Telltale Games

ChiPsiUp · 08/31/2010, 04:10 pm

So... I've finished 305. But at no point in the game did I actually hear Girl Stinky admit that she was a mermaid. Now, reading the forums people seem to take it for granted, but where did they actually say it in-game? There's no place where I can talk to Girl Stinky directly this game, and all I actually learned is that she isn't really a demon cake.

SunnyGuy · 08/31/2010, 04:11 pm

Flint calls Stinky a mermaid during the battle at the clone lab, Sam reacts surprised and Stinky just says something similar to "you mean you didn't know already?"

ChiPsiUp · 08/31/2010, 04:16 pm

Really? I don't recall seeing that at all... was it right when you first walked in? Or do you have to click on something?

GinnyN · 08/31/2010, 04:16 pm

You have to click the Box of Stuff under the Fog machine for that conversation though.

Shwoo · 08/31/2010, 04:17 pm

I never saw that either. I'll have to replay it. I saw the explanation about Stinky and Sal being con artists.

tabstis · 09/01/2010, 12:10 am

God, guys. Catch up.

doodinthemood · 09/01/2010, 12:21 am

Telltale must have panicked after 301 where everyone was saying "I bet stinky's a mermaid"

tabstis · 09/01/2010, 12:21 am

Quote:

Originally Posted by doodinthemood

Telltale must have panicked after 301 where everyone was saying "I bet stinky's a mermaid"

Nah, it was an original plan for Season 2. And she's had her mermaid apron for ages... if they hadn't said she was a cake, it would be fact.

LikaLaruku · 09/01/2010, 01:15 am

SPOILERS!!!

I learned a lot of interesting things about the Stinky's this season.

*Grampa Stinky hasn't slept in 3 years.
*Grampa Stinky cannot be killed (is his brain or body indestructable? & is his body still floating around in space if it's the latter?)
*Grampa Stinky never said WHEN he created Girl Stinky.
*Sal practically said either that he & Stinky have been trying to kill Stinky for at least 20 years or that they had been dating that long. He was either going to tell her that he wanted to stop trying to kill, or he was going to break up with her.
*Grampa Stinky has a weird thing with cakes & has been associated with 3 different kinds of cakes.

Is Stinky himself a demon cake of someone else's creation?

Soeroah · 09/01/2010, 02:14 am

And remember back in 302, the poster in the century-old theater advertising a show called "The Mermaid and the Cockroach"?

Shwoo · 09/01/2010, 02:55 am

Quote:

Originally Posted by LikaLaruku

*Grampa Stinky cannot be killed (is his brain or body indestructable? & is his body still floating around in space if it's the latter?)

He can be killed. He died at some point before 205 in a mountain climbing accident.

Emo Hoe · 09/01/2010, 03:00 am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Shwoo

He can be killed. He died at some point before 205 in a mountain climbing accident.

No he did not.
That where Stinky said he was, but quite clearly he did not die.

tabstis · 09/01/2010, 03:00 am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Shwoo

He can be killed. He died at some point before 205 in a mountain climbing accident.

I think that was the reason why Stinky believed he couldn't be killed. She thought he had survived that when he returned from Hell.

Shwoo · 09/01/2010, 03:02 am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Emo Hoe

No he did not.
That where Stinky said he was, but quite clearly he did not die.

Why was he trapped in Hell for eternity if he didn't die?

Emo Hoe · 09/01/2010, 03:04 am

Oh yeah my bad total blanked on that one!

Hassat Hunter · 09/01/2010, 03:37 am

She claimed that was his reason, but S&M didn't buy it.

The twist was when in 205 we meet him in hell and he says that *was* actually the reason he died.

Fazz · 09/01/2010, 05:46 am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hassat Hunter

The twist was when in 205 we meet him in hell and he says that *was* actually the reason he died.

When is that? I don't remember him being in a box!

Mooshiiii · 09/01/2010, 05:51 am

Yup, he was in the-hell cooking show with Stinky and the rats, you got him out with tiny's 'cursing', in 205

Hassat Hunter · 09/01/2010, 05:53 am

Ninja'ed.

But yeah, he was in the cooking show.

Fazz · 09/01/2010, 05:55 am

He was? Oh, thanks. I did remember of Girl Stinky and the rats, but not of Stinky himself. By the way, to cover the spoiler, its with [*spoiler][/spoiler*] (without the asterisks.)

08/31/2010, 04:10 pm	#1
ChiPsiUp Junior Member Join Date: Aug 2010 Posts: 3	Mermaid? So... I've finished 305. But at no point in the game did I actually hear Girl Stinky admit that she was a mermaid. Now, reading the forums people seem to take it for granted, but where did they actually say it in-game? There's no place where I can talk to Girl Stinky directly this game, and all I actually learned is that she isn't really a demon cake.

08/31/2010, 04:11 pm	#2
SunnyGuy Senior Member Join Date: Jul 2010 Location: Guadalajara, Jalisco (Mexico) Posts: 980	Flint calls Stinky a mermaid during the battle at the clone lab, Sam reacts surprised and Stinky just says something similar to "you mean you didn't know already?" __________________ Go look at my art at my DA account...please? There are free cookies! (but I may or may not have eaten them all already) "Nobody expects the lagomorphic inquisition!"

