Telltale Games

That1Guy · 12/09/2012, 07:08 am

Since there's been many mercy choices thorought the game, I wanted to know what other people did.

Ghositex · 12/09/2012, 07:17 am

Gave Irenne the gun, because we would have to shoot her anyways (cleaning the Motor Inn). Why not let her die without turning? Shot Beatrice, because I'd like someone to do the same if i were about to get nomnomnom'ed by zombies; Clementine shot me.

CharmingBirch · 12/09/2012, 07:37 am

I didn't give Irene the gun.

I left the girl on the street because, let's face it, I didn't want the extra attention and Kenny was 100% right in his suggestion. Still don't know what happens when you do shoot her, but I imagine things are a bit more difficult.

I shot Duck.

I had Clem shoot me, and I didn't hesitate for a minute. I guess I'm in the minority by thinking leaving Lee and/or watching him turn into a walker would be MORE traumatizing than shooting him. She says so many times throughout the game, "Please don't become one of them", that shooting him would at least give her some kind of peace. Especially when you choose "Don't be afraid" as your last words. Just drives the point home to me.

Arbitrator · 12/09/2012, 07:48 am

Gave Irene the gun.

Shot the girl in the street. Yeah, it would draw attention but... THOSE SCREAMS, man.
I shot Duck. Making Kenny do it would tip the man over the edge.

Had Clem shoot me. I doubt she'd be able to shake the knowledge Lee was chained in some cellar as a zombie. long-term it was best.

Quote:

Originally Posted by CharmingBirch

I left the girl on the street because, let's face it, I didn't want the extra attention and Kenny was 100% right in his suggestion. Still don't know what happens when you do shoot her, but I imagine things are a bit more difficult.

You have less time to collect stuff from the chemist. It is possible to collect enough that you still get "You collected a lot of stuff" and the "This will see us through the winter" line from Lilly.

That1Guy · 12/09/2012, 07:53 am

Wow, excluding the Duck and Lee choice this is pretty damn even.

QuarterPounderVlad · 12/09/2012, 08:11 am

Didn't give Irene the gun, Left the girl (Beatrice, was it?)
Shot duck myself, Clem shot Lee.

MuffinMansBro · 12/09/2012, 08:33 am

Gave Irene the gun

Shot Beatrice (I probably would have left her if Kenny didn't make it sound like such an asshole thing to do)

Shot Duck myself

Clem shot me.

Kaserkin · 12/09/2012, 08:42 am

Not in my group? Not wasting bullets, sorry.

Zeruis · 12/09/2012, 09:21 am

-Didn't give Irene the gun.
-Left the woman on the street.
-Shot Duck myself.
-Told Clem to leave me.

ZacTB · 12/09/2012, 09:21 am

I gave Irene the gun, shot the girl in the street, shot Duck and had Clementine shoot Lee. Also I killed the boy in the attic.

Always think the nicest thing to do is kill someone who is bitten. Hardest decision to make out of all of those was the girl in the street, actually. Thought putting her out of her misery was a much nicer thing to do.

StarvingHobo · 12/09/2012, 09:39 am

I tried to play true to what my real life actions would be, but it's hard to do... In real life NO WAY would Irene get the gun, she was so high strung, imagine she just turned psycho like "F*** IT ALL!!!!!" and shot us all before topping herself... Or maybe she'd turn whilst holding the gun and then it might be hard to get back (I forget if anyone else had a gun at the time)...

Also I would have probably let myself become a walker rather than getting shot in the head, just on the off chance I somehow managed to survive (fuck knows how, but headshot = NOPE)...

I should really do a truthful playthrough next time. Funny 'cause I totally would have made everyone else do the dangerous stuff even bitten. I'd be all "lol you guys walk across the rickety sign I have one arm!"...

DreadMagus · 12/09/2012, 09:48 am

Gave Irene the gun.

Left the girl - she was dead anyway and I needed the distraction.

Shot duck.

Had Clem shoot Lee.

Ghositex · 12/09/2012, 11:12 am

Quote:

Originally Posted by DreadMagus

Gave Irene the gun.

Left the girl - she was dead anyway and I needed the distraction.

Shot duck.

Had Clem shoot Lee.

Irene, Duck, and Lee were dead anyway and you could have saved the bullets :P

Robbingrobin · 12/09/2012, 11:42 am

Ghositex is right.

Rock114 · 12/09/2012, 01:30 pm

Gave her the gun

Shot the girl

Shot Duck

Had Clem shoot Lee. The world has enough walkers in it already.

YamiRaziel · 12/09/2012, 01:36 pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rock114

Gave her the gun

Shot the girl

Shot Duck

Had Clem shoot Lee. The world has enough walkers in it already.

Same for me

TheRickGrimes · 12/09/2012, 01:37 pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Arbitrator

Gave Irene the gun.

