Telltale Games

Hudomonkey · 11/26/2012, 08:22 am

If you chose every single good option is it possible for the Stranger to not call you a monster?

Just wondering

littlezoe · 11/26/2012, 08:25 am

Where are you headed?

Hudomonkey · 11/26/2012, 08:29 am

Quote:

Originally Posted by littlezoe

Where are you headed?

I'm headed to the land of the hypothetical

trd84 · 11/26/2012, 08:32 am

He nitpicks anything you do.

zeke10 · 11/26/2012, 08:39 am

*Steps on a bug*
Stranger:Your a MONSTER!!!

Viser · 11/26/2012, 08:42 am

Yeah, he'll never like Lee. Keep in mind that that guy is a tad bit crazy and wants Clem to himself, so he'll obviously call back on anything that makes you look like a bad guardian for her, even if you had a valid reason for doing so.

zeke10 · 11/26/2012, 08:44 am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Viser

Yeah, he'll never like Lee. Keep in mind that that guy is a tad bit crazy and wants Clem to himself, so he'll obviously call back on anything that makes you look like a bad guardian for her, even if you had a valid reason for doing so.

Him and jolene would make a great couple

Hudomonkey · 11/26/2012, 08:51 am

He shouted at me for letting her eat human meat, taking her to crawford and not telling her about my past

zeke10 · 11/26/2012, 08:54 am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hudomonkey

He shouted at me for letting her eat human meat, taking her to crawford and not telling her about my past

"Your a monster"
Also what happens if you let her eat it?

Snake Liquid · 11/26/2012, 08:57 am

He criticized me for taking her to the dairy farm. And mind you, when she came there, there was absolutely no indication that it wasn't safe and that the St. Johns were nothing more than just farmers trying to help people. Taking her there for food when she's starving and as a potential safer place is something literally any one would do, and that includes probably her real father and yet, the stranger was still infuriated that I did that.

If you take Lilly with you in the RV, he'll criticize you for taking an unstable crazy woman with you in the RV. If you leave her, he'll criticize you for leaving a grieving woman by the side of the road.

My brother played through, and he criticized him for saving a pretty girl with a gun over an innocent man (saving Carley over Doug).

Nothing you do is the right thing in this guys eye, and he will criticize any choice you made.

Hudomonkey · 11/26/2012, 08:58 am

Quote:

Originally Posted by zeke10

"Your a monster"
Also what happens if you let her eat it?

Nothing really...

I told her she was eating human meat when I should have told her to spit it out

You get a slightly different dialogue choice

My bad decisions were either mistakes or saved Molly's Life

zeke10 · 11/26/2012, 09:01 am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hudomonkey

Nothing really...

I told her she was eating human meat when I should have told her to spit it out

You get a slightly different dialogue choice

My bad decisions were either mistakes or saved Molly's Life

Oh does he get mad if i let larry eat it

bazenji · 11/26/2012, 10:21 am

He hated me for killing a man in front of her and taking her into danger with me...somewhere...I guess...

Joe Newberry · 11/26/2012, 10:31 am

No matter what choices you made (including not allowing Lee or Clem to take anything from his station wagon), he was always going to find a reason to hate you. Kind of makes all the choices seem less significant somehow, since they all lead to this same confrontation regardless.

The_Cheshire_Cat · 11/26/2012, 10:59 am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Joe Newberry

No matter what choices you made (including not allowing Lee or Clem to take anything from his station wagon), he was always going to find a reason to hate you. Kind of makes all the choices seem less significant somehow, since they all lead to this same confrontation regardless.

yeah sounds about right.

though I guess it would be weird to get a slap on the back from the guy that has the head of his zombie wife in a bowling bag.

Gratefully Dead · 11/26/2012, 11:01 am

Save the animal crackers from episode 3! Don't give'm to Duck! Lee will give them to the stranger and they'll chuckle about how his kid used to like them.

.....DO IT.

marcu5 · 11/26/2012, 11:01 am

he definitely didnt have a strong case against me. only hates me for things i couldnt control

DreadMagus · 11/26/2012, 11:27 am

To be honest, he didn't seem to hate my Lee and was glad things were going diplomatically.

CarScar · 11/26/2012, 02:47 pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by DreadMagus

To be honest, he didn't seem to hate my Lee and was glad things were going diplomatically.

How the hell did you manage that? He hated me because I:

A. Saved Carley over Doug.

B. Brought Clem with me to the St. John's Dairy.

C. Brought Lilly with me on the RV.

He's so unreasonable, why is it a bad thing I saved Carley over Doug? She has the only gun in the group (so far) and Doug would have probably wanted me to save her instead of himself (that's just the kind of guy Doug is). Also Lee, or at least my Lee, developed a much stronger relationship with Carley (there's few conversation choices you get with Doug in episode 1). I had no control over Clem coming to the St. Johns, we all go there regardless of what I say. Why is it a bad thing I brought Lilly with me on the RV? Isn't that a good thing? Apparently he gets mad at you either way apparently, it's like what the hell do you want me to do Stranger?!

