I haven't read the full thread, but I read most of the first page and I just wanted to make a point that some of you are being a bit oblivious to reality with your Dom fanboydom:
Personally I think Dominic does a great job at Guybrush's voice. Except SoMI:SE. To be completely, utterly, and brutally honest, I personally feel that Dom failed to deliver in SoMI:SE. His inflection (to me at least) was off-key resulting in the delivery of many punchlines being missed.
Beyond SoMI:SE Dom's done a great job. Just wanted to show you all that,
believe it or not, not everyone feels the same about his voice acting role as Guybrush Threepwood.
Welcome aboard the U.S.S. Reality, this is Captain Killjoy speaking. Please keep your arms and minds inside the ride at all times, it's gonna be a bumpy ride!