The Choice Thread

[TheNNerdGamer]

ok so after months season one is finally over.
what where your choices?

my personal where:

Episode 1:
I was honest to Hershel
I saved Duck
I defended Kenny
Refused to give Irene the gun
Saved Doug (first playthrough)/Carley (second)
Episode 2:
I chopped David's leg off
I had Danny shoot Jolene
I killed Larry
I didn't kill any ST.John brothers
I didn't steal from the car
Episode 3:
I didn't shoot the girl in the street
I left Lilly on the road
I talked Kenny down
I shot Duck
I helped Omid
Episode 4:
I killed the boy in the attic
I was honest to Vernon
I brought Clem to Crawford
I pulled Ben up
I showed the bite
I got everyone with me
Episode 5:
I didn't remove Lee's arm
I lost temper with Kenny
I surrendered my weapons
I killed stranger (we all know why)
I had Clem shoot Lee
____________________________________

so what where your choices?
guys remember that you can look at your choices on the stats

[Zeruis]

Oh boy. Let's see:

Episode 1:
-Honest to Hershel
-Saved Duck
-Defended Kenny
-Did not give gun to Irene
-Chose Carley
Episode 2:
-Cut David's leg
-Let Danny shoot Jolene
-Helped Lilly in meat locker
-Did not kill St.John bros
-Did not steal from car
Episode 3:
-Let Beatrice get eaten
-Left Lilly on the road
-Talked Kenny into stopping the train
-Shot Duck
-Saved Omid
Episode 4:
-Killed the boy in the attic
-Lied to Vernon
-Brought Clem to Crawford
-Pulled Ben up
-Showed the bite; whole group came with me.
Episode 5:
-Cut arm off
-Did not lose temper with Kenny
-Surrendered weapons
-Clem shot stranger
-Told Clem to leave me

[RainbowSprinklz]

Episode 1
I was honest to Hershel
I saved Duck
I defended Kenny
Refused to give Irene the gun
Saved Carley
Episode 2
I chopped David's leg off
I had Danny shoot Jolene
I killed Larry
I didn't kill any Saint John brothers
I didn't steal from the car
Episode 3
I didn't shoot the girl in the street
I left Lilly on the road
I talked Kenny down
I shot Duck
I helped Omid
Episode 4
I had Kenny kill the boy in the attic
I was honest to Vernon
I brought Clem to Crawford
I pulled Ben up
I showed the bite
Episode 5
I removed Lee's arm
I didn't lose temper with Kenny
I surrendered my weapons
I had Clem kill the stranger (for some reason it wouldn't let me)
I had Clem shoot Lee

Pretty similar game

[CarScar]

Episode 1:

• I was honest with Hershel.
• I chose Duck over Shawn.
• I sided with Kenny.
• I gave Irene the gun.
• I chose to save Carley.

Episode 2:

• I didn't chop off David's leg.
• I didn't shoot Jolene.
• I attempted to save Larry.
• I didn't kill either of the St. John's brothers.
• I didn't steal the supplies from the car.

Episode 3:

• I shot Beatrice
• I brought Lilly with me.
• I convinced Kenny to stop the train.
• I shot Duck.
• I pushed Omid off the bridge.
• I chose to save Omid.

Episode 4:

• I killed the boy in the attic.
• I didn't lie or threaten Vernon.
• I brought Clementine with me to Crawford.
• I didn't let Ben fall to his death.
• I revealed the bite to the group.
• I got Christa, Omid, Kenny, and Ben to come with me to find Clementine.

Episode 5:

• I didn't remove Lee's arm.
• I lost my temper with Kenny (was there even an option to not lose my temper with him...)
• I kept my weapon.
• I killed the Stranger.
• I made sure Lee wouldn't turn.

