(Ep.2 SPOILERS!) Did anyone actually kill the St. John. Brothers?

[Karibe]

Honestly i wanted to kill Andy so bad, but then it hit me that it would be even worse to let his mother which do you see coming after him eat him alive while he cant do nothing about it. I figured shooting him honestly would be giving him more mercy then the guy deserves.

[CapnJay]

Originally Posted by Karibe

Honestly i wanted to kill Andy so bad, but then it hit me that it would be even worse to let his mother which do you see coming after him eat him alive while he cant do nothing about it. I figured shooting him honestly would be giving him more mercy then the guy deserves.

Eh I was more pissed at Danny. He enjoys killing too much. I have a feeling Danny was mutilating small animals as a kid and Andy had to cover it up. With his father dead Andy's had to step into his fathers shoes juggling the care of his mom and his psychotic younger brother. It's a lot of strain on him .

[thestalkinghead]

i was sort of 50/50 when the option to kill came up, but i think it was Danny thinking it was a good idea to kill him that made me realise it was a bad thing to kill him and batman would agree, so how can i be wrong?

[bdawgnit1785]

Originally Posted by thestalkinghead

i was sort of 50/50 when the option to kill came up, but i think it was Danny thinking it was a good idea to kill him that made me realise it was a bad thing to kill him and batman would agree, so how can i be wrong?

if you watch the third batman movie you'd know different, batman find he was wrong in his give them the hero they need bs and learns truth is always better...lol just saying. man is fallible even if that mans a bat *shooting star* The more you knowww

[Kiel555]

After watching playing dead #5, I really identified with how they said many players killed Danny but when it came to Andy only a low percentage opted to kill him. Mainly because Lee's whole group was there in the rain watching Lee and this would be the second person Clem saw Lee kill as well. I think I understand why people didn't kill Andy. I'm just glad I was able to push through those emotions and kick Andy into the electrified fence. Clem will understand. Bad people need to die.

[CapnJay]

Originally Posted by Kiel555

After watching playing dead #5, I really identified with how they said many players killed Danny but when it came to Andy only a low percentage opted to kill him. Mainly because Lee's whole group was there in the rain watching Lee and this would be the second person Clem saw Lee kill as well. I think I understand why people didn't kill Andy. I'm just glad I was able to push through those emotions and kick Andy into the electrified fence. Clem will understand. Bad people need to die.

of course what if she thinks lee is a bad person

[Hudomonkey]

I couldn't kill anyone in from of clem she needs to trust you and you need to be a good role model
In the walking dead I do what is right not what will be the best thing thing or make me the most popular I will not kill I will always attempt to save and will not kill

[Hudomonkey]

Originally Posted by Kiel555

After watching playing dead #5, I really identified with how they said many players killed Danny but when it came to Andy only a low percentage opted to kill him. Mainly because Lee's whole group was there in the rain watching Lee and this would be the second person Clem saw Lee kill as well. I think I understand why people didn't kill Andy. I'm just glad I was able to push through those emotions and kick Andy into the electrified fence. Clem will understand. Bad people need to die.

Third if ... larry

[Kiel555]

Originally Posted by CapnJay

of course what if she thinks lee is a bad person

Clem is going to have to work that out on her own. Is a convicted murderer who kills bad a people a bad person? Whatever she decides is fine with me.

[Kiel555]

Originally Posted by Hudomonkey

Third if ... larry

I didn't help that wacko Kenny Kill Lilly's dad. That Kenny is a bad person.

[Ja1862]

Any money this choice will hardly be mentioned in ep3, just being a small of the hand comment or something having no real actual impact.

[Moraledilemma]

Honestly, they were both going to die anyways. Andy, being in a state of severe shock, was in no position to just get up and escape the walkers (plus your entire group was watching) and Danny was stuck in a bear trap which you learn at the beginning of the episode has no release latch. I'm not going to lower myself to their level in the name of revenge and I'm sticking by my decision.

[Cyreen]

There is really no moral high ground. Whether you killed them or left them to die, it's really all the same thing. The only difference between the two scenarios is that Clementine didn't have to watch Lee kill.

[Hudomonkey]

Originally Posted by Cyreen

There is really no moral high ground. Whether you killed them or left them to die, it's really all the same thing. The only difference between the two scenarios is that Clementine didn't have to watch Lee kill.

And that is important
You should never kill in front of Clem

[Rock114]

Killed Jolene cause I was focusing on her crossbow and not what she was saying. Killed Danny with Kenny's help after escaping the meat locker. When it gave me the choice to kill or spare Andy, I figured that enough blood had been spilled by the four dead people on the farm already, so I let him live. Felt I'd done enough horrific things in that episode, and I'll probably be trying for redemption for what I did in Episode 2 (and the senator) for the rest of the game.

[Maximus123458]

First post, whoo! Ahem, anyway.

Well, for Danny, i killed him yeah. I was way too angry, so i aimed the pitchfork at him. Of course, few seconds later i panicked because Clem saw that. :3

As for Andy, i left him, mostly because clementine. I just want to keep my relationship with her steady so i decided to not do any more harm.

God, do i care for that kid. Once Telltale makes a tough choice involving her, i will be screwed.

[Master of Aeons]

Select the gun from your inventory and then select Clementine.

[LeeLee]

I've kill both of them like a shit

it doesn't matter that Clem seen what Im done! I just would to kill those bastard so bad

[Saoralba131]

In my first save I killed none.(my mainly good guy save)Though in my second save (My pragmatic Lee) I also killed none of the brothers,I felt it wouldn't matter anyway,they weren't going anywhere...being devoured is a worse fate for those b****rds!

[yourgamesbroke]

anyone notice all the villians in games are southern people?