Quote:
Originally Posted by waroftheworlds01
I saw the whole Hurley, Ben, and Walt thing on the DVD release. I'm intrested in what that could lead to as well.
And I have to ask. What did you think of the Lost ending? I mean, am I the only one who thinks that they weren't dead the whole time? I know that they were dead when they were in the church in the last season. But everthing that happened on the island did indeed happen. It was after all they had died on the island after the crash when they entered that pergatory world where they were living a second life and re-discovering each other and not when the plane crashed. Or at least that's how I saw it. I guess it's really up to the viewer to decide that.
|
You may want to add a spoiler notice to your post but I'll add my two cents...
SPOLIER WARNING [IF YOU HAVEN'T WATCHED LOST AND DON'T WANT THE ENDING SPOLIT, THEN READ NO FURTHER... YOU HAVE BEEN WARNED]
.
.
.
.
Although you are correct that the ending and many aspects of the show are open to interprtation (the makers intended it that way and I completely agree with that decesion), I do believe that I've read the intensions of the writers in the past. Basically, you're spot on! Everything that happened on the Island did indeed take place.
As you said, the purgatory aspect is a way for the deceased to meet up and remember how important each of them was in each others life (so that they may pass into the afterlife at peace). That space exists in a place where time has no relevance, which is to say that someone who died during season 2 will arrive there at the same time as someone who lived on and died many years after they had left the Island following season 6.
The Island itself is in essence the Garden of Eden, the point of all creation and the light is what allows life and time to exist. The light flows from its source (the cave where the Man In Black transformed into the smoke monster) and travels to different areas throughout the Island (these are the areas that the Dharma Initiative discovered and attempted to study; the Swan being a prime example of this). From the Island the light travels through the ocean and around the entire world, thus maintaining life. It could be argued that the light represents God.
Of course, as the light travels further away from the source and across the Earth it becomes less potent (think along the lines of adding water to concentrated orange juice), which leaves just the Island with the highly concentrated power. As the light controls time as well as life, manipulation of the light (as performed initially by the MIB) allows the Island to travel to different points in time.
Remember how the Jacob explained to Hurley that the Island acts as a cork and if the Island were to be sunk (as the MIB wishes to do in order to escape his eternal torture as Smokie) then life would end? Basically, if the Island sinks then the light goes out (imagine pouring a bottle of water out of its reciprocal).
Another interesting point that was intended but only suggested by the writers was that Mother was a smoke monster herself, remember when she managed to somehow wipe out an entire colony of people by her self, off screen? She even warns Jacob that a fate worse then death awaits those who enter the cave where the light is; she should know
This next bit's long but bear with me...
Another thing I noticed whilst watching the 1st season for the second time was when Jack kept seeing his dad on the Island, it was always smokie (who had come across Jack's Dad's coffin in the jungle following the plane crash; hence allowing him to alter his apperance to Jack's Dad's form and also absorb his memories). If you remember, when Jack first see's the MIB as his Dad, the MIB runs away and Jack gives chase, narrowly avoiding falling off a cliff. Well...
...the MIB had hoped to get Jack to kill himself (because the MIB knew that Jack was a candidate who might protect the light but the MIB can't harm him directly...there are rules). After that failed attempt, the MIB changes tact and leads Jack to the empty coffin of his Father, leading Jack to believe that his Father is walking around the Island.
Later on in the show (6th season I think), when the MIB is trying to allie himself with Jack (boo!), he lies to Jack and "reminds" him that it was he who led Jack to the cave where there was drinking water (the same cave where the coffin was). He tells Jack that he has been watching over him and protecting him since day one, when in fact he tried to kill Jack on day one! Truly, he is the master of manipulation. Even more so than this fellow:
The other Man In Black
...which is appropriate seeming that Star Wars was an influence on LOST