Shot the girl in the street. Yeah, it would draw attention but... THOSE SCREAMS, man.
I shot Duck. Making Kenny do it would tip the man over the edge.

Had Clem shoot me. I doubt she'd be able to shake the knowledge Lee was chained in some cellar as a zombie. long-term it was best.

You have less time to collect stuff from the chemist. It is possible to collect enough that you still get "You collected a lot of stuff" and the "This will see us through the winter" line from Lilly.

This.

DreadMagus · 12/10/2012, 12:02 am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ghositex

Irene, Duck, and Lee were dead anyway and you could have saved the bullets :P

I didn't need them for a distraction.

Besides, I made an effort to "save" Irene. Leaving her after that would have been cruel.

Duck was part of the team.

And Clem needed to learn how to put down "friends" - Lee's death was a sacrifice to improve her chances of survival.

"The Girl" - letting her die bloody gave me a chance to help feed my people. Sucked to be her. Wrong place, wrong time.

Snake Liquid · 12/10/2012, 03:53 am

Irene: Didn't give her the gun. This is still one of the early days in the apocalypse. From Lee's perspective, he didn't want people to give up already. He didn't fully understand the infection, and wasn't ready at that point to give someone a gun to end their life.

Beatrice: Left her in the street. An awful act, but she was bitten and I had to think about everyone back at the motel. If I shot her, that would instantly draw all the walkers in Macon on me and Kenny while we tried to get supplies.

Duck: I shot him. By this point, Lee understands what is going on in the world. They can't just leave the little boy to become a walker, and he wasn't going to make one of the kid's parents do it.

Lee: Clementine shot him. Personally, I think it'd be more emotionally devastating for Clem to leave knowing that Lee was going to come back as one of the walkers, especially after just having seen her parents in the street as walkers.

Mornai · 12/11/2012, 07:33 am

Didn't give Irene the gun. - I wouldn't let her give up... plus it was still early in the apocalypse. I wouldn't change my decision now either.

Shot the girl in the street. - Losing morality for survival means one step closer to becoming the next St. Johns/Crawford/Bandits, and i refuse to let that happen.

Shot Duck. - No parent should have to kill their own child.

Clem shot Lee. - Becoming a walker is a fate worse than death, and one that Lee shouldn't have to go through.

The difference in the first and last decisions for me are how it happens. Killing yourself so you won't turn just feels wrong to me...

View Poll Results: What did you do?
Gave Irene the gun	72	60.50%
Didn't give her the gun	43	36.13%
Shot the girl on the street	59	49.58%
Left her on the street	57	47.90%
Shot Duck	103	86.55%
Kenny shot Duck	11	9.24%
Left Duck	2	1.68%
Clem shot Lee	94	78.99%
Left Lee	24	20.17%
Multiple Choice Poll. Voters: 119. You may not vote on this poll

12/09/2012, 07:08 am	#1
That1Guy Senior Member Join Date: Oct 2012 Location: Brazil Posts: 206	Dealing with the bitten Since there's been many mercy choices thorought the game, I wanted to know what other people did.

12/09/2012, 07:17 am	#2
Ghositex Senior Member Join Date: Oct 2012 Location: A house. With windows. Posts: 380	Gave Irenne the gun, because we would have to shoot her anyways (cleaning the Motor Inn). Why not let her die without turning? Shot Beatrice, because I'd like someone to do the same if i were about to get nomnomnom'ed by zombies; Clementine shot me. __________________ ~Goodbye, she quietly says~

12/09/2012, 07:53 am	#5
That1Guy Senior Member Join Date: Oct 2012 Location: Brazil Posts: 206	Wow, excluding the Duck and Lee choice this is pretty damn even. Last edited by That1Guy; 12/09/2012 at 07:56 am.

12/09/2012, 09:48 am	#12
DreadMagus Arrgh! Thar Be Zombies! Join Date: Sep 2012 Location: The space between worlds. Posts: 2,095	Gave Irene the gun. Left the girl - she was dead anyway and I needed the distraction. Shot duck. Had Clem shoot Lee. __________________ WITCH! Oh sorry, got confused by all your crying. ~ Francis

12/09/2012, 07:37 am	#3
CharmingBirch I don't bite :) Join Date: Nov 2012 Location: US Posts: 71	I didn't give Irene the gun. I left the girl on the street because, let's face it, I didn't want the extra attention and Kenny was 100% right in his suggestion. Still don't know what happens when you do shoot her, but I imagine things are a bit more difficult. I shot Duck. I had Clem shoot me, and I didn't hesitate for a minute. I guess I'm in the minority by thinking leaving Lee and/or watching him turn into a walker would be MORE traumatizing than shooting him. She says so many times throughout the game, "Please don't become one of them", that shooting him would at least give her some kind of peace. Especially when you choose "Don't be afraid" as your last words. Just drives the point home to me.

