The Perfect Playthrough

[Red Panda]

After playing the first time, did anybody have regret or wish they would have made different choices? Did anybody replay the game to fix perceived wrongs? If so, what did you change?

I changed big things, like I didn't save Carley the first time because I didn't see the purse so I changed that. I also changed minor things, like saying manure when Clem ask what it smells like in the barn so in episode two she knows the answer in episode 2 when Duck ask the same question.

[Milosuperspesh]

Originally Posted by Red Panda

Did anybody replay the game to fix perceived wrongs? What did you change?

I changed big things, like I didn't save Carley the first time because I didn't see the purse so I changed that. I also changed minor things, like saying manure when Clem ask what it smells like in the barn so in episode two she knows the answer in episode 2 when Duck ask the same question.

welcome back ! Now behave !!

i am doing one, it's pro kenny, pro /honest clem, honest to hershal only feeding those closest to lee, not killing the brothers, i tried to save the teacher, stopping clem eating mark and i help kenny kill larry..
i also saved doug

[thestalkinghead]

i did a play through where i tried to tell everyone as much as i could about myself, i wish i could have just spoken to everyone in the group and just told them my life story (i wonder how Lee has avoided talking about it in small talk) but i told katjaa i used to be a teacher and kenny that the chemist was owned by my family and just tried to be 100% honest to everyone, i think that may add a few complications later

[j.em26]

To me, I believe a perfect playthrough is a playthrough that involves making Lee act in a Socially Desirable way.

[Master of Aeons]

I'll wait for the fourth episode finale twist before deciding what's a perfect playthrough.

[mkane24]

There is no perfect play through. I would be willing to bet no matter what choices are made its ultimately going to end in a shit show.

[Joker93]

I don't know about perfect but I wanted to be honest to hershel, make a couple choices pro lilly, not kill danny for clems sake, & stole from the car cause I don't want her tobe cold or hungry

[Awesoke]

The perfect playthrough is purely subjective in this type of game.

I haven't replayed anything on my first playthrough. I feel it defeats the purpose of what TTG is trying to accomplish. In hindsight I second guess some of the decisions I made but that's what we're supposed to do. If I changed my decisions for the sake of a better outcome, then the consequences become less meaningful.

Of course, that's what the other save slots are for.

[Joker93]

Originally Posted by Awesoke

The perfect playthrough is purely subjective in this type of game.

I haven't replayed anything on my first playthrough. I feel it defeats the purpose of what TTG is trying to accomplish. In hindsight I second guess some of the decisions I made but that's what we're supposed to do. If I changed my decisions for the sake of a better outcome, then the consequences become less meaningful.

Of course, that's what the other save slots are for.

that's why I'm sticking with my decisions the rest of the game

[Cyreen]

My initial save is based on my first instincts and I consider that my "perfect" play through. My second save has the opposite choices where in some cases I could have gone the other way, while some decisions remained the same because they really were the only choice for me.

The third save is for playing with the psychology, then deleted.

[thestalkinghead]

Originally Posted by Cyreen

My initial save is based on my first instincts and I consider that my "perfect" play through. My second save has the opposite choices where in some cases I could have gone the way, while some decisions remained the same because they really were the only choice for me.

The third save is for playing with the psychology, then deleted.

yeah similar thing for me, but even in my opposite game i cant be mean or not look after clementine

[Yertos]

Choose to leave in the day so Chet lives.

Choose Duck because we as a player know Shaun dies anyway plus Duck is a child.

Side with Kenny in the drugstore, we as a player know Duck isn't bitten, and Larry's idea of tossing him out right now is pretty dark, atleast wait to find a bite or he dies and before the change.

Tell Carley you trust her and help her deal with the radio station part.

Choose Carley to save. This one is kinda more subjective but IMO Carley has more to bring story-wise, she's the only possible survivor to know about Lee's past, she is nice to you, supports you as the leader, and the always thought of romance option.

Don't cut the leg. Like before, we as the player know he'll die anyway and cutting off his leg for no reason is only causing the man more pain.

Don't shoot Jolene, kinda obvious.

Stop Clem from eating people.

Try to save Larry, despite personal opinions on the man, he's dieing and needs to try and be saved. Plus Kenny's solution isn't wrong, but he wants to act to quick instead of waiting a little bit, much like Larry wanting to toss Duck out ASAP.

Don't kill the brothers, murder is wrong and Danny isn't going anywhere much like the teacher, and Andy gets surrounded and killed by walkers anyway.

Don't steal the food. Stealing is wrong and it upsets Clem, the "perfect" playthrough should be 100% favouring Clem.

Also don't be a dick to people lol, kinda obvious though.

The above playthrough is MY opinion on the best you can do currently, the following could very well change after playing Episode 3, 4, and 5.

[Master of Aeons]

Man, I have to redo everything after 3.