Telltale Games

Motordead · 10/08/2012, 06:53 am

So Lilly is either abandoned or takes the RV. If she is never to be seen again in the last 2 episodes, could she in fact be the protagonist for season 2? We presume her to be dead, but than again maybe not.

thestalkinghead · 10/08/2012, 06:56 am

i don't like her already, so that would be a bad start to a season

Motordead · 10/08/2012, 07:04 am

Quote:

Originally Posted by thestalkinghead

i don't like her already, so that would be a bad start to a season

I'm inclined to agree, but so far she is the only loose end. Or perhaps this is TT explaining how she got to Woodbury?

Than again our current protagonist is a murder as well /shrug.

thestalkinghead · 10/08/2012, 07:07 am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Motordead

I'm inclined to agree, but so far she is the only loose end. Or perhaps this is TT explaining how she got to Woodbury?

Than again our current protagonist is a murder as well /shrug.

we still don't know the details of Lee's conviction no matter what options you choose he never says he is a murderer or explains what happens, but we know Lilly killed in cold blood

That1Guy · 10/08/2012, 07:13 am

I want this but I don't at the same time.

FarmerJoe · 10/08/2012, 07:14 am

Too many people hate her for what she did, so...
Not as the protagonist but I'd be interested in a season 2 cameo to see what's happened to her and how events an her actions have affected her(and if she's the same Lilly as the comics).

Realistically,I believe that Telltale is done with Lilly's story and she wont appear ever again. I think Telltale will finish Clem's story this season but may(I'm hoping) continue with Lee's.

RafaelBrasileiro · 10/08/2012, 07:16 am

may be, but would have the option of suicide right at the beginning?

Motordead · 10/08/2012, 07:22 am

Lol oh i'm sure everyone will find every way that Lilly can die in the game.

RedKoolLoops · 10/08/2012, 07:26 am

Lilly's awesome, but she's not a character I'd want to play as. She's too much of a defined personality and knowing her as the hard-ass, slightly crazy, survivor that she is, the choices we would be able to make wouldn't be as open as what we have with Lee.

I do hope she cameos again at some point though, however unlikely that may be.

Rock114 · 10/08/2012, 07:56 am

Lilly wouldn't be a good player character because we already know her and what she's like. The reason Lee is so good is because we get to define his personality right from the get-go, plus his bitchin' backstory as a history teacher.

Red Panda · 10/08/2012, 08:12 am

I can't stand Lilly's face most of the time, honestly. It has nothing to do with what she has done. She just makes ugly faces. She ends up looking like her dad, which is gross. I wouldn't want to look at that for 10-15 hours while playing season 2.

Ninnuendo · 10/08/2012, 08:34 am

Whatever happens in Season 2, I fully expect Woodbury to feature and that in turn will mean this won't be the last time we see her.

cormoran · 10/08/2012, 10:29 am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Motordead

So Lilly is either abandoned or takes the RV. If she is never to be seen again in the last 2 episodes, could she in fact be the protagonist for season 2? We presume her to be dead, but than again maybe not.

If she was the protagonist for season 2 I simply wouldn't bother buying season 2.

Phoenix VII · 10/08/2012, 10:34 am

Meh, I don't really care for her, she went too far off the deep end for my tastes in Episode 3.

Zeruis · 10/08/2012, 01:49 pm

Not as a protagonist, but she'd be one of the people who I'd look forward to seeing in season 2. Especially after what happened at the prison.

YamiRaziel · 10/08/2012, 01:59 pm

Season 2 featuring Woodbury, Lilly, The Governor and Rick's group as antagonists (the prison bandits) would be totally sick

However, Lilly can't be a protagonist. Her personality is too well-defined and it has to stay a constant. It can't change into a player dependant character.
Still it would be pretty interesting to see if people would treat her bad, judging on their previous experience with her, although their new character wouldn't have any reason to do so. Could be pulled off I believe, however, putting integral characters like the Governor and Rick.... highly unlikely because they'll have a plot armor. Nevertheless, a short cameo or just mentioning them will make me as the youtuber Tobuscus say "Nerd all over the floor"

walkerkiller413 · 10/10/2012, 05:06 am

I dont think so because Kirkman already invested in a book about Lilly before and during woodbury. I don't think he'll want anything to contradict her story. Especially considering how VERY important she is in the walking dead universe.

Cjcfman · 10/10/2012, 05:33 am

Lilly is the protagonist of the new Walking dead novel that comes out next week. Different universe (her father died protecting her from zombies), and it also details the beginning of Woodbury.

