I'd be completely fine with either -- I'm honestly not sure which ones I like better. Cartoon Sam was more gruff and "doggy", whereas video game Sam was more nasal and sarcastic. Cartoon Max was more sprightly, or something like that, and video game Max was, once again, more nasal and sarcastic. I guess it depends somewhat on the tone of the game, though they really didn't strike me as being all that different, aside from the cartoon adding a sidekick and not allowing "adult content".
One thing that's good to keep in mind, if you want the old voices, is that Nick Jameson does a heck of a lot of acting (most recently, he was the Russian president on 24 about a week ago), so he's not some guy at Lucasarts that only does Lucasarts stuff.
New voices, on the other hand, would worry me. Of course I'd have to hear them first...
|