Telltale Games

Ashton · 10/17/2010, 08:26 pm

Who do you think would win in a fight?

(non-psychic) Max or Guybrush?

Vote! ^__^

*divisionten* · 10/17/2010, 10:45 pm

Sorry Guybrush, if we're talking a straight up fight in an arena, your organs will be strewn across the ground in 5 minutes or less (see: Demon Peepers).

Now, if we're talking tactical battle with hiding places and items, Guybrush has a chance. Max isn't stupid- he's certainly mentally unstable but NOT stupid (see They Stole Max's Bran, Egypt section, where it's essentially Max being rational and in control)- but he has nothing on Guybrush's level of sheer ingenuity.

caeska · 10/18/2010, 02:29 am

Well I like both, but fighting is the only way to find out which is better.

But in my opinion, Guybrush would win. He's taken down Lechuck what, 8 times? (SOMI, LcR, twice in CMI, EfMI, the Walrus Lechuck and technically twice in ToMI.
So yeah, Max would have nothing on him.

Captain Mickey · 10/18/2010, 05:01 am

I think Guybrush has a chance at winning. He's smart enough to find a way around Max.

Alcoremortis · 10/18/2010, 07:53 am

I think it depends on what Guybrush has in his inventory.

jeeno0142 · 10/18/2010, 08:58 am

I really think it would be a draw. Max would be fighting with his fists and Guybrush would be fighting him off using logic. It sounds like an epic battle that will last centuries.

crfh · 10/18/2010, 12:31 pm

Rule of Comedy, guys. Max wins.

The Highway · 10/19/2010, 01:12 am

Quote:

Originally Posted by jeeno0142

I really think it would be a draw. Max would be fighting with his fists and Guybrush would be fighting him off using logic. It sounds like an epic battle that will last centuries.

Max has a gun

Javi-Wan Kenobi · 10/19/2010, 01:28 am

Sadly, Guybrush won't have the slightest chance in a physical fight (with or without weapons and/or inventory items).
But in a battle of wits, Guybrush is more likely to be the winner, even if it's by luck or accident.

jaden551 · 10/19/2010, 07:30 am

If anything it should be witch writing team can type faster and still make it sound like their character.

Scnew · 10/19/2010, 08:43 am

Max has a gun and a love of using it.

SlasherMan · 10/19/2010, 10:13 am

Yup, Max would win... Though I thought at first this poll would be which series was better, if it was that, I would'nt chose since I love both series equally... But hey, this is a vs. Battle so I say Max would definitly win.

jeeno0142 · 10/19/2010, 10:13 am

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Highway

Max has a gun

I guess that would make Max the winner then...

...unless Guybrush had a lightsaber!

Ashton · 10/21/2010, 06:35 am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Alcoremortis

I think it depends on what Guybrush has in his inventory.

A pack of breath-mints, a chicken-with-a-pulley-in-the-middle, 2 minnows, and some yarn.

(somehow I think Guybrush could still find a way to defeat max using those items...)

S@bre · 10/21/2010, 05:17 pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ashton

A pack of breath-mints, a chicken-with-a-pulley-in-the-middle, 2 minnows, and some yarn.

(somehow I think Guybrush could still find a way to defeat max using those items...)

In the time it takes for Guybrush to start an item combination, Max has already jumped and got his jaws into Guybrush's head in the same way he did to Hitler.

Hayden · 10/24/2010, 02:42 am

This thread ended with post #13.

What use is a gun against a lightsaber?

coolguy721 · 03/23/2011, 01:53 pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hayden

This thread ended with post #13.

What use is a gun against a lightsaber?

a light saber cant defeat psychic power's

Klatuu · 03/23/2011, 03:48 pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hayden

What use is a gun against a lightsaber?

Quote:

Originally Posted by hamza721

a light saber cant defeat psychic power's

Hokey religions and ancient weapons are no match for a good blaster at your side, kid.

View Poll Results: Guybrush Vs Max. FIGHT!!!
Guybrush would win hands-down!	19	26.39%
Max would be the victor!	48	66.67%
It would be a draw	5	6.94%
Voters: 72. You may not vote on this poll

10/17/2010, 10:45 pm	#2
divisionten Card (Whale) Shark Join Date: Mar 2010 Location: 時の向こう風の町 Posts: 2,314	Sorry Guybrush, if we're talking a straight up fight in an arena, your organs will be strewn across the ground in 5 minutes or less (see: Demon Peepers). Now, if we're talking tactical battle with hiding places and items, Guybrush has a chance. Max isn't stupid- he's certainly mentally unstable but NOT stupid (see They Stole Max's Bran, Egypt section, where it's essentially Max being rational and in control)- but he has nothing on Guybrush's level of sheer ingenuity. __________________ I am a community moderator, here to assist, keep the peace, and keep these boards clean and friendly for all. I am a volunteer, and not a Telltale employee, and my opinions are my own. --Playin' poker with GLaDOS before it was cool--

