You're basically getting a new card instead of that old one, guys. I totally understand being disappointed, especially if this one was your favourite, but then they ended up going an extra mile and adding a new card instead... I don't think they should send that card to everyone, personally. I mean it would cost them a lot and it's an extra card. Maybe if you returned one of the new cards in return?
I just don't think mailing a single card would be very cost-effective for them, even if they did manage to get them printed. I think at best, if they get it printed they should have it for free to people who bought the voodoo cards, but you'd still pay for shipping - like with the DVDs. Or you could order it but only grouped with something else. But I don't think they're going to print that one card, it just seems too unlikely to me.
I personally would care more about the lack of the dagger in the betrayal card. Why did it disappear? That's a bit weird.