12/09/2012, 08:11 am	#6
QuarterPounderVlad Senior Member Join Date: Sep 2012 Posts: 586	Didn't give Irene the gun, Left the girl (Beatrice, was it?) Shot duck myself, Clem shot Lee.

12/09/2012, 08:33 am	#7
MuffinMansBro Member Join Date: Oct 2012 Posts: 42	Gave Irene the gun Shot Beatrice (I probably would have left her if Kenny didn't make it sound like such an asshole thing to do) Shot Duck myself Clem shot me.

12/09/2012, 08:42 am	#8
Kaserkin Senior Member Join Date: Nov 2012 Posts: 294	Not in my group? Not wasting bullets, sorry.

12/09/2012, 09:21 am	#9
Zeruis Mundy Join Date: Jun 2012 Posts: 1,980	-Didn't give Irene the gun. -Left the woman on the street. -Shot Duck myself. -Told Clem to leave me.

12/09/2012, 09:21 am	#10
ZacTB Woodbury Bound Join Date: May 2012 Posts: 294	I gave Irene the gun, shot the girl in the street, shot Duck and had Clementine shoot Lee. Also I killed the boy in the attic. Always think the nicest thing to do is kill someone who is bitten. Hardest decision to make out of all of those was the girl in the street, actually. Thought putting her out of her misery was a much nicer thing to do.

12/09/2012, 09:39 am	#11
StarvingHobo Junior Member Join Date: Dec 2012 Posts: 4	I tried to play true to what my real life actions would be, but it's hard to do... In real life NO WAY would Irene get the gun, she was so high strung, imagine she just turned psycho like "F*** IT ALL!!!!!" and shot us all before topping herself... Or maybe she'd turn whilst holding the gun and then it might be hard to get back (I forget if anyone else had a gun at the time)... Also I would have probably let myself become a walker rather than getting shot in the head, just on the off chance I somehow managed to survive (fuck knows how, but headshot = NOPE)... I should really do a truthful playthrough next time. Funny 'cause I totally would have made everyone else do the dangerous stuff even bitten. I'd be all "lol you guys walk across the rickety sign I have one arm!"...

12/09/2012, 11:42 am	#14
Robbingrobin Senior Member Join Date: Nov 2012 Location: Somewhere safe Posts: 433	Ghositex is right. __________________ *I am surrounded by Idiots* The fucking game has nothing to do with the fucking TV-Series. When do people get that finally, huh?

12/09/2012, 01:30 pm	#15
Rock114 Senior Member Join Date: Jul 2012 Location: U.S. of A. Posts: 1,780	Gave her the gun Shot the girl Shot Duck Had Clem shoot Lee. The world has enough walkers in it already.

12/10/2012, 03:53 am	#19
Snake Liquid Senior Member Join Date: Sep 2012 Posts: 152	Irene: Didn't give her the gun. This is still one of the early days in the apocalypse. From Lee's perspective, he didn't want people to give up already. He didn't fully understand the infection, and wasn't ready at that point to give someone a gun to end their life. Beatrice: Left her in the street. An awful act, but she was bitten and I had to think about everyone back at the motel. If I shot her, that would instantly draw all the walkers in Macon on me and Kenny while we tried to get supplies. Duck: I shot him. By this point, Lee understands what is going on in the world. They can't just leave the little boy to become a walker, and he wasn't going to make one of the kid's parents do it. Lee: Clementine shot him. Personally, I think it'd be more emotionally devastating for Clem to leave knowing that Lee was going to come back as one of the walkers, especially after just having seen her parents in the street as walkers.

12/11/2012, 07:33 am	#20
Mornai Always Have Hope Join Date: Oct 2012 Location: Ohio, U.S.A. Posts: 1,082	Didn't give Irene the gun. - I wouldn't let her give up... plus it was still early in the apocalypse. I wouldn't change my decision now either. Shot the girl in the street. - Losing morality for survival means one step closer to becoming the next St. Johns/Crawford/Bandits, and i refuse to let that happen. Shot Duck. - No parent should have to kill their own child. Clem shot Lee. - Becoming a walker is a fate worse than death, and one that Lee shouldn't have to go through. The difference in the first and last decisions for me are how it happens. Killing yourself so you won't turn just feels wrong to me...

Thread Tools	Search this Thread
Show Printable Version Email this Page	Search this Thread: Advanced Search

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
GAME FREEZE: Ep 1: Motel with bitten lady	deadpoolware	PC/Mac Support	4	12/23/2012 06:52 pm
***** is bitten and will die. [SPOILERS]	Alanz	The Walking Dead Story Discussion - SPOILERS	34	10/27/2012 12:49 am
What would you do if someone got bitten?	Rasher	The Walking Dead Discussion	36	05/07/2012 04:31 pm