08/31/2010, 04:16 pm	#4
GinnyN An Armed Lagomorph Join Date: Jun 2009 Location: Ask the earth Posts: 2,426	You have to click the Box of Stuff under the Fog machine for that conversation though. __________________ Because we have nothing, we want to do everything --- - My Zazzle Store! - My DeviantArt Account! #nadaesimposiblehueonniunawea.

08/31/2010, 04:17 pm	#5
Shwoo Senior Member Join Date: Apr 2008 Location: Canberra, Australia Posts: 1,486	I never saw that either. I'll have to replay it. I saw the explanation about Stinky and Sal being con artists. __________________ This is a link to the Sam & Max wiki. This is a link to a Sam & Max deviantART group.

09/01/2010, 12:10 am	#6
tabstis Back to the Telltale Join Date: May 2010 Location: Hill Valley Posts: 938	God, guys. Catch up. __________________ It's About Time I Get Double Visions of Citizen Brown.

09/01/2010, 12:21 am	#7
doodinthemood Your 4th favourite member Join Date: Jul 2009 Location: Birmingham England Kudos: 867 Posts: 975	Telltale must have panicked after 301 where everyone was saying "I bet stinky's a mermaid" __________________ Hi Logan. I know you're reading this.

09/01/2010, 01:15 am	#9
LikaLaruku Everybody to the limit! Join Date: Apr 2008 Posts: 281	SPOILERS!!! I learned a lot of interesting things about the Stinky's this season. Grampa Stinky hasn't slept in 3 years. Grampa Stinky cannot be killed (is his brain or body indestructable? & is his body still floating around in space if it's the latter?) Grampa Stinky never said WHEN he created Girl Stinky. Sal practically said either that he & Stinky have been trying to kill Stinky for at least 20 years or that they had been dating that long. He was either going to tell her that he wanted to stop trying to kill, or he was going to break up with her. Grampa Stinky has a weird thing with cakes & has been associated with 3 different kinds of cakes. Is Stinky himself a demon cake of someone else's creation? Last edited by LikaLaruku; 09/01/2010 at 01:17 am.*

09/01/2010, 02:14 am	#10
Soeroah Member Join Date: Jan 2010 Posts: 88	And remember back in 302, the poster in the century-old theater advertising a show called "The Mermaid and the Cockroach"?

09/01/2010, 03:04 am	#15
Emo Hoe Senior Member Join Date: Jun 2008 Posts: 331	Oh yeah my bad total blanked on that one!

09/01/2010, 03:37 am	#16
Hassat Hunter Fluffy monkey/Cute kitten Join Date: Jan 2010 Posts: 2,804	She claimed that was his reason, but S&M didn't buy it. The twist was when in 205 we meet him in hell and he says that was actually the reason he died. __________________ Sam: "We're 98% certain General Skun-ka'pe is evil." Stinky: "And the other 2%?" Max: "That he's crazy and we have to shoot him! But that may be wishful thinking on our part." (Any resemblance to KOTOR is purely coincidential, really!)

09/01/2010, 05:51 am	#18
Mooshiiii Member Join Date: Feb 2008 Location: United States of America Posts: 34	Yup, he was in the-hell cooking show with Stinky and the rats, you got him out with tiny's 'cursing', in 205 Last edited by Mooshiiii; 09/01/2010 at 06:37 am. Reason: covering spoilers

09/01/2010, 05:53 am	#19
Hassat Hunter Fluffy monkey/Cute kitten Join Date: Jan 2010 Posts: 2,804	Ninja'ed. But yeah, he was in the cooking show. __________________ Sam: "We're 98% certain General Skun-ka'pe is evil." Stinky: "And the other 2%?" Max: "That he's crazy and we have to shoot him! But that may be wishful thinking on our part." (Any resemblance to KOTOR is purely coincidential, really!)

09/01/2010, 05:55 am	#20
Fazz I cracked Sam up! Join Date: Apr 2010 Location: With other French rabbits Posts: 108	He was? Oh, thanks. I did remember of Girl Stinky and the rats, but not of Stinky himself. By the way, to cover the spoiler, its with [spoiler][/spoiler] (without the asterisks.)

Thread Tools	Search this Thread
Show Printable Version Email this Page	Search this Thread: Advanced Search

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
How Stinky could have worked in a diner setting and still have been a mermaid	SamnMad	Sam & Max Series Discussion	20	07/15/2010 07:48 pm
The Mermaid and the Cockroach?	Captain Viku	Sam & Max Series Discussion	21	05/29/2010 12:24 am
Happy Birthsday Mermaid	Novotnus	Tales of Monkey Island General Discussion	23	11/30/2009 12:16 pm
Summing it up - Chapter 4 (video)	Mermaid	Tales of Monkey Island General Discussion	28	11/08/2009 11:16 am