He's just crazy.

Zarron · 11/26/2012, 02:50 pm

I wonder how he decides what to chew you out for; I brought Lilly on the RV with us, but he never mentioned that with me.

11/26/2012, 08:22 am	#1
Hudomonkey Senior Member Join Date: Aug 2012 Posts: 496	Can the stranger like you? If you chose every single good option is it possible for the Stranger to not call you a monster? Just wondering Last edited by Hudomonkey; 11/26/2012 at 08:29 am.

11/26/2012, 11:27 am	#18
DreadMagus Arrgh! Thar Be Zombies! Join Date: Sep 2012 Location: The space between worlds. Posts: 2,089	To be honest, he didn't seem to hate my Lee and was glad things were going diplomatically. __________________ WITCH! Oh sorry, got confused by all your crying. ~ Francis

Thread Tools	Search this Thread
Show Printable Version Email this Page	Search this Thread: Advanced Search

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
Clem knocks the stranger the fugg out!	Motordead	The Walking Dead Story Discussion - SPOILERS	10	12/01/2012 06:32 am
How do you let the Stranger survive?	AsariTears	The Walking Dead Story Discussion - SPOILERS	16	11/28/2012 11:55 pm
Question about stranger	PsychologyOK	The Walking Dead Story Discussion - SPOILERS	14	11/25/2012 08:12 am
Pirates of the Caribbean: On Stranger Tides	Hayden	General Chat	151	06/07/2011 09:10 am
Ron Gilbert - On Stranger Tides - And Tales of Monkey Island SPOILERS	sladerlmc77	Tales of Monkey Island General Discussion	11	07/27/2009 02:33 pm

11/26/2012, 08:25 am	#2
littlezoe Junior Member Join Date: Jul 2012 Posts: 27	Where are you headed?

11/26/2012, 08:32 am	#4
trd84 Senior Member Join Date: Jun 2012 Posts: 368	He nitpicks anything you do.

11/26/2012, 08:39 am	#5
zeke10 Legendary Solider҉ Join Date: Nov 2012 Location: Badass crater of badassitude Posts: 197	Steps on a bug Stranger:Your a MONSTER!!!

11/26/2012, 08:42 am	#6
Viser Ben is a cool guy Join Date: Aug 2012 Location: Brazil Posts: 422	Yeah, he'll never like Lee. Keep in mind that that guy is a tad bit crazy and wants Clem to himself, so he'll obviously call back on anything that makes you look like a bad guardian for her, even if you had a valid reason for doing so.

11/26/2012, 08:51 am	#8
Hudomonkey Senior Member Join Date: Aug 2012 Posts: 496	He shouted at me for letting her eat human meat, taking her to crawford and not telling her about my past

11/26/2012, 08:57 am	#10
Snake Liquid Senior Member Join Date: Sep 2012 Posts: 152	He criticized me for taking her to the dairy farm. And mind you, when she came there, there was absolutely no indication that it wasn't safe and that the St. Johns were nothing more than just farmers trying to help people. Taking her there for food when she's starving and as a potential safer place is something literally any one would do, and that includes probably her real father and yet, the stranger was still infuriated that I did that. If you take Lilly with you in the RV, he'll criticize you for taking an unstable crazy woman with you in the RV. If you leave her, he'll criticize you for leaving a grieving woman by the side of the road. My brother played through, and he criticized him for saving a pretty girl with a gun over an innocent man (saving Carley over Doug). Nothing you do is the right thing in this guys eye, and he will criticize any choice you made.

11/26/2012, 10:21 am	#13
bazenji Senior Member Join Date: Aug 2012 Posts: 116	He hated me for killing a man in front of her and taking her into danger with me...somewhere...I guess...

11/26/2012, 10:31 am	#14
Joe Newberry Call the Meteor Police! Join Date: Nov 2007 Location: Acworth, GA Posts: 100	No matter what choices you made (including not allowing Lee or Clem to take anything from his station wagon), he was always going to find a reason to hate you. Kind of makes all the choices seem less significant somehow, since they all lead to this same confrontation regardless.

11/26/2012, 11:01 am	#16
Gratefully Dead Senior Member Join Date: Jun 2012 Posts: 124	Save the animal crackers from episode 3! Don't give'm to Duck! Lee will give them to the stranger and they'll chuckle about how his kid used to like them. .....DO IT.

11/26/2012, 11:01 am	#17
marcu5 Senior Member Join Date: Jul 2012 Posts: 395	he definitely didnt have a strong case against me. only hates me for things i couldnt control

11/26/2012, 02:50 pm	#20
Zarron Junior Member Join Date: Nov 2012 Posts: 26	I wonder how he decides what to chew you out for; I brought Lilly on the RV with us, but he never mentioned that with me.