[Saracenar]

Ep1
Was Dishonest
Saved Duck
Defended Kenny
Refused the Gun
Saved Doug

Ep2
Chopped the Leg
Didn't Shoot Jolene
Tried to Save Larry
Didn't Kill the Brothers
Stole from the Car

Ep3
Left the Girl
Left Lilly Behind
Fought Kenny
Shot Duck
Helped Omid

Ep4
Killed the Boy
Nice to Vernon
Left Clem at the House (with a gun)
Saved Ben
Hid the Bite; Went Alone

Ep5
Kept my Arm
Kept Calm With Kenny
Surrendered My Weapons
Clem Killed the Stranger
Had Clem Shoot Me

[HiggsBoson2142]

Ep. 1
Honest with Hershel
Saved Shawn
Defended Kenny
Gave Irene the Gun
Saved Doug
Ep. 2
Left David
Didn't shoot Jolene
Tried to help Larry (Though I sided with Kenny every other time)
Killed the brothers
Stole from the car
Ep. 3
Left the girl
Took Lilly in the RV
Fought Kenny
Shot Duck
Helped Omid
Ep. 4
Stomped the kid's head in
Was nice to Vernon
Took Clementine to Crawford
Saved Ben (Haven't dropped him ever either)
Showed the bite - Got Christa, Omid, and Ben
Ep. 5
Cut the arm off (Even though I like keeping it better)
Lost temper with Kenny
Gave all my weapons
Tried to let Stranger live (He didn't)
Had Clem shoot me

[Viser]

Eh. Here goes:

Episode 1:
-Honest with Hershel
-Saved Duck
-Sided with Kenny
-Gave Irene the Gun
-Saved Doug
Episode 2:
-Cut David's Leg off
-Didn't shoot Jolene
-Sided with Lilly in the meat locker
-Killed Danny/Spared Andy
-Didn't take supplies from the car
Episode 3:
-Shot Beatrice
-Let Lilly back into the RV
-Talked Kenny down
-Had Lee shoot Duck
-Helped Omid first
Episode 4:
-Had Kenny shoot the kid
-Didn't threaten Vernon
-Didn't take Clementine to Crawford
-Stood up for Ben and pulled him up
-Showed the bite, Omid, Christa and Ben came with me
Episode 5:
-Kept the arm
-Lost my temper with Kenny (didn't throw the marble thingy at him, though)
-Didn't surrender my weapon
-Didn't kill the stranger (Had Clem shoot him)
-Told Clementine to leave me

[Danno123]

Episode 1

I was honest to Hershel

I saved Shaun

I defended Kenny

Refused to give Irene the gun

Saved Doug

Episode 2

I chopped David's leg off

I had Danny shoot Jolene

I killed Larry

I didn't kill any ST.John brothers

I stole from the car

Episode 3

I didn't shoot the girl in the street

I left Lilly on the road

I fought Kenny

I shot Duck

I helped Omid

Episode 4

I killed the boy in the attic

I was honest to Vernon

I brought Clem to Crawford

I pulled Ben up

I showed the bite; everyone came with

Episode 5

I didn't remove Lee's arm

I lost temper with Kenny

I surrendered the walkie talkie, that's it

I killed the stranger

I had Clem leave me

Yeah, :3

[CarScar]

I'm surprised so many people saved Doug.

[Rock114]

Episode 1

Honest with Hershel
Saved Duck
Defended Kenny
Gave Irene the gun
Saved Carley

Episode 2

Cut David free
Shot Jolene
Killed Larry
Killed Danny, spared Andy
Didn't take the food

Episode 3

Shot the girl
Left Lilly
Talked Kenny down
Shot Duck
Helped Christa

Episode 4

Had Kenny kill the kid
Was nice to that bastard (Vernon)
Left Clem at the house
Dropped Ben
Showed the bite
Got Christa, Omid, and Kenny to come with me

Episode 5

Kept the arm
Lost Temper with Kenny (I just wanted to know what would happen when I picked up the statue)
Kept all my weapons (why wouldn't I?)
Clementine killed the Stranger
Had Clem shoot Lee

[Perfect_Cell]

Episode 1:
I was honest to Hershel
I saved Shawn(tried at least)
I defended Kenny
gave Irene the gun
Saved Carley
Episode 2:
I chopped David's leg off
I had Danny shoot Jolene
I killed Larry
I didn't kill any ST.John brothers
I didn't steal from the car
Episode 3:
I shot the girl in the street
I left Lilly on the road
I fought Kenny
I shot Duck
I helped Omid
Episode 4:
I killed the boy in the attic
I was honest to Vernon
I didn't bring Clem to Crawford
I dropped Ben
I showed the bite
Kenny,omid,christa came
Episode 5:
I did remove Lee's arm
I didn't lose temper with Kenny
I surrendered my weapons
I dind't kill him( I was hoping to talk him down)
I had Clem shoot Lee