10/18/2010, 05:01 am	#4
Captain Mickey Mighty Pirate Enthusiast Join Date: Sep 2009 Location: You know what? I have no idea... Posts: 477	I think Guybrush has a chance at winning. He's smart enough to find a way around Max. __________________ I don't care, I said 40 hours. It's gonna be 40 hours. Player Be Damned! -Ron Gilbert, MI2:SE Commentary

10/18/2010, 07:53 am	#5
Alcoremortis Lonely Ruffian Join Date: Jul 2009 Location: Ankh-Morpork PD Status: Killjoy Extraordinaire Actual Posts: Lots! Posts: 4,371	I think it depends on what Guybrush has in his inventory. __________________ ETERNAL QUEEN OF HALLOWEEN STATUS CONFERRED. ~ Comrade Pants How can we be sure that Alcoremortis isn't just Comrade Pants trollplaying as a girl? ~ GuruGuru214 You're a shiny bright star; floating amongst a million slimy slugs in a sea of sludge. You transcend the pre-conceived and supposed limits of the human race, to emerge from the pit of pitiful maggots as a beautiful, majestic butterfly. ~ Davies The suspence of what's gonna come after death is killing me! ~ Jon NA Are you a secret Plaster Princess or something? ~ Secret Fawful

10/18/2010, 12:31 pm	#7
crfh Senior Member Join Date: Sep 2010 Location: Mexico Posts: 709	Rule of Comedy, guys. Max wins. __________________ Power Nap A guy who has to sleep in a world that never sleeps anymore. College Roomies from Hell!!! Mutants, tentacles, Satan, gun-toting girls.

10/17/2010, 08:26 pm	#1
Ashton Senior Member Join Date: Apr 2008 Posts: 1,017	ToMI vs S+M! Who would win? (1) Who do you think would win in a fight? (non-psychic) Max or Guybrush? Vote! ^__^

10/18/2010, 02:29 am	#3
caeska Monkey Smuggler Join Date: Mar 2010 Location: Fondor Orbital Shipyards Posts: 740	Well I like both, but fighting is the only way to find out which is better. But in my opinion, Guybrush would win. He's taken down Lechuck what, 8 times? (SOMI, LcR, twice in CMI, EfMI, the Walrus Lechuck and technically twice in ToMI. So yeah, Max would have nothing on him.

10/18/2010, 08:58 am	#6
jeeno0142 Love is for the Living. Join Date: Apr 2010 Location: Liverpool, England Posts: 1,122	I really think it would be a draw. Max would be fighting with his fists and Guybrush would be fighting him off using logic. It sounds like an epic battle that will last centuries.

10/19/2010, 01:28 am	#9
Javi-Wan Kenobi Adventure Gaming Jedi Join Date: Jul 2009 Location: Estella, Navarra, Spain Posts: 1,060	Sadly, Guybrush won't have the slightest chance in a physical fight (with or without weapons and/or inventory items). But in a battle of wits, Guybrush is more likely to be the winner, even if it's by luck or accident.

10/19/2010, 07:30 am	#10
jaden551 My name is of many. Join Date: Feb 2008 Location: In G land. Posts: 437	If anything it should be witch writing team can type faster and still make it sound like their character. __________________ KAGE BUSHIN NO JUTSU! Follow me on twitter: http://twitter.com/theREALjaden550

10/19/2010, 08:43 am	#11
Scnew Fighter of the Night Man Join Date: Jul 2010 Posts: 956	Max has a gun and a love of using it.

10/19/2010, 10:13 am	#12
SlasherMan Senior Member Join Date: Oct 2009 Location: Puerto Rico... As far as I know I'm the only Sam & Max fan that was born and raised in this island. Posts: 239	Yup, Max would win... Though I thought at first this poll would be which series was better, if it was that, I would'nt chose since I love both series equally... But hey, this is a vs. Battle so I say Max would definitly win. __________________ Not changing this signature until Sam & Max Season Four is announced. Date Started: 11/28/11

10/24/2010, 02:42 am	#16
Hayden ...is procrastinating Join Date: Jul 2009 Location: Australia Posts: 3,498	This thread ended with post #13. What use is a gun against a lightsaber? __________________ Read that instead ^.

Thread Tools	Search this Thread
Show Printable Version Email this Page	Search this Thread: Advanced Search

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
We want TOMI on XBL !!!!!	Fliter	Tales of Monkey Island General Discussion	112	12/16/2012 12:56 pm
A crazy yet fair TOMI question	unicronic	Tales of Monkey Island General Discussion	16	06/18/2010 05:01 am
I Love ToMI so far!	Agetian	Tales of Monkey Island General Discussion	3	10/20/2009 06:55 am
Problems with ToMI 3 - [issue-21670]	clairelc	Game Support - General	4	10/10/2009 11:59 am
So, is basically TOMI for PC an oversized WII port?	Bloody Eugene	Tales of Monkey Island General Discussion	56	08/07/2009 01:33 pm