Telltale Games

Arbitrator · 12/05/2012, 06:06 am

Most people would still save her because "OMG WOMAN LEE MIGHT BANG!"

I think, if Doug had just had THE ONE zombie on his ankle he could have stomped on (because Lee does this several times himself) and Carly was being grabbed by several zombies, I'd have gone for her. In the game of course I saved Doug for this reason.

ColtPeacemaker00 · 12/05/2012, 08:49 am

I would still save carley

Tyrant · 12/05/2012, 09:06 am

I agree, too bad she had to die.

Robbingrobin · 12/05/2012, 09:18 am

Yeah, Doug had like... 2 pairs of Zombiehands on him!

Hudomonkey · 12/05/2012, 09:47 am

I would have chosen Carley
(I chose Doug)
Everyone has a gun only Doug has a laser pointer

Robbingrobin · 12/05/2012, 09:48 am

Just carley had a gun in episode 1.

Hudomonkey · 12/05/2012, 09:51 am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Robbingrobin

Just carley had a gun in episode 1.

Didn't Lilly also have a gun?

To be honest I couldn't really tell the difference between Lilly and Carley

They were quite similar

Only difference one had a dad and the other knew who you were

Mornai · 12/05/2012, 09:52 am

Would Doug be as bad at batteries as Carley was?

I probably still would have chosen Carley, but if everything was reversed i would lean more to Doug's side. It would be a heat of the moment decision, one i can never make beforehand.

thestalkinghead · 12/05/2012, 11:28 am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mornai

Would Doug be as bad at batteries as Carley was?

I probably still would have chosen Carley, but if everything was reversed i would lean more to Doug's side. It would be a heat of the moment decision, one i can never make beforehand.

yeah, doug never had a passion for technology and he also hadn't had his coffee that day

ClementineFTW · 12/05/2012, 12:02 pm

No. Well, yes. Maybe. Actually, I reasoned the opposite way than most people here it seems. I helped Doug because Carley had a gun, so I thought "She's armed, and a good shot, she can handle herself."
I can't be the only one to have this kind of reasoning ?

Guess I'm not pragmatic enough !

Robbingrobin · 12/05/2012, 12:38 pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by ClementineFTW

No. Well, yes. Maybe. Actually, I reasoned the opposite way than most people here it seems. I helped Doug because Carley had a gun, so I thought "She's armed, and a good shot, she can handle herself."
I can't be the only one to have this kind of reasoning ?

Guess I'm not pragmatic enough !

I thought that so much, that I thought she would shoot Dougs walkers.

QuarterPounderVlad · 12/05/2012, 12:44 pm

Save doug! He's my bro!

reversingmemories · 12/05/2012, 07:07 pm

I saved Carley because we had more interactions with her. I couldn't even give Doug an energy bar. lol. Also, she helped Lee and Glenn at the motel. And Carley saved Lee more than Doug in episode 1. Also, I saved Carley because there wouldn't be many female characters if I saved Doug and I wanted to even it out. However, I do like Doug when I did another play through with him. They're both my favorite characters. But in the end, I would still pick Carley.

Yertos · 12/05/2012, 07:18 pm

Chose Doug the first time, but it was hard and had to pause. Almost went with Carley but I figured Doug's smarts might end up being more useful then Carley, to bad it wasn't really focused on much. If reversed I would choose Carley for sure, already was on the fence but if she was smarter then for sure. Question, in this scenario does Doug know your past this time?

Doctanian · 12/07/2012, 04:53 pm

Most people saved her because she was pretty. Most people that said they saved her because she was a crack shot is lying. The crack shot thing was just a bonus.

She's a female and possible romance option. I might as well say what every other guy won't.

You really think all the outrage at Carley's death was because she was a crack shot? C'mon, now.

Mornai · 12/07/2012, 05:03 pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Doctanian

Most people saved her because she was pretty. Most people that said they saved her because she was a crack shot is lying. The crack shot thing was just a bonus.

She's a female and possible romance option. I might as well say what every other guy won't.

You really think all the outrage at Carley's death was because she was a crack shot? C'mon, now.

It was a big thing for me. In all her lifetime(that we've seen) she never misses. Headshot, headshot, headshot, not a single bullet hit anything other than the head(she probably didn't shoot to kill Andy on purpose). That is pretty damn useful in a zombie apocalypse.

Scaeva · 12/14/2012, 10:58 pm

I would have saved Doug in that case.

Carley ended up saved in my playthrough only because she seemed more useful, and since she had a gun I was hoping maybe she could somehow save Doug after dealing with her own walker.

Leegacy · 12/14/2012, 11:21 pm

xD if the roles were switched and doug was a reporter with a gun and carley was a nerd i would have killed doug because he didn't know what a battery was

Nonomino · 12/15/2012, 03:16 am

I love both Doug and Carley, so I randomly choose who to save. It wouldn't really change anything if their personality were swapped!

Arbitrator · 12/15/2012, 05:54 am

Well, Carley only had a zombie on her ankle and could have at least stomped on it. If the places were reversed I'd have saved her (being grabbed by several).