Good times

[dinofire]

Episode 1:
I was honest to Hershel
I saved Shawn
I did mixed neutral and Kenny, but no Larry.
Refused to give Irene the gun
Saved Carley
Episode 2:
I chopped David's leg off
I had Danny shoot Jolene
I killed Larry
I didn't kill any ST.John brothers
I didn't steal from the car
Episode 3:
I didn't shoot the girl in the street
I took Lilly with me.
I talked Kenny down
I shot Duck
I helped Omid
Episode 4:
I killed the boy in the attic
I was honest to Vernon
I brought Clem to Crawford
I pulled Ben up
I showed the bite
I got everyone but Ben
Episode 5:
I didn't remove Lee's arm
I talked to Kenny and let him grab the sculpture (lol Omid)
I surrendered my weapons
I killed stranger
I had Clem leave Lee

Lol, 95% of my choices are the same as yours xD

[englishnick]

Pretty sure I remembered this correctly:

Episode 1:
I withheld the truth with Hershel
I saved Duck
I defended Kenny
Helped Irene kill herself
Saved Doug (reflex... not thought out)
Episode 2:
I chopped David's leg off
I had Danny shoot Jolene
I killed Larry
I killed one but spared the other
I stole from the car
Episode 3:
I shot the girl in the street
I left Lilly on the road
I talked Kenny down
I shot Duck
I helped christa instead of omid (again... reflexively pressed a direction without taking the time to think...)
Episode 4:
I killed the boy in the attic
I was honest to Vernon
I brought Clem to Crawford
I dropped Ben's coward, screw-up ass
I hid the bite
Only Kenny came with me
Episode 5:
I didn't remove Lee's arm
I lost temper with Kenny
I surrendered my weapons
I killed stranger
I had Clem shoot Lee

[Pickles312]

Episode 1

- I was honest with Hershel
- I saved Shawn
- I defended Kenny
- I let Irene have the gun
- I saved Carley

Episode 2

- I chopped David's leg off
- I had Danny shoot Jolene
- I killed Larry
- I spared the St. John brothers for the walkers
- I didn't steal from the car

Episode 3

- I left the girl in the street
- I left Lilly
- I talked Kenny down
- I shot Duck
- I helped Omid

Episode 4

- I killed the boy in the attic
- I was honest to Vernon
- I brought Clem to Crawford
- I saved Ben
- I showed the bite
- Everyone came with me

Episode 5

- I removed Lee's arm
- I kept calm with Kenny
- I kept my weapons
- I killed the stranger
- I had Clem shoot Lee

[xXNinjaScoreXx]

How do you not lose your temper with Kenny, I chose all the non bad word choices, and even tried to be completely silent.

[thestalkinghead]

Episode 1:
I was honest to Hershel
I saved Duck
I defended Kenny
I gave Irene the gun
Saved Doug
Episode 2:
I chopped David's leg off
I had Danny shoot Jolene
I killed Larry
I didn't kill any ST.John brothers
I took the supplies from the car
Episode 3:
I didn't shoot the girl in the street
I let lilly back in the RV
I talked Kenny down
I shot Duck
I helped Omid
Episode 4:
I got kenny to kill the zombie kid
I was honest to Vernon and not threatening
I got clementine to stay with omid and gave her the gun
I pulled Ben up
I hid the bite
I got everyone with me
Episode 5:
I didn't remove Lee's arm
I didn't loose my temper with Kenny (but it was heated and later said sorry)
I didnt touch the statue
I surrendered my weapons
I didn't kill the stranger Clementine did
I told clementine to cuff the zombie
I had Clem shoot Lee

[o0HeaDShoT0o]

These are the choices that I made:

Episode 1:
-Honest with Hershel
-Chose Duck
-Defended Kenny
-Refused the Gun
-Saved Carley

Episode 2:
-Cut David's Leg off
-Had Danny shoot Jolene
-Helped Kenny kill Larry
-Spared Danny and Andy
-Stole supplies from the car