I doubt that telltale would tell that story again

NeonBlade · 10/10/2012, 06:11 am

It would be an interesting twist. I could see how Carley players would feel horrible playing as her, but I chose Doug, and his murder seemed more...natural, in terms of a conflict and narratively, and yes I left her and was very saddened.

The killing of Carley was shockingly bizarre, sloppy, out of character and shoddy penmanship. No one just out right murders someone for no reason, and no gain. Even Shane killed with a purpose. The murder of Carley was one of the most juvenile forms of writing displayed in a cinematic or digital age simply from a story stand point.

I don't know how anyone who chose Carley could call their Episode 1 a comprehensive experience. In my mind Carley was such a poorly implemented character in the structure of the game that even her death had to be forced and untidy.

So yes I would be very up to playing as Lily in episode 2.

Yertos · 10/10/2012, 09:38 am

I would love to see her again, aside from Mark's death, Lilly's departure hurt me more then any of the deaths yet. What they could do is ask Kirkman if they can expand on what happened to Lilly and the Woodbury folk after fleeing inside the prison since he kinda just left that plot point behind. We could spend an episode at the prison trying to find a way out and meeting new people from the town, another episode at Woodbury which soon falls without the Governor there, etc. Lots of cool ways they could do it and have it seem more involved with the comic then this season did with only a couple cameos.

10/08/2012, 06:53 am	#1
Motordead 'Urban' Zombie Join Date: Aug 2012 Location: Indiana Posts: 313	Lilly as protagonist for season 2 So Lilly is either abandoned or takes the RV. If she is never to be seen again in the last 2 episodes, could she in fact be the protagonist for season 2? We presume her to be dead, but than again maybe not. __________________ “ ….Many are stunned today as a man, was shot to death in the middle of the street by police in downtown Atlanta as he tried to lunge at anyone who he got near. After being given many warnings the man was shot. Police say the man was high on bath salts and couldn’t be stopped by any other means. In other news a local man saves three….” - WABE Transmission one day before the apocalypse Paul Wells Survival Story

10/08/2012, 07:22 am	#8
Motordead 'Urban' Zombie Join Date: Aug 2012 Location: Indiana Posts: 313	Lol oh i'm sure everyone will find every way that Lilly can die in the game. __________________ “ ….Many are stunned today as a man, was shot to death in the middle of the street by police in downtown Atlanta as he tried to lunge at anyone who he got near. After being given many warnings the man was shot. Police say the man was high on bath salts and couldn’t be stopped by any other means. In other news a local man saves three….” - WABE Transmission one day before the apocalypse Paul Wells Survival Story

10/10/2012, 05:06 am	#17
walkerkiller413 Junior Member Join Date: Oct 2012 Posts: 5	i dont think so I dont think so because Kirkman already invested in a book about Lilly before and during woodbury. I don't think he'll want anything to contradict her story. Especially considering how VERY important she is in the walking dead universe. Last edited by walkerkiller413; 10/10/2012 at 05:34 am.

Thread Tools	Search this Thread
Show Printable Version Email this Page	Search this Thread: Advanced Search

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
F*** Kenny	deadk1ng	The Walking Dead Story Discussion - SPOILERS	1311	Yesterday 07:03 pm
“Last Survivor” -- Walking Dead / We’re Alive Crossover (Carley is found and saved.)	ZombieGoBoom	The Walking Dead Story Discussion - SPOILERS	122	04/07/2013 06:32 pm
Episode Three – Long Road Ahead Review (Spoilers)	Gregory2012	The Walking Dead Story Discussion - SPOILERS	0	08/29/2012 07:30 pm
Will Lilly Leave the Group?	The Jubster	The Walking Dead Story Discussion - SPOILERS	69	08/12/2012 07:56 am
Lilly Rapp Interview (Lilly Caul, The Walking Dead) - Alternative Magazine Online	martymcfly	The Walking Dead Discussion	16	07/22/2012 04:00 pm

10/08/2012, 06:56 am	#2
thestalkinghead stay safe Join Date: Jul 2012 Posts: 1,895	i don't like her already, so that would be a bad start to a season

10/08/2012, 07:13 am	#5
That1Guy Senior Member Join Date: Oct 2012 Location: Brazil Posts: 201	I want this but I don't at the same time.

10/08/2012, 07:14 am	#6
FarmerJoe Senior Member Join Date: Jul 2012 Posts: 337	Too many people hate her for what she did, so... Not as the protagonist but I'd be interested in a season 2 cameo to see what's happened to her and how events an her actions have affected her(and if she's the same Lilly as the comics). Realistically,I believe that Telltale is done with Lilly's story and she wont appear ever again. I think Telltale will finish Clem's story this season but may(I'm hoping) continue with Lee's.