Quote:

Originally Posted by Doctanian

Most people saved her because she was pretty. Most people that said they saved her because she was a crack shot is lying. The crack shot thing was just a bonus.

She's a female and possible romance option. I might as well say what every other guy won't.

You really think all the outrage at Carley's death was because she was a crack shot? C'mon, now.

Also this.

View Poll Results: if Carley was a nerd and Doug was a crack shot would you save a different person?
yes	78	46.15%
no	91	53.85%
Voters: 169. You may not vote on this poll

12/05/2012, 08:49 am	#42
ColtPeacemaker00 ..... Join Date: Aug 2012 Location: Second star to the right and straight on till morning Posts: 101	I would still save carley __________________ "All we need is one pin Rodney."

12/15/2012, 03:16 am	#59
Nonomino Junior Member Join Date: Dec 2012 Location: Nice, France Posts: 10	I love both Doug and Carley, so I randomly choose who to save. It wouldn't really change anything if their personality were swapped! Last edited by Nonomino; 12/15/2012 at 03:18 am.

Thread Tools	Search this Thread
Show Printable Version Email this Page	Search this Thread: Advanced Search

12/05/2012, 06:06 am	#41
Arbitrator Member Join Date: Dec 2012 Posts: 67	Most people would still save her because "OMG WOMAN LEE MIGHT BANG!" I think, if Doug had just had THE ONE zombie on his ankle he could have stomped on (because Lee does this several times himself) and Carly was being grabbed by several zombies, I'd have gone for her. In the game of course I saved Doug for this reason.

12/05/2012, 09:06 am	#43
Tyrant Senior Member Join Date: Nov 2012 Posts: 136	I agree, too bad she had to die.

12/05/2012, 09:18 am	#44
Robbingrobin Senior Member Join Date: Nov 2012 Location: Somewhere safe Posts: 433	Yeah, Doug had like... 2 pairs of Zombiehands on him!

12/05/2012, 09:47 am	#45
Hudomonkey Senior Member Join Date: Aug 2012 Posts: 481	I would have chosen Carley (I chose Doug) Everyone has a gun only Doug has a laser pointer

12/05/2012, 09:48 am	#46
Robbingrobin Senior Member Join Date: Nov 2012 Location: Somewhere safe Posts: 433	Just carley had a gun in episode 1.

12/05/2012, 09:52 am	#48
Mornai Always Have Hope Join Date: Oct 2012 Location: Ohio, U.S.A. Posts: 1,026	Would Doug be as bad at batteries as Carley was? I probably still would have chosen Carley, but if everything was reversed i would lean more to Doug's side. It would be a heat of the moment decision, one i can never make beforehand.

12/05/2012, 12:02 pm	#50
ClementineFTW Junior Member Join Date: Dec 2012 Posts: 2	No. Well, yes. Maybe. Actually, I reasoned the opposite way than most people here it seems. I helped Doug because Carley had a gun, so I thought "She's armed, and a good shot, she can handle herself." I can't be the only one to have this kind of reasoning ? Guess I'm not pragmatic enough !

12/05/2012, 12:44 pm	#52
QuarterPounderVlad Senior Member Join Date: Sep 2012 Posts: 586	Save doug! He's my bro!

12/05/2012, 07:07 pm	#53
reversingmemories Member Join Date: Sep 2012 Location: I LIVE SOMEWHERE Posts: 30	I saved Carley because we had more interactions with her. I couldn't even give Doug an energy bar. lol. Also, she helped Lee and Glenn at the motel. And Carley saved Lee more than Doug in episode 1. Also, I saved Carley because there wouldn't be many female characters if I saved Doug and I wanted to even it out. However, I do like Doug when I did another play through with him. They're both my favorite characters. But in the end, I would still pick Carley.

12/05/2012, 07:18 pm	#54
Yertos Omid Fan #1 Join Date: Aug 2012 Posts: 459	Chose Doug the first time, but it was hard and had to pause. Almost went with Carley but I figured Doug's smarts might end up being more useful then Carley, to bad it wasn't really focused on much. If reversed I would choose Carley for sure, already was on the fence but if she was smarter then for sure. Question, in this scenario does Doug know your past this time?

12/07/2012, 04:53 pm	#55
Doctanian Senior Member Join Date: Nov 2012 Posts: 271	Most people saved her because she was pretty. Most people that said they saved her because she was a crack shot is lying. The crack shot thing was just a bonus. She's a female and possible romance option. I might as well say what every other guy won't. You really think all the outrage at Carley's death was because she was a crack shot? C'mon, now.

12/14/2012, 10:58 pm	#57
Scaeva Senior Member Join Date: Dec 2012 Posts: 102	I would have saved Doug in that case. Carley ended up saved in my playthrough only because she seemed more useful, and since she had a gun I was hoping maybe she could somehow save Doug after dealing with her own walker.

12/14/2012, 11:21 pm	#58
Leegacy Tea Drinking Pacifist Join Date: Nov 2012 Location: Nosgoth Posts: 30	xD if the roles were switched and doug was a reporter with a gun and carley was a nerd i would have killed doug because he didn't know what a battery was