccine which would never be used

But if it was literally a button that ended the zombie outbreak I would choose it over Clem...

I choose Mankind I just wouldn't in this unbelievable pointless situation

[HarjKS]

I love Clementine...however, I had to get the vaccine.

[Ronedor]

I think its a very difficult choice for all of us..but,we shouldn't be selfish at this moment because we can save mankind. I think that the vaccine is not so useless for us ( for the humankind ) !!!
P.S i know that we all love clementine .

[Ronedor]

Originally Posted by HarjKS

I love Clementine...however, I had to get the vaccine.

I totally agree with you. I love clementine too,but with vaccine we can save a lot of people as like clementine.
P.S the author of this topic ( zev_zev ) are " MONSTER " .

[VadimDOR]

Hey man, you is casual not the screenwriter? ? ?
Pretty cool it turned out, I made this decision really long, very difficult and having weighed all pros and cons, stopped on a vaccine. It is clear that Clem is the little, lovely girl with whom all fell in love and which personifies good, but a vaccine is rescue, though not at all hundred percent, but it is chance, and you can call me insensible, but loss of one person, for the sake of the whole world is the correct decision.

[Mark$man]

I choose to save both!!! *Tells woman piloting plane to pull down lever bringing the bottom of the plane upward.* *Clem falls into cockpit with syringe* WINNING )))

Seriously, why can't you do that? If someone is piloting the plane, then simply tell them to drop the plane. If no one is piloting, it will drop on it's own(I think that's the case if the woman died, and you and Clem are all that's left). So couldn't you save them both, really? lol

Either way, I'd save Clem first. The world can do without it. And it was made once, it can be made again. A single antidote can't cure the world's babies. And what happens if the woman dies? Or the child dies? Oops, sorry Clem. I loved you, but... yeah... that was bad. LMAO.

[zev_zev]

Originally Posted by Mark$man

I choose to save both!!! *Tells woman piloting plane to pull down lever bringing the bottom of the plane upward.* *Clem falls into cockpit with syringe* WINNING )))

Because the plane, began to take off, and a sharp lurch down would be a disaster, runway end

[Mark$man]

Um... it wouldn't need to be a sharp lurch, just down in general. I mean, if you are a skilled flier, no matter how high/low the plane, you should be able to land it safely(considering plane is intact).

[Mark$man]

Another answer: Close the cargo compartment doors? Or to lean to one side to allow gravity to keep the syringe from falling out of your pocket? Or have Clem catch it with one of her hands? You can still hold her with the other, if you drop her, you are a pretty weak adult, right? I mean, I doubt there is a way in that situation you COULDN'T save both.

I only choose Clementine because I'd think of her as my daughter, a little girl I'd sworn to protect with my life, and that I'd expected to survive. Any situation where her life was in my hands, that she could see me, was crying, was pleading to save her, was knowing that I could save her, there is no way in the game or not that I could let her die to save anyone else. It may sound selfish, but as a man, and if I were a parent, I would not be able to sacrifice someone I loved, even for humanity's sake. They'd have to get themselves killed, and even then I'd probably be so shocked and such I'd hesitate to react. I'd say I'd think a lot like Kenny. That she could survive, that she could make it in this world with me if I pulled her up. What good was an antidote if she died? I was doing it all for her, surviving for her, I was raising her to survive the ZA. That antidote might not even save anyone. It would stop the future children from becoming walkers. So what? They'd be born into a world infested with walkers anyway, and when their parents die they'd become walkers. What good is not being infected if you die from a single bite anyway? When all that was needed was shooting you in the head and it'd be the same affect? That antidote was too soon. The walkers in the world would have to be dealt with before trying to get the world to go back to normal.

So I stand firm that'd I'd save Clementine. I'm sure most fathers/mothers would agree, that if faced in that position, there is no chance they'd drop Clem(their daughter) on their own. She'd have to drop herself.

[zev_zev]

Originally Posted by Mark$man

Another answer: Close the cargo compartment doors? Or to lean to one side to allow gravity to keep the syringe from falling out of your pocket? Or have Clem catch it with one of her hands? You can still hold her with the other, if you drop her, you are a pretty weak adult, right? I mean, I doubt there is a way in that situation you COULDN'T save both.

I only choose Clementine because I'd think of her as my daughter, a little girl I'd sworn to protect with my life, and that I'd expected to survive. Any situation where her life was in my hands, that she could see me, was crying, was pleading to save her, was knowing that I could save her, there is no way in the game or not that I could let her die to save anyone else. It may sound selfish, but as a man, and if I were a parent, I would not be able to sacrifice someone I loved, even for humanity's sake. They'd have to get themselves killed, and even then I'd probably be so shocked and such I'd hesitate to react. I'd say I'd think a lot like Kenny. That she could survive, that she could make it in this world with me if I pulled her up. What good was an antidote if she died? I was doing it all for her, surviving for her, I was raising her to survive the ZA. That antidote might not even save anyone. It would stop the future children from becoming walkers. So what? They'd be born into a world infested with walkers anyway, and when their parents die they'd become walkers. What good is not being infected if you die from a single bite anyway? When all that was needed was shooting you in the head and it'd be the same affect? That antidote was too soon. The walkers in the world would have to be dealt with before trying to get the world to go back to normal.

So I stand firm that'd I'd save Clementine. I'm sure most fathers/mothers would agree, that if faced in that position, there is no chance they'd drop Clem(their daughter) on their own. She'd have to drop herself.

Agree.

P.S. Cargo compartment doors is jammed.

[Mark$man]

Originally Posted by zev_zev

Agree.

P.S. Cargo compartment doors is jammed.

I think Clem would hate you for this stupid situation -_- She'll stare you down from heaven lol. Either that, or in my version, would hate you for trying to get you killed :P

[Clemmy1]

No brainer for me,Clem and then choose the ''f@*k'' option for when you see antidote fall from plane.