You are given the choice...

[ZeroShoot]

Originally Posted by J_Scheff

As a fatherly instinct your first thought is always your child.

didn't get to become father yet but I get your point of view, your first thought and you reaction are two different things though, when people are driving a car, and suddenly see a reason to hit the break (like a dog or child running on the street) it takes it's time to realize, and to act, and depending on how skilfully you are, you might not make it in time (like missing the break, and just stomping on the car's bottom), because there is a moment where you might be in a state of shock, when seeing how someone runs on the street, or to get back to topic your daughter is getting attacked by a walker, however- it depends on whether you ever shot a gun and on how quick and accurate you aim, and how fast you CAN react. 3 seconds can be short sometimes... if it's not a game, we got used to such situations IG, but not IRL.

btw. yeah I also felt for Clem like for a daughter, and i would've killed anyone, or sacrificed anyone to save her.

[thestalkinghead]

this scenario doesn't seem like it would be a Lee or Clementine Choice, i would shoot the one getting Clementine but i don't think you would get a better shot at the zombie that was on Clementine if you were being eaten, why not use one arm to hold off the zombie and the other to shot the one getting Clementine then shoot the one getting Lee?

and actually i don't think the sound of a gunshot would just cause Clementine to get killed so shooting the one getting Lee first then saving Clementine a few seconds later

if this was just a hypothetical choice of Lee or Clementine the obvious answer would be saving Clementine

[ZeroShoot]

Originally Posted by thestalkinghead

i don't think you would get a better shot at the zombie that was on Clementine if you were being eaten, why not use one arm to hold off the zombie and the other to shot the one getting Clementine then shoot the one getting Lee?

and actually i don't think the sound of a gunshot would just cause Clementine to get killed

to first quote: Lee first pushs the Zombie away, then takes the shot at the one being on Clem, after that the Zombie (behind him) stands up and bites him.
So why can't you use one hand to hold of the walker, and the other one to shoot? - because that would be very very risky, Clem can't hold "her" walker steady, because she's too weak, and Lee would have to hold of a walker, the walker would push towards Lee though, so he couldn't really aim either, so he'd only risk shooting her, besides that in such a situation shooting with both hands on the gun is just way safer.

to second quote: like many things in the twd universe it's up to everybody himself to believe it or not, it would be reasonable don't you think? Imagine her starring at that walker, all scared, holding him off SOMEhow, and not seeing that Lee takes out his gun, and suddenly hearing a shot, she would wonder where it came from, like: "what the?" *turns head to Lee, disoriented, in a little, very short but fatal state of shock* - zombie falls on her, bites her, and... you know...

in the end I posted the question to see who, or better say how many people would save her life over Lee's or his over her's, oh that reminds me I wanted to do a poll... I guess it's too late now.

[thestalkinghead]

i guess i would have to see it to actually believe that it was impossible to save both, but as i said hypothetically the obvious answer would be to save a child's life, so obviously i would save Clementine

[J_Scheff]

Originally Posted by ZeroShoot

btw. yeah I also felt for Clem like for a daughter, and i would've killed anyone, or sacrificed anyone to save her.

She is the best isnt she? Best character of any game in my opinion. Not many characters in games can get the emotion out of me like she did, that shows she is a great character.

I get what your saying, I do live in Wyoming, so shooting guns is a bit of a specialty for me, but with the shock and everything you are right, it would be much more than just knowing what to do and actually getting it done...

[ZeroShoot]

Originally Posted by J_Scheff

She is the best isnt she? Best character of any game in my opinion. Not many characters in games can get the emotion out of me like she did, that shows she is a great character.

ain't that the truth...

[Araron]

I'd save Lee,really though...

...

...what?Don't hate me. :P

[Toasty]

I would choose Clem, no hesitation.

[Web Head]

Both

[Vladisimo]

Save myself. I'm much more useful to the group than she is plus that you only have one life.

[Iyrsiiea]

How is this even a question?

Clementine. Always Clementine.