[SPOILERS]The Walking Dead Episode 4 REVIEW Thread

[bdawgnit1785]

Originally Posted by ImmortalAbraham

I was wondering, how many people killed that first walker as soon as you exit the sewer in Crawford with their gun, because I didn't seem to have a choice there and lee went and 'axed' him a question. I've seen exactly one person use their gun to dispatch that walker guard. What exactly affects this decision? How do I make Lee shoot him? Mostly, I just want to hear Lee casually ask the guard,
"How's it going?" before shooting him like the true badass he is. Lee must be as Badass as possible in my playthrough, so that dialogue is a must. How do?

I too would like to know. I have done two plays one where I use the gun and one where its hatchet time. No clue how I did one and not the other.

[Feja10]

hi in which date for ep 4 for ipad?

[Zeruis]

Originally Posted by Feja10

hi in which date for ep 4 for ipad?

Considering the release date for the ios versions, I'm guessing that we'll see a release for episode 4 on ios following a week or two after episode 5 is released.

[angelo1985]

after having to play through the whole game again! cus it wont let me play my other saved slots anymore i realized something, the guy who took clem is probably the leader of crawford, oberson. they make a point of showing his face on the poster, and it makes since that crawford would have a radio and that if anyone got out alive it would be the leader. just my opinion.

[Roran_SK]

But wait a sec. If walkers are dead, then they are rotting too, no? Than just we need wait some years and wait until they all rot. And everything will be allright?! No?!

[Viser]

Originally Posted by Roran_SK

But wait a sec. If walkers are dead, then they are rotting too, no? Than just we need wait some years and wait until they all rot. And everything will be allright?! No?!

Now try surviving all those years. And as time passes, more and more survivors die, so the number of 'new' walkers still increases. And the survivors would have to worry more about foods and supplies as they are pretty limited.

[angelo1985]

not to mention other people who might not be so nice

[uelrindru]

I'm glad I'm not the only who saved Ben. Yeah I was pissed to find out Carley was dead because of him. I still can't really blame him for Duck and Katja. I wanted to punch him out and leave him in the street when he left Clem alone but I realized something, he's a teenager and teenagers do stupid shit all the time. I was a teenager, I did stupid shit. He wanted to do the right thing and he wants to change so I that's a step towards the right thing.
Kenny on the other hand can go straight to hell, not helping me find Clem really? When he asked me what have I done for him lately I said to myself I am leaving him here.... he will probably take the boat the minute we leave and I couldn't care less about that, I hope the herd gets him.
All in all I liked the episode but there weren't a lot of muddy questions to me, it was pretty easy to make my choices and make them quickly which is sort of dissappointing to me but the story was still good and although it did feel more like a movie than a game it was still a good movie.
Oh and I'm pretty sure the guy that was watching you was the leader of Crawford. Walkie talkie man still has me stumped though

[Roran_SK]

Originally Posted by Viser

Now try surviving all those years. And as time passes, more and more survivors die, so the number of 'new' walkers still increases. And the survivors would have to worry more about foods and supplies as they are pretty limited.

But If many survivors just grouped on some smaller island. They can build farms and be isolated from the outside zombie world. And wait those years. And If they can survive the first hard years then that shouldn t be that big problem... And they can invite something like big controlling system and every time if child born they do something like tiny bomb in his head and one monitoring chip. And that shows if he is breathing or some other things and if he is dead like for more than 5 minutes then that bomb explodes and destroy the brain. But that is little bit sci-fi thought.

[sosy]

Originally Posted by uelrindru

I'm glad I'm not the only who saved Ben. Yeah I was pissed to find out Carley was dead because of him. I still can't really blame him for Duck and Katja. I wanted to punch him out and leave him in the street when he left Clem alone but I realized something, he's a teenager and teenagers do stupid shit all the time. I was a teenager, I did stupid shit. He wanted to do the right thing and he wants to change so I that's a step towards the right thing.
Kenny on the other hand can go straight to hell, not helping me find Clem really? When he asked me what have I done for him lately I said to myself I am leaving him here.... he will probably take the boat the minute we leave and I couldn't care less about that, I hope the herd gets him.

I 100% agree.
Btw, I'm pretty sure that the leader of Crawford was the one hanged on the bell.

[NessaT]

Strange that people are saying Kenny won't come with Lee to look for Clem. I went against him and sided Lilly in the locker. I helped him take out Duck because he couldn't do it himself... and I helped him take out the little boy in the attic too.

So, yes, he bitched about it for a bit about Lee not being there for him, but he did mention also that Lee was there for Kaatja and Duck, so he went along with Lee to look for Clem.

He didn't like Ben very much though - so I was one man down.

[angelo1985]

yeah i thought that might be him hanging from the bell, also if you go against kenny too much there is no way to get him to go with you but if you sided with him on a few things then there is a chance for him to go with you, you just have to say the right things

[TWDFTW]

I think that this was a very heavy episode what with Clem going missing, the chance to kill Ben, Lee being bitten and all the other stuff that happens. I think that this deserves to be played and shouldn't written off straight away. I know people who were disappointed by this episode but I wasn't, I really enjoyed it and thought it was my second favourite episode. The end was a little predictable but it doesn't detract the tension which the games has done so well to create and build. I have plenty I could write but I will do a proper review tomorrow when I'm not so tired.

[2-_-DEAD]

Does anybody else think (if you let Ben live) Ben will be the first to die in Episode 5 since it said "You have talked Ben into coming with you"? I hope he is the first so he doesn't have the chance to get anybody else killed. Maybe since he came he will take the place of somebody else getting bitten?

[TWDFTW]

Originally Posted by angelo1985

after having to play through the whole game again! cus it wont let me play my other saved slots anymore i realized something, the guy who took clem is probably the leader of crawford, oberson. they make a point of showing his face on the poster, and it makes since that crawford would have a radio and that if anyone got out alive it would be the leader. just my opinion.

No it isn't Oberson,because when you are about to climb through the window and Ben gets grabbed by that walker hung from the bell, that was Oberson. When Crawford fell, he went and hung himself I can't remember why though.

[TWDFTW]

Originally Posted by uelrindru

Oh and I'm pretty sure the guy that was watching you was the leader of Crawford. Walkie talkie man still has me stumped though

It isn't Oberson because when you are about to climb through the window of the armoury to escape, and Ben gets grabbed by that walker hung from the bell, that was Oberson, when Crawford fell he went up there and killed himself but I'm not sure why.

I am 100% it's Oberson because I've read it everywhere, including on here. And the walkie Talkie guy is especially weird. But we will find out soon enough

[2-_-DEAD]

^ Yes that was definitely Oberson hanging from the bell.

[TWDFTW]

Originally Posted by 2-_-DEAD

^ Yes that was definitely Oberson hanging from the bell.

Cool, thanks for confirming that

[2-_-DEAD]

Originally Posted by TWDFTW

Cool, thanks for confirming that

No prob.

[RaceCarAndyMan]

For everyone talking about how this episode "proves how much choices matter," you can convince everyone (including Kenny and Ben) to come with you to find Clementine no matter how you've interacted with them. You could side against Kenny 100% of the time throughout the whole game and still get him to help.