Episode 3:
-Didn't shoot Beatrice
-Left Lilly on the road
-Talked Kenny down
-Had Lee shoot Duck
-Helped Omid first

Episode 4:
-Had Kenny shoot the kid
-Honest and rational with Vernon
-Brought Clementine to Crawford
-Dropped Ben
-Showed the bite - Omid, Christa and Kenny came with me

Episode 5:
-Kept the arm
-Kept cool with Kenny
-Surrender weapons
-Killed the stranger
-Told Clementine to shoot Lee

[Sutinen]

Episode 1

Semi-honest with Hershel
Saved Duck
Defended Kenny
Didn't give the gun to Irene (Where the fuck did this name come from?)
Saved Carley

Episode 2

Cut David free
Let Danny shoot Jolene
Helped Kenny to kill Larry
Didn't kill Danny or Andy
Didn't take the food

Episode 3

Didn't shoot the girl
Left Lilly
Fought Kenny (I didn't intend to, but he just randomly got pissed off and tried to whoop my ass, so I beat him down )
Shot Duck
Helped Omid (I thought I should help him, because he hurt his leg.)

Episode 4

Killed the kid
Threatened Vernon
Took Clementine to Crawford
Saved Ben
Showed the bite
Got Christa, Omid, and Kenny to come with me (Ben left behind)

Episode 5

Had the arm cut off
I kept calm with Kenny
Kept the cleaver
Choked the fucker with one hand
Had Clem shoot Lee

[Ghositex]

Episode 1:
I was honest to Hershel - I don't quite get why people would lie to him.
I saved Shawn - I don't really know why, should have saved Duck.
I defended Kenny - Gave hell to larry, thought the "NO" option would be less violent. This is the only time i rewound my save file.
Gave Irenne the gun - She would turn and we would have to shoot her later: Why not prevent her from turning? She was dead one way or another.
Saved Carley - I liked her and got to spend more time with her than I did with Doug. Doug was an okay guy, I liked him.

Episode 2:
I chopped David's leg off
I shot Jolenne - Accidentally /lol
I tried to save Larry - It WAS risky, since we didn't know (I didn't know) if he would make it. I also tried killing him on a second alt save file: I hated how you had to drag Lilly away from his Larry
I didn't kill any ST.John brothers - Spared Danny's life, and Andy got paralyzed (but not killed) by his own electrified fence.
I didn't steal from the car - Telling the other about to starve survivors wouldn't get them to stop looting the car, I figured out they would still take it and I thought it's owner might had been alive (unlikely, since the car ran out of fuel, the keys were still on, and everything. but well... episode 5..)

Episode 3:
I shot Beatrice - I just had to shoot her.
I brought Lilly with me - everyone could have a mental breakdown in a ZA, and I would like people supporting me if I had just lost everything I had. I'm not saying that Lilly's decissions were the best (Carley/Doug), but I dont know how I would have reacted in her shoes.
I fought with Kenny - I didn't want to, but somehow I still had to do it.
I shot Duck - If I had kids of my own, I wouldn't want to be the one putting them out of their missery. Specially not after losing the love of my life.
I helped Omid - Saving a young, fit woman wearing a sports jacket over a recently injured guy: Really?

Episode 4:
I killed the boy in the attic - Both of the options here are indirectly helping Kenny.
I was honest to Vernon - Again, why lying?
I brought Clem to Crawford - She is always safer when Lee is taking care of her. Besides, there was the Radio guy (Stranger) stalking us.
I pulled Ben up
I showed the bite - Once again, WHY lying?
I got everyone with me - Kenny didn't give me his bro speech, but he came with me anyways.

Episode 5:
I didn't remove Lee's arm - Lee was already feeling sick, meaning the infection already had spread thru his body. Besides, he could have needed his arm later.
I lost temper with Kenny - Snowball Statue fight!
I surrendered my weapons - He would have just got more pissed if he found out Lee still had weapons, and I would (i guess) have reacted fast enough to take his gun away.
I killed stranger - yeah..
I had Clem shoot Lee - If she could shoot Lee, she could shoot anyone afterwards. She had to go through this.

[Ghositex]

Originally Posted by xXNinjaScoreXx

How do you not lose your temper with Kenny, I chose all the non bad word choices, and even tried to be completely silent.

Shit happens, I suppose.