Best/Worst Guybrush Threepwood? (Vote one for Best, one for Worst)

[Catfish33]

Originally Posted by Frogacuda

Escape from Monkey Island gets a reprieve because the design itself (as in the 2D concept art) was quite good and I liked the look. The blocky in-game graphics drag it down, but that's more the fault of the technology of the day.

Personally I would have preferred the same engine from Curse over the one in Escape but that's just me... A part of me even wished the new MI would stay away from 3d, but TTG did great and I couldn't be happier so far.

Voodoo lady's room looks especially spiffy.

[Catfish33]

A lot of you voting for MI2 as best Guybrush are forgetting something: He's not supposed to be a bad azz pirate. He's Guybrush Threepwood, mighty pirate, but not that mighty.....

[tmfm2000]

Originally Posted by Catfish33

A lot of you voting for MI2 as best Guybrush are forgetting something: He's not supposed to be a bad azz pirate. He's Guybrush Threepwood, mighty pirate, but not that mighty.....

I agree
I think alot of people see what they want to see. It's easy to imagine things from a few pixels on a sprite. But if you look at the script, he really is just the same guybrush as in secret, just a few years older and with that attempt on a beard going on.. nobody really takes him seriously anyways. but I still like him

[SubSidal]

Originally Posted by prizna

I wish everyone would stop bashing the new look of Guybrush in SOMI:SE, its not that bad and if everyone keeps on saying the that Guybrush looks crap, they wont bother making any more Special Editions.

It's called criticism... We let them know we don't like his look and they'll do it differently for the next one. Unless they have no listening skills, which I doubt.

[thatdude98]

I think Curse Guybrush was the best. EMI guybrush (while awesome) can't compare to the gangly limbed lovable CMI mighty pirate. TOMI guybrush just looks like they mashed MI2, CMI, EMI together. Still, that's awesome.