Quote:
Originally Posted by Chyron8472
I will watch The Phantom Edit then, and give them a comparison.
|
I'm watching
The Phantom Edit as we speak (10 minutes in, so far.)
I'm making notes in notepad about The Phantom Edit as I go along.
So far...
- picture quality not very good.
(top is Phantom Editor's edit, bottom is L8wrtr's edit--never mind the black bars on the top one as it has not been encoded in Handbrake yet.)
- audio quality not as good as L8wrtr's or even official DVD.
- opening crawl not a prologue
- not enough Jar Jar dialogue cuts (Jar Jar still says "ex-squeeze me")
- wipe into swimming underwater mid dialogue is weird.
- Ric Olie is still Captain Obvious.
[PAUSE: not watching anymore atm, as my wife doesn't feel like watching Star Wars. At any rate, I can remember why I'd seen so little of this edit previously, as the first 4 complaints alone are enough to warrant me looking elsewhere.]