10/08/2012, 07:16 am	#7
RafaelBrasileiro Senior Member Join Date: Sep 2012 Location: Brazil, Rio De Janeiro Posts: 216	may be, but would have the option of suicide right at the beginning?

10/08/2012, 07:26 am	#9
RedKoolLoops Senior Member Join Date: Sep 2012 Location: UK Posts: 138	Lilly's awesome, but she's not a character I'd want to play as. She's too much of a defined personality and knowing her as the hard-ass, slightly crazy, survivor that she is, the choices we would be able to make wouldn't be as open as what we have with Lee. I do hope she cameos again at some point though, however unlikely that may be.

10/08/2012, 07:56 am	#10
Rock114 Senior Member Join Date: Jul 2012 Location: U.S. of A. Posts: 1,712	Lilly wouldn't be a good player character because we already know her and what she's like. The reason Lee is so good is because we get to define his personality right from the get-go, plus his bitchin' backstory as a history teacher.

10/08/2012, 08:12 am	#11
Red Panda Ailuridae Join Date: Aug 2012 Location: Bay Area, California Posts: 838	I can't stand Lilly's face most of the time, honestly. It has nothing to do with what she has done. She just makes ugly faces. She ends up looking like her dad, which is gross. I wouldn't want to look at that for 10-15 hours while playing season 2.

10/08/2012, 08:34 am	#12
Ninnuendo Senior Member Join Date: May 2012 Posts: 263	Whatever happens in Season 2, I fully expect Woodbury to feature and that in turn will mean this won't be the last time we see her.

10/08/2012, 10:34 am	#14
Phoenix VII Senior Member Join Date: Jul 2012 Posts: 255	Meh, I don't really care for her, she went too far off the deep end for my tastes in Episode 3.

10/08/2012, 01:49 pm	#15
Zeruis Mundy Join Date: Jun 2012 Posts: 1,945	Not as a protagonist, but she'd be one of the people who I'd look forward to seeing in season 2. Especially after what happened at the prison.

10/08/2012, 01:59 pm	#16
YamiRaziel Lilly Fan #1 Join Date: Jul 2012 Location: Woodbury Posts: 774	Season 2 featuring Woodbury, Lilly, The Governor and Rick's group as antagonists (the prison bandits) would be totally sick However, Lilly can't be a protagonist. Her personality is too well-defined and it has to stay a constant. It can't change into a player dependant character. Still it would be pretty interesting to see if people would treat her bad, judging on their previous experience with her, although their new character wouldn't have any reason to do so. Could be pulled off I believe, however, putting integral characters like the Governor and Rick.... highly unlikely because they'll have a plot armor. Nevertheless, a short cameo or just mentioning them will make me as the youtuber Tobuscus say "Nerd all over the floor"

10/10/2012, 05:33 am	#18
Cjcfman Junior Member Join Date: Jun 2012 Posts: 8	Lilly is the protagonist of the new Walking dead novel that comes out next week. Different universe (her father died protecting her from zombies), and it also details the beginning of Woodbury. I doubt that telltale would tell that story again

10/10/2012, 06:11 am	#19
NeonBlade Senior Member Join Date: Apr 2012 Posts: 142	It would be an interesting twist. I could see how Carley players would feel horrible playing as her, but I chose Doug, and his murder seemed more...natural, in terms of a conflict and narratively, and yes I left her and was very saddened. The killing of Carley was shockingly bizarre, sloppy, out of character and shoddy penmanship. No one just out right murders someone for no reason, and no gain. Even Shane killed with a purpose. The murder of Carley was one of the most juvenile forms of writing displayed in a cinematic or digital age simply from a story stand point. I don't know how anyone who chose Carley could call their Episode 1 a comprehensive experience. In my mind Carley was such a poorly implemented character in the structure of the game that even her death had to be forced and untidy. So yes I would be very up to playing as Lily in episode 2.

10/10/2012, 09:38 am	#20
Yertos Omid Fan #1 Join Date: Aug 2012 Posts: 459	I would love to see her again, aside from Mark's death, Lilly's departure hurt me more then any of the deaths yet. What they could do is ask Kirkman if they can expand on what happened to Lilly and the Woodbury folk after fleeing inside the prison since he kinda just left that plot point behind. We could spend an episode at the prison trying to find a way out and meeting new people from the town, another episode at Woodbury which soon falls without the Governor there, etc. Lots of cool ways they could do it and have it seem more involved with the comic then this season did with only a couple cameos.